11 ms·
>"Hundreds of cities and dozens of countries, fine for living but previously entirely unsuitable for a place of business, will blink from red to green on the ma
by Barrin92 7y ago
>"Hundreds of cities and dozens of countries, fine for living but previously entirely unsuitable for a place of business, will blink from red to green on the map once Starlink goes live."
this reads like a marketing piece rather than actual analysis. Throughput of a single satellite is 20Gbps. The finished constellation if I recall correctly is supposed to be about 12k satellites. So about ~250.000Gbps. So assuming you offer everyone a 100MB/s connection, that's... one city? And that doesn't account for transmission between the satellites or satellites not in range and so on, and the fact that those satellites are short-lived and need to be replaced.
How is this supposed to be economical or scale compared to regular terrestrial networks?
And one point on the social impact. We have heard this idea that you just need to 'connect people' over the internet to somehow give every disadvantaged place economic opportunity for decades now. This isn't how the real world works. Everyone still runs to California/their national equivalent You can count the areas where the VC money goes on one hand. Putting a satellite in the sky over Siberia isn't going to upend the social realities of geography.
- Dunedan 7y agoIt's a shared medium, as is internet via cable. The 100MB/s or whatever they'll offer will be the peak throughput you can achieve. Aside from that they already have plans to send up 30.000 more satellites [1] and of course future satellites might also have a significantly higher throughput. [1]: https://spacenews.com/spacex-submits-paperwork-for-30000-more-starlink-satellites/ https://spacenews.com/spacex-submits-paperwork-for-30000-mor...
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoYou can do a lot of business with much less bandwidth than that. Isn’t this more about getting them ability to send emails and read text and information and not things like livestream?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- grahamburger 7y agoThat's true for dedicated circuits but no residential or even small business Internet plans are dedicated. You can put at least 200 customers on a 1 gigabit connection and they'll still get 100 Mbps+ speedtests even during peak usage times of the day.
- Jamwinner 7y agoMy ISP seems to share your optimism, but I fear it must be grossly overprovisioned, or they have no intention of providing the agreed upon and advertised speeds.
- grahamburger 7y agoProbably they're overselling at a much worse ratio than I described, or there are other problems in their infrastructure causing poor performance (likely both). It's not at all uncommon for ISPs to put even like 10,000 customers on a 10gbps line. 10 years ago that actually would have been fine, but bandwidth usage per customer has increased since then and naturally ISPs don't upgrade fast enough.
- big_chungus 7y agoI've been on connections where the ISP (AT&T) tried this due to an ancient backhaul where it grossly over-committed on bandwidth. The neighbors would have kids home after school streaming three netflix 4k streams, and we would watch our speeds tank. Some bizarre QOS config seemed to prioritize their connection over ours. It ticked me off enough I almost started deauthing their devices because I couldn't load a simple web page. On the other hand, we finally got FTTH and it's great. So nice to have good speeds.
- EpicEng 7y ago>So assuming you offer everyone a 100MB/s connection... It's ridiculous to assume that everyone will be using 100MB/s at all times.
- ac29 7y agoEven at 100-1000x oversubscription, this doesn't seem like a solution for the "half of humanity" that the article claims this will affect (~3.9B people as of today). I certainly find Starlink interesting, but I think its impact will be a lot smaller than the author does.
- randyrand 7y agoI think he meant 100 Mb/s, which is much more reasonable but still pretty high for a single person. The average bitrate of a youtube video is about 6mbps. An average constant bitrate per person in the evenings is perhaps around 10 Mb/s. So 25 million people could use this assuming 100% satellite use.
- Retric 7y agoThey have approval for up to 42,000 satellites, most internet connections are shared at homes and businesses, and broadband is over subscribed anyway. One way to look at it is up to 42 million 4k streams at the same time. But, a significant fraction of the constellation will be over the ocean or other minimally inhabited regions so something like 25% of total bandwidth is likely utilized at any one time. However, that’s spread around the globe with some areas like Hawaii having much better than average available bandwidth.
- cmarschner 7y agoWhat entity give them this approval? Isn‘t airspace over countries to be approved by these countries? Did countries opt out?
- njarboe 7y agoI don't think there is a treaty about it. These satellites are in space, not in the air. Around 100km usually is used as the boundary or, more practically, as high as your anti-aircraft missiles can go. It does not really make sense to claim everything up in a cone from your country to infinity. Multiple countries claiming different planets at different times would be weird. SpaceX got approval to launch these satellites from the FCC.
- unnouinceput 7y agoWasn't some time ago a Chinese satellite blown from their orbit by a missile? I think current technology allows you to blow stuff up from sky quite more then just 100 Km.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- garaetjjte 7y agoSovereignty doesn't extend to space. It is one of points of Outer Space Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty Some countries attempted to claim sovereignty over geostationary orbit, but failed http://djilp.org/the-bogota-declaration-and-the-curious-case-of-geostationary-orbit/ http://djilp.org/the-bogota-declaration-and-the-curious-case...
- sneak 7y agoDo you think California would be prosperous without connectivity? It’s not 100% of it, but it is absolutely an essential prerequisite. Slow or no internet makes places a nonstarter. Having a fallback option to a single national telco lets lots of places start the long process of building an information economy that they cannot begin at all without it.
- Barrin92 7y agoit's a prerequisite sure I don't disagree. But it's actually funny in how many ways California is mismanaged, from lack of public transport to infrastructure to rent cost and tax burden and silly regulations and still people run there. The human network-effect is insanely substantial. If you were to do napkin math on which cities have the best internet speeds and the lowest cost of doing business, and the best regulations then probably we'd all have moved to Estonia by now, but people are still more likely to go to Israel, a place in the middle of a warzone. So for that reason, I find hyping technology up as the great equalizer very cynical. It's mostly still people and culture at the end of the day.
- sudhirj 7y agoThe human network effect is substantial, but constantly decreasing with increasing connectivity. It’s getting easier and easier to get the same benefits online without much of the downsides. If people can fall in love online, they can certainly collaborate without having to smell each other.
- twunde 7y agoRegarding the social impact, while likely overstated it has the possibility of making a real impact. Rural communities in upstate NY (Catskills, Adirondacks) have had their tourist season drop to ~6 weeks in the summer, basically because people can't take so much time off while being out of contact (there is limited internet and cell phone service. Not having either is the norm). Being able to work remotely from those types of locations will extend that tourist season and help the local economies there. For some areas, this may be enough to move the economy from depressed to prosperous.
- midnightclubbed 7y agoWhat is stopping cell providers from adding more towers/capacity to that area? Are there geographic reasons or just a matter of time and economics?
- zaroth 7y agoI would assume that cell towers will absolutely love Starlink as a backhaul. Think how much easier it gets to stand up a tower when all you need is electricity on-site.
- TylerE 7y agoLots of nimbyism, for a start.
- SteveGerencser 7y agoOut here it is purely economics and population density. I live in West TN and the nearest cell phone tower is 7 miles in a straight line from my house. There is one provider that works here, and a good signal is 2 bards, but usually, 1 is normal and things like 4g or LTE rarely work. I offered $1/yr lease to the providers, all of them, to put a tower on my farm and not one of them is even a little interested.
- 14 7y agoI am willing to bet that changes once Starlink is within the finish line. My dad talks of a small town here in Canada that refused to upgrade the towers and when a private citizen started applying to create his own company magically it was suddenly economic for Telus to put up a tower. I know that I feel ripped off every single day by what we pay for mobile data compared to the rest of the world. If Starlink suddenly shows up there is an alternative to Bell Rogers Telus. They should be shaking in their boots. It should be easy for Starlink to undercut their business because they made a business out of customer gouging.
- fragmede 7y agoThere are scant details about what the launched product will look like in practice, but keep in mind that urban and suburban areas are spoiled by high-speed 4G LTE and wired gigabit. The vast majority of the US, by land area, has to chose from dial-up and very expensive pre-Starlink satelite Internet service. Even 1 Mbit is a huge improvement over 56 kbps. I'm haven't looked into the economics of running fiber everywhere, as compared to launching an extensive constellation of satellites but I will note that SpaceX has the competitive advantage of having at-cost access to reusable rockets, compared to an outside party paying SpaceX market rates for transit to space.
- swiley 7y agoThe pre-starlink stuff isn’t just expensive. It’s slow, has crazy high latency, and low transfer caps (the biggest you can get for geosynchronous might be 20GB a month no matter how much you want to pay.) Really anything is better than what’s currently available in the rural US. Having grown up there I’m kind of mad that we give so much spectrum to cell companies who block people from setting up terrestrial radio networks in places like this.
- shaklee3 7y agoThat's completely false. Several providers have over 100GB/mo plans.
- baq 7y agoLatency is completely true. Can’t be otherwise because speed of light is a thing.
- shaklee3 7y agoThe latency part is true, but the cap is not: https://www.satelliteinternet.com/resources/unlimited-satellite-internet/ https://www.satelliteinternet.com/resources/unlimited-satell... We can argue about whether latency matters for most people, but it's not going to go anywhere.
- cambalache 7y agoThat is correct, as someone looking for a remote job opportunity, 95+% of the "remote" job posts are still restringed to residents of specific countries/zones. Having good connectivity or being in the same time-zone matter very little.
- sneak 7y agoI solved this by incorporating a company (b2b consulting) and spending time periodically in the cities my clients live/work in. Work onsite for a couple weeks, then go home and finish the project. If you’re remote, they shouldn’t care where you are. It’s just a sales issue, then, and can be overcome like any other sales objection.
- skissane 7y ago> If you’re remote, they shouldn’t care where you are It depends on whether you are an employee or contractor. For a contractor, it mostly shouldn't matter. (Some countries, especially countries with which the HQ country has difficult relations, may represent unacceptable risk even for a contractor.) With an employee, the employer has to be registered to pay tax in the country; they need to familiarise themselves with the labour laws of the country to ensure they comply with them; they may need to make various arrangements with respect to benefits (insurance, retirement, etc); usually to do all this they need to have a legal entity set up in the country, which in turn also needs things like local bank accounts, directors appointed, accounting and auditing contracts, etc. For the first employee in a country, that can be a lot of overhead. If some manager wants to hire some random person in country X where there are currently no employees, it probably isn't worth it unless they plan to hire more people in country X, or that person is someone very special. A workaround some places use is contract with some sort of agency who acts as the employee's legal employer and handles all those local legal/tax/benefits/etc issues. However, that adds overhead costs, and if a firm doesn't already have a relationship with such an agency, they probably aren't going to start one just because some manager wants to hire somebody in a country in which there is no legal entity.
- CydeWeys 7y agoSomething is off with your analysis. At any given time, the vast majority of the people in a given city aren't all using 100 Mbps 24/7/365. For instance, my typical monthly mobile data consumption is around 4 GB, which is .0015 MB/s -- a far cry from 100!
- fao_ 7y agoCan you share what has led you to believe that you're the average rather than just an outlier?
- CydeWeys 7y agoFor the average bandwidth usage of a city to be 100 MB/s per user, the average monthly total per user would have to be 263,974 GB. Obviously the real figure is much, much less than that.
- fao_ 7y agoSure not everyone is always going to be using it at the same time, but streaming times are going to be around the same because most people will clock off at around the same time, and new technology such as Google Stadia, the introduction of 4k streaming, etc. mean that it's very likely that people will start needing more bandwidth soon, no? Also the target audience of this, the people that will be able to afford it, are going to be highly paid people (assumption: it's going be charged higher than 30£/month, or even £60/mo) who will be more likely to do those sorts of activities due to having more free time.
- fao_ 7y agolol at getting downvoted by asking for evidence that a highly paid technology worker who browses hacker news represents "the average" and isn't just an outlier. Do the people on this site understand that they are not the average? A lot of the hackernewses seem to enjoy the idea of being an outlier in medicine, knowledge, etc. but reject the rather more likely idea that they're an outlier with regards to their usage of technology and internet.
- stephen_g 7y agoI'm also interested to see what kind of throughput they can achieve with a 'briefcase sized' terminal. Our company makes satellite terminals for military, and from that experience I can't really see the physics working for hundreds of Mbps with some type of panel antenna (phased array, etc.) that small at any kind of decent spectral/power efficiency...
- greglindahl 7y agoAll LEO internet providers have said they expect to use phased array antennae, which are not yet available at a consumer-friendly price.
- scrumbledober 7y agoLast i heard they were definitely planning on phased array antennae
- eqvinox 7y agoOn one hand, as other sibling posts are pointing out, you're comparing true network capacity with subscribed ("sold") capacity; those are massively different by orders of magnitude (depending on how shitty your ISP is.) On the other hand, it's far worse than "20G per satellite." Bandwidth is limited by available RF spectrum, and that's not magically gonna increase with satellite count. Best thing they can try is limit the coverage area of each radio as much as possible, but there's limits to that and now you have an onslaught of handovers since the satellites are moving quite fast. I honestly am too lazy to do the math, but my gut says this may work great for larger areas with lower population density (let's say the Amazon, U.S. Midwest, Australia, Sibiria, etc.) but it's not gonna replace high-density broadband access. Also, just for comparison, current optical network technology (in the market, not research) puts 50G on a single wavelength on an optical fiber. There's 80 wavelengths in a medium-density DWDM setup, so that's 4T ... on a single strand. A low-density cable has 12 cores (that's what you deploy on the outskirts of your network), so, uh, 48 terabit/s with current technology. Infrastructure cables are commonly 144 cores, that's 576 terabit/s... (These are obviously "maximum" numbers, you rarely see all 80 wavelengths or all 144 strands in use, and there's gonna be slower links like 10G occupying some wavelengths too.)
- Hikikomori 7y agoProducts for 200G on 50Ghz channels (up to 96) have been available for some time now, so you can up your numbers quite a bit.
- virtuallynathan 7y agoYep, you can now get 4700 fibers or so in a 2in conduit. Current tech can do over 35Tbps per fiber pair, up to 800Gbps per wavelength.
- Robotbeat 7y ago> "On the other hand, it's far worse than "20G per satellite." Bandwidth is limited by available RF spectrum, and that's not magically gonna increase with satellite count." That's not true. More satellites allows you to put them in lower orbits, increasing spatial multiplexing. Yes, even for the same spectrum. This is not like mobile where the phones have fairly omnidirectional antenna (improving to a handful of elements under 5G). The user terminals will have dozens if not hundreds or thousands of phased array elements, allowing connections to multiple satellites simultaneously and very narrow beamwidths. The satellites also have phased arrays with lots of elements. I agree that dense cities and optical fiber will still be able to beat out Starlink (and similar), but there is PLENTY of room for using the same amount of RF spectrum for vastly greater bandwidth using spatial multiplexing and phased arrays on both ends and multiple, cooperating satellites in view simultaneously.
- kbenson 7y agoNo ISP actually allocates enough upstream and peering connections for every customer to use their connections at full speed at the same time, just as no cellphone provider build their network out so every customer can be on the phone at the same time. In both setups, there are multiple levels of bottlenecks. The bottom line is that a properly configured network makes sure they can cover their usual peak usage easily, and has enough spare capacity that special events don't impact much of the customer base, and those it impact it doesn't do so much. Consider that ISPs that offer gigabit speeds can't easily put in individual (or even paired) networking equipment that can serve thousands of people at that speed, because such equipment doesn't exist or is far too expensive to be using all over the place in the network. What you really see is that 100 people on gigabit circuits during peak usage (likely Netflix prime time in the evening) will use less than even a fiftieth or h undredth of their allocated capacity (unless you're steaming 4k all the time, and then you'll probably use about a fortieth of a gigabit sustained). As usage goes up, ISPs allocate more resources and shift traffic around to make sure they can supply for the demand. If done well, you don't ever notice. You can also see this in highways and freeways. No highway is build to serve all the possible people that could use it at the same time, it's built to service what the number of people expected to use it in a specific time period is. This is also a good idea of what it's like when planning fails, as these works require a long lead time and a lot of accurate forecasting that's hard, so you often see vastly under-provisioned systems, and even by the time they upgrade them, they are sometimes already under-provisioned at the new size (or the time until it's under-provisioned is relatively short).
- danielheath 7y agoThey don't have to serve the whole city to generate a benefit - they just have to offer competition so that the incumbents can't abuse their monopoly position. Because they can reallocate satellite time to a new region quite cheaply, they could have approximately zero customers while forcing ISPs around the globe to behave sensibly.
- chameleon_world 7y agoContrary to what Musk & co's claims it doesn't look like this will help the people/countries who actually need access, at least not with the prices that they are saying they will charge. Someone scatter-plotted the GDP of countries and internet penetration, and it turns out none of the countries who need access can afford starlink internet. (There are many other similar calculations out there on the interwebs). https://twitter.com/chmn_victor/status/1219721896075366403 https://twitter.com/chmn_victor/status/1219721896075366403 Most likely this is mainly to be used by bankers and computer stock traders to buy and sell stocks even faster over the ocean.
- rictic 7y agoDoesn't it also depend on how wealthy your neighbors are? For an extreme example, an area with extremely low population (like the middle of the ocean), the bandwidth (at least surface to satellite bandwidth) will be wasted if no one is using it. The price could be much lower. A poor community in a rich and population dense area probably would be priced out. Will be interesting to see how it shakes out in practice. I could see it go both ways honestly.
- Veedrac 7y agoStarlink will sell at pretty much whatever price it needs to, since serving data has effectively no marginal cost. The only unavoidable one is the ($300) base station, but people can share.
- estsauver 7y agoI may be biased as the CTO of a company that connects rural, small subsaharan African farmers with financing, but the role out of cell infrastructure has definitely changed the world in a good chunk of rural Kenya at least.
- sgt101 7y agoYeah. In the UK 12m connections are serviced with 80000 points of presence to provide consumer grade internet. This will be niche...
- ryanmercer 7y ago>How is this supposed to be economical or scale compared to regular terrestrial networks? I don't think it is. People think they're going to get unlimited data, gigabit connection, etc etc and I think they're all highly delusional. Starlink is not meant to replace wired internet, it's meant to give HughesNet customers something that is actually usable. It's meant to give people in remote areas with no wired connection available something that actually allows them to meaningfully interact with the internet. Realistically I see it like this: I think the bulk of the customers will always be companies working in remote areas such as ships, oil rigs, mining operations, gas stations primarily serving semi trucks in rural areas along highways etc. Also, first responder agencies as it will be handy in grid-down natural disasters for command centers. Then you'll have RV parks, camp sites, rest stops, EV charging locations in remote areas, etc reselling access by subscription or in time increments. Then you'll have folks that just live in rural areas that want something better than HughesNet and possibly THOW/vanlife folks that work remotely and move frequently. Then you'll have low-profit/served-at-cost customers that will be schools in developing nations, especially in rural areas.
- Robotbeat 7y agoThe throughput per satellite is not fixed. The constellation is designed to be refreshed and upgraded (more beams, more phased array elements, better back-end) about every 4-5 years. Geosynchronous satellites can have up to 1 terabit per satellite (and increasing). The size of the constellation may eventually be up to 40,000 satellites, many at an even lower altitude which increases gain in each direction. So on the order of 40Petabit/s throughput is doable in the medium-term. And of course, people don't use 100MB/s constantly. The ratio is not uncommonly 1:100 in max vs average throughput, and this ratio is higher the greater the max bandwidth (average used throughput increases sub-linearly with max throughput). So say about 1Mbps average per user with 40Pbps constellation-wide, and you're looking at on the order of billions of connections possible at the largest scale. Still about 12Pbps possible at 12000 satellites. Enough for billions of connections still. Even at 20Gbps and 12,000 satellites and 1Mbps average usage per connection, that's still on the order of a hundred million connections. More likely, they'll have fewer-than-billions of connections with more available average bandwidth than 1Mbps. But it definitely is a gamechanger in rural internet capability.
- sheepybloke 7y agoI agree with the social impact point. The wording reminds me a lot of what Zuckerburg's mission for Facebook was for the longest time: connect people and everything will be great. I think this is amazing and definitely going to change the world, but we in the tech world need to curb our hubris because it's bitten us before, and if unchecked, it will bit us again.
- ghostpepper 7y agoThis was my reaction as well. It seems that looming existential threat the tech industry is currently grappling with is a direct result of the laissez-faire idealism of the early internet pioneers. Obviously the internet is a net-benefit to the human race but we really should learn from our previous mistakes. I'm not sure what the solution is but we shouldn't pretend that there won't be some criminals and terrorists among the ~3Bn people who suddenly find themselves connected.
- travisporter 7y agoYeah the social impact will probably be just streaming movies and shopping. I wonder if tracking down some malicious attacker will be much harder without the need for wires, although probably not too different