3 ms·
You said "Bitcoin works like the coffee example not the bike." after "Now you can't identify your distinct stolen coffee anymore." But you can identify distinc
by rahimnathwani 7y ago
You said "Bitcoin works like the coffee example not the bike." after "Now you can't identify your distinct stolen coffee anymore."
But you can identify distinct stolen/tainted Bitcoin. Just like you can identify distinct stolen banknotes.
The difference (according to the article) is that banknotes have special legal status meaning that they're effectively fungible after being spent.
- pryce 7y agoWe should also carefully distinguish: * Bitcoin proponents desire that bitcoin work like the earlier currency example, where an innocent actor who receives stolen currency at part of some transaction for a good or service is protected from having to return those bitcoin. * Whether an innocent actor in that position is in fact liable or protected in that scenario is fundamentally up to the state(s) involved and their legislative choices. This (as with the centralization of mining, and exchange prominence) seems to be another example where Bitcoin is -in practice- far more subject to the powers of states than its proponents respresent. I postulate that few if any states will see any advantage in granting that kind of protection to bitcoin transactions, as states have incentives to ensure their own currencies can be transacted without rigorous detective work, and do not have these same incentives with bitcoin.
- FDSGSG 7y agoYou seem to be speculating about some future legislation. What about the situation right now? >I postulate that few if any states will see any advantage in granting that kind of protection to bitcoin transactions, as states have incentives to ensure their own currencies can be transacted without rigorous detective work, and do not have these same incentives with bitcoin. Usually these principles apply to all currency, not just the states "own" currency. Why would states need to grant such protection to bitcoin transactions, as opposed to taking away such protection?
- nybble41 7y agoThe real difference is that coffee and banknotes are property, whereas cryptocurrency is an entry in a distributed database. One can "steal" (or at least gain unauthorized access to) a private key, but one cannot "steal" bitcoins. There is no inherent right to have the rest of the Bitcoin network agree that these bitcoins belong to you. Especially not after the authorized owner of the coins (meaning anyone in possession of the private key) has announced to the network that the coins belong to someone else.
- Canada 7y agoOnly after the coffee goes in the big container full of lots of other coffee is it rendered unidentifiable. If the coffee vendor didn't pour the stolen bag of beans into the rest of it then it's still clearly identifiable. Bitcoins are not quite like the a banknote. If I have a $1 and $20 bill that's 2 things each with a serial number. I can give them to you, and you can give them back to me. Bitcoins on the other hand don't work that way. The movement of them changes them, even though you can trace the flow of the value represented. Let's say someone steals your 1 bitcoins, sending 0.999998 bitcoins to himself, leaving 0.000002 bitcoins for the miner who confirms the transaction. Then the thief sends 0.999996 bitcoins to someone totally innocent in exchange for a car, leaving another 200 satoshi for that miner. You find the person who sold that car for those bitcoins and he still controls that balance. Are you entitled to get those bitcoins back? Well, say the car seller had no other bitcoin. One argument would be that he still has 0.999996 of your bitcoins, so he's obligated to give your property back and he needs to figure out how to collect for the car, tough luck for him. The fact that he doesn't have it all is no different than if his car was stolen and he found just missing a couple of hubcaps. Another argument could be that no, your bitcoins were the UTXO that you could solve the unlock script for, which you still can, so it's like the car seller had received an item that your bitcoins were exchanged for (new script). I don't think most people would have much sympathy for this argument. But what if your coins were only 1 input into the transaction sent to the car seller, and then the car seller spent half of on his rent, receiving back the balance to his change address? Now we've arrived at coffee beans. Even though you can know the balances, you cannot say whether your bitcoins are in the possession of the car seller or his landlord. It makes no sense to say that each of them has half, nor does it make any sense to claim that one or the other has your stolen property. So assuming bitcoins do not have the special money status and stolen bitcoins are going to be treated like other stolen property is then they are like the coffee beans in that they become unidentifiable without anyone trying to be dishonest.
- AstralStorm 7y agoHowever as the exchanges are visible it is easy to know the exact amount that has to be returned, therefore theft of such property has a clearly known value (plus damages) as if you kept a precise ledger. Said value thus does not have to be decided in court to be returned - the question is, do you have to return it in cash of choice or Bitcoin? The big question is how you find the responsible ransomer if they used a mixer, and whether mixer is culpable for not following KYC for big transaction amounts.
- FDSGSG 7y ago>But you can identify distinct stolen/tainted Bitcoin. Just like you can identify distinct stolen banknotes. Not at all. You can merge stolen bitcoin with "clean" bitcoin. You can not do that with banknotes. If you give someone two $10 bills those don't magically turn into a $20. That does happen with Bitcoin though.