3 ms·
Blaming the problem on "people" is also missing a large part of the problem. The breadth of the crisis meant that it affected a lot of people who had never hear
by jfengel 7y ago
Blaming the problem on "people" is also missing a large part of the problem. The breadth of the crisis meant that it affected a lot of people who had never heard of CDOs, and never should have. People lost their jobs in totally unrelated fields. Companies couldn't grow because credit dried up while the mess was sorted out. People couldn't sell their houses because the entire market crashed. And so on.
Of the people who did know about CDOs, many should have understood them, because they were playing around with sums large enough to affect the economy as a whole. They didn't through a combination of inertia and fraud.
There were systemic effects, where a whole lot of people were making apparently sensible local decisions and nobody understood the entire interaction -- but that's not really a good justification for shrugging shoulders and say, "Well, I guess it's everybody's fault, then".
People should be able to make the "assumption" that they'll be able to work in a functioning economy, without having to become experts in complex financial instruments. If the financial industry can't leave them to make that assumption, they'll vote for a government that will enforce it -- probably clumsily. If the system requires everybody to understand a financial network that most of them can't, they'll forbid it, which isn't good for the economy but is more acceptable to a lot of people than being told that the financial crash was their fault.
- darawk 7y ago> Blaming the problem on "people" is also missing a large part of the problem. The breadth of the crisis meant that it affected a lot of people who had never heard of CDOs, and never should have. People lost their jobs in totally unrelated fields. Companies couldn't grow because credit dried up while the mess was sorted out. People couldn't sell their houses because the entire market crashed. And so on. Sure, but i'm not sure what this has to do with my point. Should we ban internet stocks because the market was irrational in 2000? > There were systemic effects, where a whole lot of people were making apparently sensible local decisions and nobody understood the entire interaction -- but that's not really a good justification for shrugging shoulders and say, "Well, I guess it's everybody's fault, then". Ok, but how does that cash out in any kind of coherent policy recommendation?