3 ms·
We have an organ in our office warehouse with 8 ranks of real pipes, and several dozen virtual ranks and it is MIDI controllable. MIDI does a poor job of mappi
by fortran77 7y ago
We have an organ in our office warehouse with 8 ranks of real pipes, and several dozen virtual ranks and it is MIDI controllable. MIDI does a poor job of mapping organs to MIDI messages. There's no good way to control stops (i.e., what stops are selected on which manual/pedal) and couplers without "overloading" a lot of the meta commands. And there's no way of defining which stops (which can be on any manual) are under expression. There's no way to represent a "tutti" stop, etc.
And even for conventional "piano" instruments, which you'd think MIDI would work well for, it's lacking. It doesn't have pedal velocity or position (often the damper pedal is held at some in between position) and it doesn't have key position. Advanced "player" systems, like the Bosendorfer SE or Disklavier Pro overload other MIDI messages to account for this. Anyone who plays a real piano will see MIDI's problems.
At the very least, every keyboard instrument like Organs and Pianos should be 100% controllable from MIDI.
- 6581 7y ago> It doesn't have pedal velocity or position (often the damper pedal is held at some in between position) It does have pedal position. Pedal data is transmitted as a control change message (e.g. CC#64 for damper) with a 7-bit data value. Many recent digital pianos support half-pedalling including transmitting and receiving the pedal position via MIDI.
- scarecrowbob 7y agoIndeed, this is true. I've often been super frustrated by things that receive MIDI: they don't expose certain controls to CC, or they don't respond to multiple channels, or they don;'t pass certain information to the Thru port. But often what is frustrating is that it's do-able in MIDI, it just wasn't implemented well on the device.
- scarecrowbob 7y agoThat's super cool that you have access to a pipe organ. I spent a lot of time in my youth building a pipe organ with my dad and the church we went to. They are amazing instruments. I'm having a hard time understanding how you'd have a hard time implementing an organ control setup over MIDI. Like I get that there there is no specific tutti setting, but why couldn't you just have all the ranks be CC channels and then have the various settings be program numbers, so tutti then is jsut calling up the program with all the stops open? I do play a real piano, and I haven't been seeing problems with MIDI in the time I've been using it. Like, I've seen a lot of issues with piano synthesizer/sampler implementations... but the basic interface of the piano seems (at least to me) fairly easy to represent in MIDI... Can you help me out by describing what kinds of problems you're seeing? Like I say, could just be my own lack of experience, but you've bade me curious what I'm possibly missing.
- nitrogen 7y agoI'm not the OP and I've had the bad habit of living in small urban apartments with no room for a MIDI-enabled acoustic piano, but one problem is resolution. 127 velocity levels can't really cover the detailed expression of playing an acoustic piano, and something like a glissando or a ten-fingered rolled chord might not have enough time resolution to sound right. I believe there are messages that add another 7 bits to velocity, and aftertouch can represent key position, but I haven't used a MIDI-enabled acoustic myself to know if those are adequate.
- fortran77 7y agoKey position is important if you want to keep some individual keys depressed (or partially depressed) in order to keep the damper up. Or if you want to release a key/keys slowly for damper effects. This is different from velocity. Also, support for Sostenuto pedal (i.e., the "middle" pedal) is spotty and frequently doesn't get captured or preserved on MIDI piano controllers and sequencers even if a MIDI'd piano records it.
- nitrogen 7y agoFor sure. I made sure that the digital piano I bought had continuous pedal and realistic key release. Still really want a player acoustic some day though.