5 ms·
Michigan left
- timsco 16y agoI like how the Wikipedia article does not mention how this strategy turns the streets into soul sucking suburban wastelands. The Michigan left may reduce accidents, but it divides neighbourhoods (reference: anywhere on 8 Mile). This is a very bad idea.
- ekanes 16y agoCan you explain why? Unless I'm misunderstanding, pedestrians can still cross, and the neighbourhoods are divided by the massive highway, rather than the specific turning pattern...?
- chipsy 16y agoIn most of Michigan, the roads are enormous, development is sparse, and there are no sidewalks to speak of. It's tied in with the history of the state as a center of auto industry and the first attempts at car-centric planning. Saying that the "Michigan Left" is the cause isn't exactly correct, but it does allude to the overall nature of the layout.
- modulow 16y agoAs a 28-year Michigander (Flint/Detroit area), I don't think the left turning mechanism is responsible for any neighborhood divides...you could say that the divided highway contributes to this, but I am more inclined to blame "White Flight" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight).
- watchandwait 16y agoI blame Michigan's anti-business labor and tax law.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jbooth 16y agoI blame people who blame everything on "unions and taxes" regardless of how little or how much they know about an actual problem.
- timsco 16y agoI'm tired of Detroiters blaming white flight for everything. I brought up 8 mile as an example but Woodward is just as bad dividing the white people in Royal Oak from the white people in Berkeley. You can't walk across the street with those huge boulevards. That's the point.
- roc 16y agoThe divided boulevard divides neighborhoods, not the Michigan Left. Left Turn lanes would actually make it harder to cross 8 mile. I'm not a fan of Michigan zoning whatsoever, but in this case, the damage is done with or without the Michigan Left.
- timsco 16y agoThat's a good point but it's chicken / egg. Now every new boulevard in Greater Detroit is divided so that it can be filled with Michigan Lefts.
- roc 16y agoThe larger point was: the zoning boards are the problem. Every new boulevard is divided because metro Detroit zoning boards design in favor of car use in almost all things. The huge parking lots, the divided neighborhoods, the laughable sidewalk situation -- it's all because optimizing car flow is the priority. The symptoms aren't the problem.
- chaz 16y agoWorse than any other road that size? It's an eight-lane road and that, by itself, is a big socio/economic dividing force, regardless of the type of intersection.
- saturdaysaint 16y agoI think that the commenter is implying that these planning conventions (and the overall mentality of prioritizing car traffic far ahead of pedestrian and bike traffic) go hand in hand with the eight-lane mega-road.
- timsco 16y agoThat is correct. I lived there for 3.5 years and now live in downtown Toronto which is the opposite of suburban Detroit in terms of population density and sprawl. Don't get me wrong, I really love Detroit but its city planning is a huge contributor to its most pressing issues. Visit Detroit though. It's possibly the most interesting place in the world.
- vnchr 16y agoAnd proud of it! - A Michigander
- markkat 16y agoYeah, it makes you feel almost like Columbus! -Another!
- agscala 16y agoNot to mention that Michigan also puts signs for major intersections before the actual intersection (like 1/4 a mile), but they can be difficult to find (or not even there) at the actual intersection...
- pkananen 16y agoI've always been surprised at how living in a different state affects far reaching things such as making left hand turns.
- blinkingled 16y agoI was more irritated than surprised but yeah - I have thought about this point more than once during my early days in the US. When I first landed - it was almost frightening to drive -the flashy noisy cop cars, the humongous, wide, structured yet confusing mingling of roads. Then you go drive to another state and few surprises get thrown at you! Oh and Stop signs really absolutely terminally mean STOP - that took a little while to get used to. I failed driving test due to this - the seriousness of driving tests, that was yet another "O'RLY, FOR REAL?" moment! I get it all now after several years, but it was fun living through the cross state road trips. --Another Michigander.
- tvchurch 16y agoLike these neat random articles? Check out Best of Wikipedia: (http://bestofwikipedia.tumblr.com/ http://bestofwikipedia.tumblr.com/) Usually twice a day, always good. (Not my site, btw) Cheers.
- IgorPartola 16y agoThis is the other type of turn we were discussing at lunch today: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2044725,00.html http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2044725,00.....
- m_myers 16y agoSee also the Texas Turnaround for highway frontage roads: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_U-turn http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_U-turn
- pavel_lishin 16y agoI've gotten so used to these, I don't understand why every city with overpasses doesn't have them.
- look_lookatme 16y agoI don't live in Texas anymore and I don't drive anymore, so I never realized this isn't standard around the US. Weird. I loved turnarounds as an option over yielding lefts. You drive a bit further, but it always felt a bit safer, particularly in large strip malls where you have several points of entry along a frontage road.
- jonnii 16y agoI'll see your Michigan left and raise you a magic roundabout http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_Roundabout_(Swindon) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_Roundabout_(Swindon)
- jrwoodruff 16y agoThat just looks like insanity. To think, Americans are confused by simple one-lane roundabouts.
- elehack 16y agoWe might not be as confused by them if they were more common. I'd like to see more roundabouts. However, I think the magic roundabout can wait until the next generation...
- jerf 16y agoI drive through this twice a day: http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&ll=42.505215,-83.758199&spn=0.005007,0.007789&t=h&z=17 http://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&ll=42.505215,-83.758199&... It's a triple roundabout with a highway bridge separating two of them. The internals are arguably simpler but there are more entrances/exits than the magic roundabout. For bonus points, check out what state this is in. (I use Bing because last I checked Google still doesn't have a good satellite view of this, despite it being several years old now.)
- jrwoodruff 16y agoI've been through that intersection! Let me tell you, coming off the highway expecting a normal intersection and getting dumped into that is pretty crazy. Not sure why they chose that design... Crazy MDOT.
- jerf 16y agoIf you sit down and try to draw the traffic light situation for that set of roads, this is actually a better solution than anything else I've been able to come up with. All the traffic-light situations I've mentally drawn out deadlock during rush hour with reasonable assumptions about people ending up in the middle of intersections accidentally as the light goes red, and have terrible throughput by comparison at all times of day. Presumably the actual civil engineers came to the same conclusion, only with better numbers and models. I can not imagine that was an easy sell, they must have had a rock-solid case.
- balanon 16y agoI am from Michigan. I hate the Michigan left. It basically puts something between you and the other side of the street. I wonder how much gas I've wasted going right for 1/8 of a mile just to go left.
- maukdaddy 16y agoProbably not much since you'd otherwise waste a lot of gas idling at a red light trying to make a left.
- colomon 16y agoIt's not like the "Michigan Left" (I hate that name, "Metro Detroit Left" would be much more accurate) does away with making a left turn at a light. Instead, you make a right turn at light at the intersection, and then a left turn at the extra stoplight they added for the Michigan left. The only time it's really a win is when there's no traffic on the road you're crossing, so you can turn right on red and then left on red. And of course, in that case it would be easy to turn left on green if it were a normal intersection...
- mdiep 16y agoThese aren't unique to Metro Detroit. Portions of the East Beltline (M-44) in Grand Rapids, one of the busiest streets in the area, make use of the Michigan Left.
- evilduck 16y agoDepends on how busy the intersection is. Worst case scenario: Miss the first light to cross straight through the intersection. Idle. Queue into the non-intersection left turn lane to cross two lanes of oncoming traffic. Idle. Wait for a right turn red light and idle, or wait for an opportunity to merge into two lanes of oncoming traffic and idle. The best case scenario is light traffic and hitting both lights green, but you're still going further and taking longer to accomplish a left turn signal's best case scenario. A double left turn lane with signal is almost always faster in my experience.
- 16y ago
- KeithMajhor 16y agoA previous article about another interesting traffic design. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1437430 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1437430
- drawkbox 16y agoNew Jersey Jughandle: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jughandle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jughandle You have to make a left by basically taking almost like a freeway ramp off to the right. If you miss your left turn ramp on the right in some parts of Jersey, you end up driving many miles to get another opportunity due to all the Jersey barriers that basically prevent real left-hand turns.
- mgkimsal 16y agoARGH - I HATE those. Couple those with poor signage and out-of-towners will be lost for, well, if not hours, certainly tens of minutes. :/ (cherry hill ... lost several times in that area and no ways to turn around for miles).
- watchandwait 16y agoIt is a lot better than collisions at lights. A NJ DOT friend says the jughandles are a lot safer-- the principle is keeping stopped and turning cars away from moving traffic.
- mgkimsal 16y agoWould many DOT workers say their systems are stupid? Michigan DOT people probably justify the Michigan Left as safe/efficient/etc, and other places use roundabouts (Camden seems to have removed their roundabout(s) last time I was there). Also, forcing people to drive an extra 3-4 miles because they missed a turn is probably not very good for the environment. Just sayin'
- cale 16y agoHow about those left turn passing lanes on two-lane roads in Maryland? Feels dangerous, but keeps traffic moving.
- davito88 16y agoI love that this hit the HN RSS. However, I prefer the Pittsburg Left: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_Left http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_Left
- notyourwork 16y agoThese are not related.
- davito88 16y agoalso, they are apparently safer than 'normal' left turns: http://news.ncsu.edu/releases/wmshummersuperstreets/ http://news.ncsu.edu/releases/wmshummersuperstreets/
- fedd 16y agolove this habit to give everything a name. we do this all the time, just didn't call it anyway. the next time i collide, i'll come out and say, "i gave you a signal, i was making the Pittsburgh left, you uneducated moron!"
- notyourwork 16y agoDid anyone else read this as "the state of Michigan has left wikipedia". Pleasantly surprised at what I found on the link though. I love ideas like this, though I fear majority of drives in the states would have trouble adjusting to this style. They have enough trouble parallel parking and making right's on red, lets not confuse them anymore!
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ohyes 16y agoThe Michigan left would never work in Massachusetts because of the Boston Sweep (A maneuver in which you merge onto the roadway and rapidly change lanes from far right to far left, without signaling).
- keiferski 16y agoRelated: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_left http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_left The driving practice of the first left-turning vehicle taking precedence over vehicles going straight through an intersection.
- steveklabnik 16y agoI can confirm that this happens quite often around here. Sometimes, it's fantastic, and alleviates a lot of congestion. Another odd Pittsburgh-ism that has its own Wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_parking_chair http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_parking_chair I'm not a big fan of this one.
- coolgeek 16y agoThis is done in Philly, too, as well as other PA cities. I'd be very surprised if it was limited to PA though
- pkamb 16y agoIn Washington, you can turn left onto a one-way street on red. This is legal when you are on a one-way OR two-way street, which is unique to Washington and a handful of other states. This applies to turning left onto freeway on-ramps (one way streets) as well.
- throw_away 16y agoleft turn to one-way on red is legal in michigan as well, it turns out. having lived in michigan and now washington, I'm glad I learned that this is not the case everywhere before it became an issue.
- pkamb 16y agoWikipedia says left on red from one-way to one-way is legal in 37 states, so you should be good in most places doing that. Alaska, Idaho, Michigan, Oregon, Washington, and B.C. (Canada) allow the left turn from two-way onto one-way as an added bonus.
- rfugger 16y agoReminded me of this brilliant configuration for avoiding left turns at freeway interchanges: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diverging_diamond_interchange http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diverging_diamond_interchange
- bugsy 16y agoIt's amazing that there are advantages to this. It seems the main one is the observation that intersections have many overloaded functions which combine to explode the complexity of operations that can occur: intersections handle cross traffic between roads, 4 different points of turning from one road to the orthogonal one via left turn, 4 different points of turning to orthogonal via right turn, four points of u-turns, and pedestrian crossing. Whichever maneuver you pick, there are that many other maneuvers that each other car might be involved in at the same time and you have to interact with. That's an insane level of complexity, and the complexity of the whole system affects all the cars coming from each of 4 directions. The Michigan turn takes roughly half of these, the 4 left turn modalities and 4 u-turn modalities and displaces each of 4 to a location where it only affects a single direction, the oncoming one, although it has the side effect of doubling the number of right hand turns at the main intersection, but these are safer turns than left ones. A variation on this I have seen on highways and interstates throughout the US is to have a left turn slow down and two-way median turn around lane that is in between the actual roads where one would turn, ensuring that no dangerous left turns take place. The left turn is replaced with a u turn which is even more dangerous due to the lower speed at which one clears oncoming traffic, and there are seldom any pedestrian situations since pedestrians aren't usually found on highways. But it does avoid the otherwise conflict with negotiating the crossing with several other directions at once, to your right cross traffic, left cross traffic, left across-left turn traffic, right across-left turn traffic, and oncoming traffic, reducing all this to having to deal with oncoming traffic only. And if I had not read this link I never would have thought about all this stuff, so thanks for posting.
- lusis 16y agoThese things ALWAYS throw me for a loop when visiting the inlaws. It's so counter-intuitive.
- callmeed 16y agoI lived in Bend, Oregon for 3 years and we had roundabouts everywhere. You could literally get across town without stopping at a light/sign. Maybe they are more of a small/medium sized city feature, but it was hard coming back to California and all it's stop lights and stupid turn lanes. http://www.ci.bend.or.us/roundabouts/docs/CityEdAug07_Roundabouts.wmv http://www.ci.bend.or.us/roundabouts/docs/CityEdAug07_Rounda...
- Jacob4u2 16y agoFlash animation showing examples of East to North and North to West turns - http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdot/MDOT_Roads-Travel_mich_left_213414_7.swf http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdot/MDOT_Roads-Travel_mic...