10 ms·
Is Nuclear Power Globally Scalable? (2011)
- fsiefken 7y agoFrom the Conclusion at the end of the paper addressing all types of nuclear technologies, fast breed reactors, Generation IV reactors and "fusion or fission, uranium or thorium": "Even a lesser goal of several terawatts of nuclear power would run into many of the outlined limitations. Therefore, the notion of a nuclear utopia is a false one. But there are two types of nuclear advocates: the nuclear utopian and the nuclear realist. A nuclear realist would only suggest that we need about 1 TW of nuclear power as part of our world energy mix. However, one only has to divide the results, in this paper, by 15 to see that 1 TW still stretches resources and risks considerably. One then has to count the cost, consider the safety, the complexity, and the issues surrounding governance of nuclear power. Also if the technology cannot be fundamentally scaled further than 1 TW, one has to ask if the same investment would have been better spent on a truly scalable technology. It has been suggested that for the same investment, solar thermal farms (with storage) would exceed the power output of nuclear stations and eliminate many of the problems [5]. Solar thermal is also scalable as it has the capacity to deliver hundreds of terawatts should mankind require it in the future. The weakness of a scalable renewable solution, however, is intermittency. In the short term, this problem can be addressed via dual use of solar thermal with natural gas. Then, the natural gas can be phased out, as storage and grid balancing techniques come online to solve the intermittency problem."
- acidburnNSA 7y agoThat's a big gamble. We know fracked natural gas emits vastly too many CO2 molecules per kWh generated for decarbonization, and it also leaks methane through the pipelines. Nuclear has been a boogeyman to fossil fuels for a long time. Intermittent renewables with storage are awesome, but when backed by gas they're antiproductive to decarbonizing. France deeply decarbonized their entire grid with nuclear in 15 years by standardizing plants and building in serial. This is a good success story. Building gas now and hoping it goes away in 50 years is a terrible solution.
- karanbhangui 7y agoCurious on your thoughts about feasibility of manufacturing compact reactors on floating barges in ship yards and floating to where needed to plug into grid (most populations are coastal). Idea would be to solve for political risk/perception in that it can be unplugged and floated away in case of meltdown.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoIs this a plant question? I am in the middle of writing a page explaining that is the best and greatest idea in the history of nuclear reactor development. It was seriously considered and big money was spent on it in the 1970s for the Atlantic Generating Station. A production facility was made. Thousands of studies of wildlife were done. An environmental impact statement was approved by the NRC. The coast guard signed off on it. It is amazing. But demand leveled off after the oil shocks and they were never built. To rapidly decarbonize this is simply one of the most enticing ideas out there.
- karanbhangui 7y agoPlease keep me posted on the page you're writing, email in profile. It's a fascination I've had since highschool after visiting an aircraft carrier in San Diego. Almost went to school for nuclear engineering but studied ECE instead.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoSent it to you last night
- natmaka 7y agoIn France this 'success story' led to a state law (2015-992, from 2015, the "loi relative à la transition énergétique pour la croissance verte") states that the part of nuke-produced electricity must fall to less than 50% in 2025, from 72% then, and that renewables must replace it. In France nuke-power is backed by gas (which produced 10,3% of gridpower in 2017). The sole reactor currently planned (Flamanville-3) is a complete disaster, more than 10 years behind schedule and 4x overbudget. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamanville_Nuclear_Power_Plant#Unit_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamanville_Nuclear_Power_Plan...
- rmtech 7y agoWhy can't nuclear be scaled beyond 1TW?
- Accujack 7y agoIt can, the author of the article is cherry picking facts to make it seem like it can't.
- guscost 7y ago"We won't ever figure out how to work safely with a substance that stores huge amounts of usable energy in its atomic structure." ... "We just need to figure out how to store and transport many terawatts of harvested solar power, and then we can finally phase out natural gas." Insanity. This sounds like it was written by Gazprom.
- stevenwoo 7y agoThis needs a 2011, neglects discussion of implications of construction of first long time nuclear waste storage facility in Finland couple of years ago (i.e. is that scaleable or even repeatable given politics now that we have an example) https://psmag.com/ideas/the-hiding-place-inside-the-worlds-first-long-term-storage-facility-for-highly-radioactive-nuclear-waste https://psmag.com/ideas/the-hiding-place-inside-the-worlds-f...
- coold 7y agoAgain? Somebody really wants you to read this.
- jwilk 7y agoArchived copy, which works with JS disabled: https://archive.is/REV0t https://archive.is/REV0t
- himinlomax 7y agoRe: nuclear waste Deep core drilling seems to solve all the problems. Burying waste 3 km deep under 2 km of dirt makes it immune to even geological timescale movements. It also solves the problem of security; it's hard to see how a bad actor could drill a 2 km deep hole without being noticed.
- pitaj 7y agoYou still have to worry about it leaking into aquifers, though I believe that problem is already solved by encasing the waste in glass.
- mLuby 7y agoAre there really aquifers that move water ≥ 1km upward? I thought they were mostly lateral or downward moving.
- pitaj 7y agoWells can be up to 200m deep. Aquifers are usually level, but the land above them might not be. So burying something 1k deep can leak into an aquifer that is drilled into elsewhere or even a high-table aquifer that drains into surface water downhill.
- himinlomax 7y agoYou will obviously notice any aquifer while drilling on the way down. And there may indeed well be water very deep down. But from what I understand, they are not connected with more surface level, and any diffusion of material takes a very long time. Keep in mind the pressure at those depths. Water is obviously lighter than rock, and if it had a way to go up, it would have.
- himinlomax 7y agoThat's supposedly not a problem at 2km. Keep in mind that the stuff would be packed under 2km of dirt.
- bcatanzaro 7y agoSure, if you restrict yourself to 1950s technology, Nuclear is pretty handicapped. It’s just crazy to me that these articles presume some sort of revolution in solar technology scalability but forbid nuclear power from using any better design than the first one we invented.
- colincooke 7y agoCompletely agreed. I was surpised reading the article about how fusion (irrespective of being able to achieve it with positive energy output) was obviously a non-starter due to neutron embrittlement. I think there is a place for this kind of work, however simply looking backwards at technology and propagating it forward with no change isn't it. The author points out many problems that weren't evident to me prior to reading, but also doesn't comment on how any of them are being solved or have progressed in within the past few decades. For example modern reactors last 80 years not 60 [0] (and can be extended to over 100). [0] https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/whats-lifespan-nuclear-reactor-much-longer-you-might-think https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/whats-lifespan-nuclear-re...
- fsh 7y agoThe article mentions breeder reactors and Uranium seawater extraction. Which other modern designs are missing in your opinion?
- bcatanzaro 7y agoThorium and molten salt reactors, for example. There are other promising ideas.
- fsh 7y agoThorium reactors are breeders. Molten salt reactors share many issues related to the corrosive radioactive colant with fast breeder reactors that are discussed in the article.
- bcatanzaro 7y ago
- StillBored 7y agoYou have to question the assumptions if the basic math at the beginning doesn't even seem right. They claim 440 reactors today need to scale to 15,000. That is a 34x increase. Yet, https://www.ieer.org/ensec/no-1/glbnrg.html https://www.ieer.org/ensec/no-1/glbnrg.html says that 18% of worldwide generation is already nuclear. So, to get to 100% that would be ~5x, not 34x. So, just that one change pretty much blows most of their argument away, particularly if you assume that simply replacing many of the existing reactors would give a capacity increase due to turbine/heat efficiency improvements now done at modern plants. So the scare mongering about having to build/replacing a reactor each day sounds like utter bollocks.
- colincooke 7y agoWorth noting that your reference is from 1993, and although your argument still stands for a modern reference: "Around 10% of the world's electricity is generated by about 440 nuclear power reactors" [0] [0] https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-future-generation/nuclear-power-in-the-world-today.aspx https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-an...
- adrianN 7y agoThis is probably a confusing on your part between energy consumption and electricity consumption. For a fossil free future we also have to replace fossil fuels used for heating and transportation. It's likely that we won't need a 1:1 replacement (by far) because heating and transportation can be done much more efficiently with electricity (thanks to heat pumps and the efficiency of electric motors).
- magduf 7y ago1. We don't need to replace all fossil fuels to just do better than we're doing now. It'd be a big help to just replace all fossil-fuel power plants, which is what the OP was talking about. 2. Cars and trucks can be powered by electricity in the near-term. Airplanes cannot; we'd need much better battery tech for that to happen. Heating can't be replaced by heat pumps entirely; heat pumps don't work in subfreezing conditions. They have to resort to "auxiliary heat" (electric resistance heating) when it gets too cold. Of course, doing that and just having more nuclear plants is still better than burning hydrocarbons, but it does mean we need more electricity generation.
- gambler 7y agoAnti-nuclear FUD. I wonder who's paying for this stuff. > Currently, the total global power consumption by mankind is about 15 terawatts (TW) —so the question we address is: Can nuclear power feasibly supply at least 15 TW? This is a downright idiotic question. Humans use and will continue to use a variety of different energy sources. Which sources specifically depends on economic viability that differs based on the location, availability of raw materials, current energy prices and government incentives. If you're really serious about preventing drastic climate change due to C02 emissions, you should consider scaling up all energy sources that don't produce CO2. Recommended viewing: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKH_iLhhkTyt8Dk4dmeCQ9w/playlists https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKH_iLhhkTyt8Dk4dmeCQ9w/pla...
- guscost 7y ago> I wonder who's paying for this stuff. Oil companies, of course: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friends_of_the_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friends_of_the_Earth > Friends of the Earth was founded in 1969 in San Francisco by David Brower, Donald Aitken and Gary Soucie after Brower's split with the Sierra Club[4] due to the latter's positive approach to nuclear energy. The founding donation of $500,000 (in 2019 USD) was provided by Robert Orville Anderson, the owner of Atlantic Richfield oil company.[5]
- fsh 7y agoI don't think that shallow dismissals and conspiracy theories add much to the discussion.
- sdinsn 7y agoOil companies fund anti-nuclear groups. This is not a conspiracy theory, it's a fact. By the way, your comment is nothing but a shallow dismissal of his comment...
- wazoox 7y agoAll of this is interesting, but for instance it states that nuclear plants occupy large amount of land (20.5km2 on average) and needs lots of resources. However without a comparison to alternative technology, this is a moot point. Having a quick look at requirements for solar plants, it's easy to check that typical ones occupy about 14km2 per GW of power. So solar requires several orders of magnitude more land than nuclear (taking into account actual power production: 80% yield for nuclear, 15% at most for solar). Furthermore, it's also easy to check that contrary to nuclear plants where land grab is largely a safety zone, a solar plant actually covers land with hardware, most of it requiring much more rare earths and exotic materials than nuclear power plants (where 95% of stuff in weight is concrete and steel). The actual take for me is the following: in the coming years, we'll go through a huge reduction in energy availability, because fossil fuels are at least 80% of world energy consumption and they'll run out at some point anyway; which implies a huge reduction in economic activity. This is absolutely unavoidable in the next few decades unless some actual miracle such as cheap and easy cold fusion happens real soon now .
- Tade0 7y agoa solar plant actually covers land with hardware, most of it requiring much more rare earths and exotic materials The most exotic material in crystalline solar panels is silver or perhaps tin. No rare earths whatsoever.
- wazoox 7y agoTo be a somewhat believable alternative to nuclear, you'll also need tons of batteries. Many, many tons of them, full of lithium and cobalt and other things. Because a solar plant produces power along a very steep bell curve centered around noon, while a nuclear plant produces linearly exactly the amount you're asking for 80 to 95% of the time. This is only alluded to in the article, but intermittency is a major nuisance and hinders significantly actual utility of renewable power, because we need a base level of production they're totally incapable to provide unless backed with literal mountains of storage (storage technology at scale we don't know how to build or manage today).
- littlestymaar 7y agoThis article is really poor. I don't even disagree with the point they make since I don't think nuclear is scalable at all, but this article has mistakes or bad reasonning like in every paragraph! I'm on my phone so I won't list them all, but come on!