3 ms·
The converse scenario is also bad. Imagine an organized government subversion cell that is willing to harm civilians to further its objectives and is skilled at
by shadowgovt 7y ago
The converse scenario is also bad. Imagine an organized government subversion cell that is willing to harm civilians to further its objectives and is skilled at hiding in public (one doesn't have to try very hard given the nature of asymmetric warfare in the 21st century). Surely, we want the ability to locate their members as efficiently as possible?
Considering the dystopia 1984 predicted is a good idea, but one should also consider the failure mode of "Snow Crash" anarchic dystopia, where sufficiently-organized individuals use modern technology to harm innocent people and government cannot stop them. The mafia stories in the US stem from the era where city organized crime had firepower that out-gunned the police.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoWhatever tools implemented need to avoid creating (terrorists/freedom fighters depending on your viewpoint). At least in the US, we're taught a culture that lauds those who fought against tryranny. If the government loses perceived legitimacy(say by suppressing the expression of first amendment rights to free speech) then there would likely be an increase in militias and home-grown terrorism.
- birracerveza 7y agoHonestly, I'd rather not want that ability than risk a never-ending unescapable 1984 dystopia.
- shadowgovt 7y agoNeither of these scenarios are de-facto inescapable. And if we're talking avoidance of technologies because of risk: historical scholars point to the message-consolidating effects of radio and television as a technology that enabled the rise of fascism in Europe between WWI and WWII (Orwell alludes directly to this with the hate rallies in front of Big Brother's TV image). Should we ban TV?
- snarf21 7y agoNo, I want locating those members to be hard. I understand human nature and we know that no one will watch the watchers. There are lots of avenues for tracking these groups but it requires real work. You have to infiltrate and investigate. You are also missing something. It is really about civilians being harmed? How many people died last year from terrorism in the US or the UK? How many died because people were texting and driving? Or drunk driving? Should we track when you text and drive the same way? Should we have police sit outside of every bar testing people to prevent harm? I think we all prefer to have the presumption of innocence and to face consequences for our mistakes and crimes, not to be tracked in case we do.
- shadowgovt 7y agoI think the UK is providing a very useful example of how one watches the watchers. The government is accountable via elections and their power seems held in check pretty well. > I want locating those members to be hard I respect your opinion, but the people who have lost loved ones to "random" attacks don't generally share that view. Hell, part of the purpose of building a society and a government is to minimize that kind of personal violence against people.
- snarf21 7y agoI understand what you are saying but are the people who lost loved ones to drunk driving or text driving any more understanding? You could argue it is even more senseless violence. We could easily make car connected breathalyzers mandatory in all cars. This would save 10K lives in the US alone. Are those thousands of lives not worth it in your mind? I agree that government has a role in protecting people. We are both free to vote for representatives that are either for spying on citizens or against spying on citizens. We can also move if the other side wins.
- shadowgovt 7y agoAre we arguing financial cost or privacy cost? I personally think the financial burden of retrofitting all US cars with breathalyzers is burdensome. If they already had such equipment, I'd 100% be in favor of gating starting the car on their use, especially if it was a completely passive, foolproof system. You're right on the number of deaths to drunk driving in the US; it's atrocious. This wouldn't even be the first time in US history a policy change to improve safety and corresponding enforcement occurred; seatbelt laws exist, and enforcement of such laws allows the police to glance in your window to see if you're wearing one and fine you if you aren't. We aren't too far away from cars refusing to be driven if the seatbelt is unclipped. To swing us back around from this analogous hypothetical to the UK's situation: the cameras are already sunk cost and the question on the table is to improve their utility via software. We aren't talking installing breathalyzers; we're talking about upgrading the existing breathalyzers' firmware to work better at the task they were intended for, so to speak. We can argue whether the software will technically work (separate question, and I'm not in favor of installing something that just doesn't work), but if it does work I'm in favor of passive mass surveillance of public spaces to find persons of interest. It bothers basically nobody and greatly improves the utility of a system that is already installed for the purpose of aiding in stopping crime.
- zzzcpan 7y ago> Imagine an organized government subversion cell that is willing to harm civilians to further its objectives and is skilled at hiding in public (one doesn't have to try very hard given the nature of asymmetric warfare in the 21st century). That cell harming people you want to imagine would be some other government agency acting as part of a covert operation after a long time of planning and preparation, with plenty of spies deep in the government. And they don't actually harm people all that much, not the point, they do just a few acts of terror with a few deaths for war propaganda. But once they are caught on surveillance it's already too late, it means they are ready to approach the head of police and start using serious military weapons, and plenty of people are already on the wrong side of war propaganda. > where sufficiently-organized individuals use modern technology to harm innocent people and government cannot stop them Such things don't really happen anymore, governments are too authoritarian already and really like their monopoly on harming people. The only way sufficiently-organized people can coexist with the government is for them to subvert law enforcement or to originate from law enforcement. Governments can deal with either case by replacing everyone or by letting them have their corruption in exchange for being loyal to the government. Basically surveillance is not the tool for anything you talk about, it's role is the exact opposite: to keep people from disobeying the government, the ruling class, the whole systems, no matter how much harm they do to the people.