2 ms·
The limit is practical, not legal. (IANAL). In practice, the law is not trying to 'get' people who innocently receive stolen money or goods. In the example you
by samatman 7y ago
The limit is practical, not legal. (IANAL).
In practice, the law is not trying to 'get' people who innocently receive stolen money or goods. In the example you gave, it would be up to prosecutorial discretion what to do; trying to claw back one salary's worth of already-spent money is probably not worthwhile.
But if someone shows up and tries to deposit a couple grand worth of marked bills, they can expect to be taken into a police station for questioning, and should fully cooperate: this makes it unlikely that the penalty will extend further than confiscation of the stolen cash.
The important thing to realize is: if any of this goes to trial, the prosecution only needs to prove that the money is stolen. It doesn't need to prove the receiver knew it was stolen; that's not what the crime is here, that knowledge makes it a worse crime, accessory to robbery.
- samatman 7y agoApparently the actual answer (I did say I'm not a lawyer!) is "it depends". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Possession_of_stolen_goods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Possession_of_stolen_goods The state-level standard appears to vary, the most common case is 'should have known', rather than 'knew for a fact'. With Bitcoin, where all transactions are a matter of public record, I'd hazard that 'should have known' is baked-in. It will be interesting to see what case law is established in this arena. That said, my statement above is clearly stronger than reality, except in some states where knowledge doesn't need to be proven.
- MockObject 7y ago> With Bitcoin, where all transactions are a matter of public record, I'd hazard that 'should have known' is baked-in. Who should have known what? After receiving any bitcoin (can't be before!) everyone is obliged to figure out if the coin came from a ransomware attack? How? And what do they do if some of the coin was so tainted?
- protanopia 7y agoThe transactions are public but the reasons for them are not. Usually ransomware victims don't publicize the fact that they were attacked. Even if they do, they additionally don't publish in which transaction they transferred the ransom. There isn't a practical to determine whether a specific transaction that a wallet received was from ransomware.
- shkkmo 7y agoI believe that if you can show that you were not involved in and had no reason to be aware of the criminal act, you are under no obligation to return the money. This is different than recieving other types of stolen goods that haven't been given this special legal status, which ensures that money is fungible and can be accepted with relatively little concern by honest people.