4 ms·
Well, that in my eyes is a very solid advertising in favour of ProtonMail. And it's not like Russians, Chinese and generally people in countries whose governme
by pdimitar 7y ago
Well, that in my eyes is a very solid advertising in favour of ProtonMail.
And it's not like Russians, Chinese and generally people in countries whose governments are in the habit of censoring the internet aren't used to using Tor and/or VPNs to dodge censorship.
- x12kk1w 7y ago> Well, that in my eyes is a very solid advertising in favour of ProtonMail. If you live in Russia, yes. Protonmails's headquarters were in SF and some of their infra in Lithuania last time I looked. Remember Crypto AG...
- Jerry2 7y ago> Well, that in my eyes is a very solid advertising in favour of ProtonMail. ... if you live in Russia.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted: just because ProtonMail allegedly refused to cooperate with Russia, it doesn't mean they must act similarly when the request comes from a nation that can leverege more diplomatic pressure.
- aksll 7y agoProtonmail threads on HN are always highly censored.
- thinkloop 7y agoYes, but if Russia can't crack it, and needs to go the diplomatic route, that's a good attribute for your privacy software to have regardless of where you live.
- C14L 7y agoThey are in Switzerland and Swiss judges are pretty independent.
- ymolodtsov 7y agoThe thing is, it’s different from, let’s say, them blocking LinkedIn. VPN won’t solve for any Russian mail service.
- 45ure 7y ago>Well, that in my eyes is a very solid advertising in favour of ProtonMail. In context of 5/9/14+ eyes, the nomenclature of solid advertising might differ from your interpretation, where perceptions matter ─ ranging from honeypots, compromised Tor exit nodes to dubious VPN providers, absence of warrant canaries to flawed encryption products etc. It is probably best to exercise caution and remain sceptical, rather than start endorsing products, based solely on a single random event.
- pdimitar 7y agoWe all work with incomplete information and we have to deal with that every day. Your comment to me reads like "you can be killed by a micro-meteorite if you go out so stay in an underground bunker". Of course there are flawed VPNs and honeypot Tor nodes out there. The fight to track people and censor information is ongoing 24/7 around the globe. Random event or not, if a government feels that it has to plug a leak as opposed to pwning/backdooring it then to me this means they chose the lesser evil and they really cannot crack ProtonMail. If that's indeed the case then this sends the message to me that I'd like my email to be better protected and I might switch away from GMail. Whether there is a bigger game involved though, I can't know. Can you?
- 45ure 7y ago>if a government feels that it has to plug a leak instead of pwn it then to me this means they chose the lesser evil and they really cannot crack ProtonMail. The government does not need to tell you anything and when it says it can't 'break' something, try and remember ─ you can dance like nobody is watching, but make sure you encrypt like everybody is watching.
- C14L 7y agoThere is ProtonVPN. Proton is based on Switzerland, so no N eyes interference there. At least not via a legal route.
- beatgammit 7y agoYou still have to worry about Swiss intelligence. That being said, ProtonMail is a fine product and I'm happy to be a customer.
- kome 7y agoTelegram is blocked in Russia, but WhatsApp still works. Why?
- anticensor 7y agoThey lack the necessary computational power to look at the messages and store them in plain text.
- floatboth 7y agoIt's way too popular, too many people would get angry. Telegram was just the right size — not so tiny that only a few nerds use it, but not so big that the majority of normies have adopted it. And there was sort of a personal conflict, government people don't like Pavel Durov..
- orthoxerox 7y agoTelegram still works as well. It's technically banned, but works thanks to its blocking countermeasures.
- Nasreddin_Hodja 7y ago> It's technically banned, but works thanks to its blocking countermeasures. Mobile version only. You have to use proxy or VPN for desktop or web app.
- another_kel 7y agoYou have to use vpn to access the website which contains the web version but only desktop installer. The app itself works just fine. Futhermore it can be downloaded from W10 or OSX app store with the only limitation being lack of autostart.
- demosito666 7y agoTelegram works just fine and is only becoming more popular.
- d0mine 7y agoI would be very surprised if certain agencies wouldn't have a nice search box for any content on ProtonMail (as it is for Gmail, etc if we believe Snowden). Remember Lavabit.
- joering2 7y agoThe difference was that number one Lavabit was made by a US citizen, and its servers were in the USA. Number two, Lavabit kept all keys to your email at their own premises and could de-crypt your email on their side. Protonmail cannot do so, because your password is a part of they key to decrypt email, and they do not know it, nor they can crack it in a reasonable amount of time, so AFAIK there is nothing they can provide LE with to decrypt your email on the go.
- antpls 7y ago> Protonmail cannot do so, because your password is a part of they key to decrypt email, and they do not know it, nor they can crack it in a reasonable amount of time, so AFAIK there is nothing they can provide LE with to decrypt your email on the go. I don't think this is true. A hash of the password could be part of the key, but Protonmail already has that hash stored on its server (otherwise they would not be able to log you in when you send the password hash). If Protonmail would like to access your emails (or be asked to do so), I'm confident that they technically can. The only benefit is when a hacker get access to the email database, but not the password hash database, then in this case the hacker cannot read the emails.
- Koshkin 7y ago> A hash of the password could be part of the key Except when it's not (and the full password is used instead).
- antpls 7y agoAfter looking at the doc, it seems Protonmail uses GPG and computes the keys on the client device. (So I was wrong in my reply earlier). However, when you send an unencrypted email with Protonmail, they claim that they encrypt the email at rest, but the claim is not verifiable.