8 ms·
> real work is typically file-centric What is this silly ‘real work’ gate-keeping? I guess the author means their work. My fitness instructor uses an iPad to
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> real work is typically file-centric
What is this silly ‘real work’ gate-keeping? I guess the author means their work.
My fitness instructor uses an iPad to refer to fitness plans. He’s doing real work. He uses files to do it as well! Opening an Excel spreadsheet.
My friend is an outdoor teacher and uses an iPad as a map. He’s doing real work. Maps are files.
Another friend works as a train engineer and uses an iPad to refer to technical manuals. He’s doing real work. The manuals are PDF files.
My colleagues who do recruitment at conferences take people’s details on iPads. They’re doing real work too. Each form filled in is a file.
- thisisnico 7y agoI use an iPad at my site for crane and forklift checklists with operators.
- totallynotabot 7y agoOut of curiosity, what app do you use?
- thisisnico 7y agoHonestly, the apps for this cost like 3-10K a year, and we're a small facility and a small factory, with a single iPad. So we have this web-based software named SimplyISO, We created the templates and forms/checklists in there, managers get reports etc, we threw the iPad into Kiosk mode to lock it down.
- aphextim 7y agoOur company pilot uses his iPad and foreflight all the time. I am pretty sure flying a plane is real work too.
- braythwayt 7y agoI built features for GitHub on an iPad 2. TIL that things like rich prose diffs aren't real work.
- drcongo 7y agoThis guy used to write pretty good articles, but this one is egocentric nonsense. I don't personally use an iPad for work much either, but I edit video and photos, and make music on one - all three of those tasks I prefer to do on my iPad.
- camillomiller 7y agoThis. But hey, let‘s stop pretending that‘s real work!
- hinkley 7y ago“Live long enough to become the villain” When Joel Spolsky was starting out I agreed with at least four out of five things he said and the fifth was more of a “huh?” As time went on quite a few “no, Joel” and a few “yikes” reactions began. He petered out when I still thought half of his stuff was good. I’m sure others have kept going.
- LukasMathis 7y agoI'm sorry.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mumblemumble 7y agos/real/office/g and then the article reads just fine. Otherwise, yeah, it makes little sense, because, yeah, just about every other kind of work, short perhaps of literal bricklaying, has been radically changed by tablets. The last time I had to visit a hospital, I got the impression that they might have had more money invested in iPads than in CT scanners. I don't see this as a failure. Expecting the iPad to be positioned as a device that would outright displace an existing line of Apple products that's typically sold at 2-3x the price point strikes me as an impressive failure to intuit Apple's priorities. The iPad was intended to break into - and even create - new markets, not to cannibalize its cousins. And if you look at it that way, it's been an amazing success.
- baroomba 7y agoBricklayers may not use tablets for work, but I bet they use smartphones a ton, and not just as communication devices. I know I use mine constantly when doing "real world" work—my laptop's a much worse camera, flashlight, level, and measurement device than my phone, and that's just the things it's worse at without even factoring in portability (which would include almost everything else one might want to use an Internet-connected device for on a job site, which a laptop would do alright at except that it's huge compared to a phone). [EDIT] "but why's a camera important to construction work?" want to get a usable estimate of how much tile you need for a room in about 5 seconds flat, recorded for later use? Snap a photo of the floor with the 4' by 8' plywood exposed. Done, you can walk away now. Ditto drywall if the studs are exposed and follow standard spacing, and so on.
- baroomba 7y agoThe "i-devices are just consumption devices and toys LOL" viewpoint, which is shockingly still common in programmer circles, seems to rely on a bizarrely narrow idea of what "doing real work with a computer" looks like. Meanwhile iPads and in some cases even iPhones are wildly better devices for lots of work, creative and otherwise, than a "real" computer.
- ekianjo 7y ago> iPhones are wildly better devices for lots of work, creative and otherwise, than a "real" computer I think we will need some examples to support that claim.
- addisonl 7y agoDigital art.
- mattkevan 7y agoAgreed, both the iPhone and iPad are amazing for digital art. I have a project where I try and create at least 2 pieces of abstract art every day on my iPhone. It’s great for getting ideas out quickly. Over 1500 pieces later I’m still going. Also, on the iPad, Procreate and the Affinity apps plus the Pencil are amazing.
- ekianjo 7y agoAn actual pressure tablet peripheral and desktop software beats the iPad easily. Not even a question.
- baroomba 7y agoThey're much, much better, and extremely useful, for just about any work that involves building or fixing things in the real world, to pick one large category of work. I'd personally find a laptop maybe 1/10 as useful as an iPhone (or smartphone more generally), at best, when, say, working on my house or car. Watching construction contractors work, they seem to love their phones and use them constantly, too, and for a lot more than making calls and sending messages. It's like carrying around a whole office's worth of office equipment in your pocket. It's a document scanner, you can use it to measure stuff, to get paperwork signed, to take pictures and look at them later, it's a level or flashlight in a pinch, you can load reference materials on it, and on and on, and that's without getting into really specialized software or peripherals that let you do all kinds of cools stuff.
- SamuelAdams 7y agoI designed a Food Safety application for iPad devices for a major retailer. Food Safety specialists / inspectors would go through all parts of a store - the produce on display, the meat locker, the freezers, the prep / cut table areas, etc. Hauling a laptop through all those environments was a pain. They would typically need to set their laptop down to type anything, even a brief five word note. Using a laptop could be done, but an iPad with a strap on the back enabled them to hold the device with one hand and input inspection results with the other. This along with other app improvements made the entire inspection process easier and faster for everyone involved. Think about how many people use clipboards and printed forms in their work. Ask why they need the mobility of a clipboard. If those reasons are sound, then they would probably be a good candidate for an iPad / tablet application for their workflow.
- hinkley 7y agoPilots are also using/moving to tablets. Search for “Electronic Flight Bag tablet”. Not only is it a thing, there are competing products.
- RodgerTheGreat 7y agoThe key is composability. On a normal desktop OS, it is routine to use multiple applications in concert to do work, using files and the clipboard as means of composition. On an iPad (or mobile devices in general), it is indeed possible to build delightful and useful end-to-end integrated suites for doing so-called "Real work". The problem is that if you want to perform a task that requires features from two or more applications, you may well be out of luck! Applications can rarely share data, often resorting to cloud services (and thus a mandatory network connection) as a clumsy workaround, and even copying and pasting data between applications can be challenging and error-prone. On a desktop, any user can invent new workflows. On an ipad, a user can only buy them wholesale. Users are at the mercy of the degree of forethought the app developers put into their designs.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> if you want to perform a task that requires features from two or more applications, you may well be out of luck! Ok... but if you don’t need that you’re not doing ‘real work’?
- RodgerTheGreat 7y agoI'm not implying that work done in integrated suites or "apps" is illegitimate. I'm just trying to close the philosophical gap by explaining that this sort of work is a subset of all the work one might want to do with a computer.
- spookybones 7y agoWhat if your work requires detailed onscreen notation and drawing or requires mobility and a rear camera? These aren’t work subsets of a computer without bulky and expensive peripherals.
- coldtea 7y ago>What if your work requires detailed onscreen notation and drawing or requires mobility and a rear camera? Then your work is not a typical example of real work, the same thing being a rock star is not -- even if people exist that are rock stars and get paid for it, so it's still "real work" in that sense.
- fetus8 7y agoI'm not a professional photographer, but the 11in iPad Pro has been my main photo editing machine for a year now. The USB-C port and external drive support via iPadOS makes for a simple workflow using my DSLR and editing pipeline. If I ended up doing this kind of work professionally, I could see myself continuing to use this current workflow. I guess that would be real work too.
- pier25 7y agoGood point. I guess workflows where a keyboard and mouse are not primordial work better on a touchscreen.
- ekianjo 7y agoI don't know, but when it comes to editing photos out of my DSLR, I want the biggest screen possible (and matte), not some kind of tablet size glossy screen that reflects everything around.
- ianai 7y agoMatte can be added onto an iPad with a screen protector. My iPad Pro is by far the best quality display I own. It’s definitely smaller than I’d want to be confined to all day, though. Edit-I wish they’d release an oddly large iPad Pro. I think some interesting use cases might exist in the 24”,30”,higher screen sizes. Not unlike LFD displays.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhy do photographers prefer a matte screen? Doesn’t that diffuse and blur the image and colours?
- m463 7y agoexternal drive support - first time I've heard of this. I generally have found it maddening that apple has set it up so that everyone has to "ask permission" before something is allowed on ipad/iphone/ipod. And they never let this happen before except to import from a camera (and the same camera adapter that worked on an ipad was not allowed on an iphone)
- dreamcompiler 7y agoFor me, real work means "realistically replace my laptop." The iPad cannot begin to do that. Apple could have designed IOS as a tightly integrated touch/keyboard-optional system, but they chose not to. Instead it's a bunch of app-centric silos that is decidedly hostile to most of my laptop-like keyboarding use cases.
- compiler-guy 7y agoAll true and mostly irrelevant. The iPad doesn't solve all use cases for everyone, it just solves some really good ones. So it's a bit like saying that "this bandsaw doesn't is terrible for hammering nails." It's true, but that doesn't mean a bandsaw is a useless tool.
- tomtheelder 7y agoNot irrelevant at all. The previous commenter's point was that many workflows have been made difficult/impossible by the design of the OS, and not for pro-user reasons. The iPad could support many additional uses cases without compromising at all on the ones it already serves. That is the frustration that is being expressed.
- stefan_ 7y agoI don't understand, you are making his point here. Real work involves lots of files and you want an operating system that does not discourage apps exchanging files or apps managing abstract files just because of a failed, aborted crusade against the whole "file system" thing.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Real work involves lots of files No I just gave examples of people doing real work who don’t need lots of files. An outdoor instructor may just need a single file - their map. A train engineer may need a single file - their reference manual. They’re still doing real work!
- nicky0 7y agoYes it is real work, of course. In all your examples the iPad is being used in a secondary function to support the main task (fixing a train or whatever). iPad is great for these types of work where it can be used for simple reference or information capture tasks.
- Shivetya 7y agoI think the OS would benefit from not only keeping apps on the screen but objects that are acted upon by apps. there is little reason why it cannot go both ways, desktops don't care if you click an app or object/file/etc.
- pier25 7y agoI agree that "real work" has different meanings for different people. OTOH I can see where the author is coming from when saying "real work" as in using the iPad in a productive manner in the device itself and not an accessory to another activity or consuming content. I've owned 3 iPads (currently iPad Pro 12.9) and while I love them for reading and consuming media I've never been able to do any kind of work on it other than answering a quick email.
- robenkleene 7y agoThe authors choice of words is terrible ("real work"), I'd phrase it as "making digital products". E.g., in the fitness instructor example, the product is of course the fitness training. I think most people who use this phrase "real work" are in the digital product business themselves, e.g., programmers, designers, even people writing for websites (although I think an iPad works decently well for web writing already, if you're willing to make a couple of adjustments). I think the author is only really looking at work through their own prism of being involved in making digital products. And files have been remarkably resilient in that domain (while there have been some inroads to non-file-centric workflows, e.g., No Code comes to mind). It's overwhelmingly how those products are made today, and, as the author points out, one of the iPad's biggest flaws, if you're trying to do use to make digital products, is it's resistance to working with files. I agree 100% that calling it "real work" is terrible, but I still think the authors points about resilience of files in the process of making digital products are important.
- unglaublich 7y agoIn this context, it is obviously about productivity. Yes, the iPad is a great device for information consumption, production not so.
- ekianjo 7y ago> What is this silly ‘real work’ gate-keeping? I guess the author means their work. This is about productivity. Real-work is usually about being about to do many different things with a single machine. This typically requires interoperability between applications, a file system (to access data thru a unified interface even outside of apps), and standard ways of storing data. The iPad can be very good for doing very specific tasks in one application, but everything else is lacking. Of course, if your "work" depends only on a single application, then you will be happy with pretty much anything. If you need to work with a wealth of different applications, at the same time, on the same machine, then "real work" won't be possible on an iPad easily: probably do-able, but akin to painting with spaghetti instead of brushes.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Of course, if your "work" depends only on a single application, then you will be happy with pretty much anything. But why are we saying that this isn’t ‘real’ work? Why are you putting ‘work’ in scare quotes?
- otabdeveloper2 7y ago> But why are we saying that this isn’t ‘real’ work? Because by 'real work' we mean creating stuff, not consuming stuff. Using a tablet as a fancy embedded device with pre-loaded industrial apps isn't creating stuff.
- threeseed 7y agoQuite a lot of artists, writers, video editors use an iPad. It takes talent to insult them all.
- otabdeveloper2 7y ago> Quite a lot of artists, writers, video editors use an iPad. Maybe, but that's accidental, because every tool sucks and you might as well use a sucky tool if it's trendier.
- ekianjo 7y ago> What is this silly ‘real work’ gate-keeping? I guess the author means their work. So... are there any web developers here (since it's a common occupation of many HNers) who do all their work on an iPad without any kind of desktop or laptop?
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't understand. What would that show?
- overgard 7y agoI love my iPad, but I think it's safe to say the sum of the parts is less than the whole. If unix is about composability, iOS is the opposite. You can get work done... within an app. Your apps will never act as a multiplier to make the device as a whole more useful though. I guess where I diverge from the author is that I don't really think it's a problem that it's mostly a consumption device. I think desktop computers are so thoroughly better as creative devices that maybe its fine that the ipad has its own niche.
- LukasMathis 7y agoI also don't think it's a problem, I just think it's a missed opportunity. I think the iPad could have had the potential to be a better computing device for many, if not most, people, had Apple made better decisions.
- ryguytilidie 7y agoAlso pretty much every pilot uses an iPad of some sort to do their real, and extremely critical work. I don't get these, "heres why a thing failed: because i decided i didn't like it and then manufactured some reasons why" articles.
- dmtroyer 7y agoclick bait.
- ticmasta 7y agomaybe the direction of the content, then? Ipads are great for generating a sub-set of content and consuming almost all of it. If you're work is (a) content creation and (b) tends to use a keyboard, it doesn't work great.
- freetime2 7y agoI use my iPad to babysit my kids for me. I’m pretty sure that qualifies as real work!
- caconym_ 7y agoThis thread is an incredibly frustrating example of people talking past each other, apparently just for the fun of it. The iPad lacks flexibility and as a result it is less generally useful than a "PC". Can we agree on that? I own a 12.9" iPad Pro, I love it, and I'm fully bought in with the pencil and the keyboard folio and all that shit. If I want to write or draw or browse the web or watch a video, I reach for my iPad first because it does all those things just as well as or far better than my laptop, and nothing would delight me more than to be able to toss my laptop in the trash (or whatever). But I can't! Neither can my partner, who does most of her computing (largely consumption) on her iPad, but often has to interact with institutional websites that have poor compatibility. Neither can my mom, for whom I bought an iPad in 2012, which she still uses and loves, but not even the latest and greatest iPad can support her hobby genealogy research workflow, so I had to buy her an iMac, too. The author's tone may strike some people as inflammatory or self-centered or whatever, I guess, but his essential point is right: the iPad's apps-first design and locked-down nature keep it from being a first-class general-purpose computing machine, especially for creative work. That it works for some people is great--we don't have to fight about that, nor should we. Obviously it is a crazy good form factor and fully capable for many real professional tasks and workflows. But it should not be recommended as a PC replacement for somebody who hasn't looked at all the angles, because it simply isn't a fully capable replacement, and that's what the author is talking about. If anything, I think the author's point is made more narrowly than it could be.
- lonelappde 7y agoiPad is different, not less. I can't use my PC on a treadmill or in a hot tub or for GPS when I'm traveling or many other things.
- caconym_ 7y agoI can use my PC for all those things if I really want to; it's just less convenient and less compelling a form factor. Those things are the big reason the iPad sells despite not being a fully-capable PC replacement.
- 7y ago
- syshum 7y agoSorry, one can only to "Real Work" if you have at minimum 3 Monitors, a Mechanical Keyboard with Cherry Switch's, and a Proper Chair.... Everything else is just pretend Work :) /s
- doctor_eval 7y agoAgreed. The vast majority of humans who are doing “real work” on computers use just one or two applications. The vast minority of people are software developers and IT workers. Lawyers, accountants, nurses, doctors, paramedics, tree surgeons, baristas, plumbers, electricians, shop assistants, mechanics, jewellers, cleaners... most of these people - if they want to use computers at all - want them to be less complicated, they don’t generally care about interoperability between applications, and iPad in some cases fits the bill. Its simplicity for some of these use cases is an enabler. To my mind there seems to be two independent narratives at play here: - “is the iPad better than a general purpose computer?” for many use cases, yes it is. - “Is it perfect?” Perhaps not yet. But it’s more perfect for those use cases than what came before.
- LukasMathis 7y agoThen why don't these people use iPads? (Maybe because iPads are actually more complicated for most common work-related tasks.) Your claim that only a minority of people use more than two applications needs a source, because I don't know a single person who gets by with just two applications for work. Pretty much everybody uses at least an email client/office messaging app, a browser, and Word, and those are just the generic tools; there are very few people who don't also use work-related, specialized tools.
- kristianc 7y ago> real work is typically file-centric Pilots fly planes using iPads. It’s a ludicrous suggestion that that isn’t real work.
- p1necone 7y agoThe work your fitness instructor friend is doing is fitness instructing, the teacher is teaching and the train engineer is doing train engineering. Referring to documents on an iPad while doing other work != doing work on an iPad. Other people have posted examples of things where the primary/producing part of the work is done on the iPad though (drawing, audio production, presumably Excel/word/PowerPoint or equivalents are decent)
- ken 7y ago> He uses files to do it as well! Opening an Excel spreadsheet. I find it interesting that your first example of a file-centric (rather than app-centric) workflow describes the file by the application that creates/views/edits it. Can you do anything with this "Excel spreadsheet" on an iPad other than open it in Excel?
- chadlavi 7y agoHe clearly means real work in the realms traditionally requiring computational power. Except for excel, all the things you mentioned could easily be done with a piece of paper. And even then, good luck converting an xls file to csv then using a text editor to manipulate it on an iPad. Real computer work is making software or graphics that require either computational power (video, graphics, music) or access to the Unix shell (programming). The first category is ready to go, capability wise, on iPad, but like the author said there's no incentive for those companies to make iPad versions of their software. The second category is a non-starter because of the App-centric nature of iPadOS.
- zepto 7y agoWhy not just open the excel file in Numbers? I do most of my spreadsheet work on an iPad.
- m463 7y agoThe ipad (and the app store) will do well-defined work in well-defined ways (with well-defined apps). I don't think it will ever do the stuff out at the edges very well.
- bishalb 7y agoI think by real work they mean the kind of work you do for 8 hours or more a day (or "get shit done" type of work) like using Excel on desktop with all it's bells and whistles, checking stuff on your crm and making a report based on it, programming etc. Sure even sending emails can be real work(and there are many people whose half the time at work is spent just sending emails) and you have been able to do that using symbian phones for more than a decade now. Putting the term "real work" into context makes sense here because iPad gets compared to laptops a lot but it can't even remotely be used for the breadth of work that you can get done on a desktop in a practical sense.
- LukasMathis 7y ago>What is this silly ‘real work’ gate-keeping? I guess the author means their work. I used the term "real work" because that's the term people use when they write "you can actually use the iPad for real work" articles. I think it's clear from context that "real work" means the kind of work Steve Jobs introduced the iPad for, i.e. the work people traditionally do on PCs: writing letters, creating presentations, doing spreadsheets, and so on. I do acknowledge that people do real work on iPads; I pointed out some examples in the first paragraph. The problem is that these are clearly niche tasks, as is reflected in the iPad's sales numbers. The iPad works well for some people, who do very specific tasks. That's genuinely great for them, but it's clearly not what Apple had in mind for the iPad. And in my opinion, it's not what the iPad's true potential could have been.