3 ms·
I worked for a bit for a lobbying firm for commercial fishermen. They would spend money on all sorts of things: global warming, removing mining, removing dams.
by legitster 7y ago
I worked for a bit for a lobbying firm for commercial fishermen. They would spend money on all sorts of things: global warming, removing mining, removing dams. I asked my boss why weren't doing any messaging around ocean acidification.
"You don't tell people about the end of the world. If people knew how fucked they were, they would just get out of the industry and stop supporting us."
Seafood is the last wild food that normal people can still affordably and regularly eat. But there is a very real chance that our generation will be the last to do so.
- grawprog 7y agoAt least along the coast and as far as 1000km inland, it won't just be the ocean ecosystems affected. Land mammals, birds and the forests themselves rely on nutrients directly from the ocean. The world as it is relies on oceans having life as it is. The oceans are tied to nearly every ecosystem in the world in some way or another.
- mymythisisthis 7y agoAlready by the twelfth century, fishing pressure and human modification of riverine and estuarine habitats threatened sturgeon populations from Italy to the Baltic. A brief history of aquatic resource use in medieval Europe Richard C. Hoffmann
- djsumdog 7y agoI talked to someone who was an agricultural scientist, working for a fishing company in Seattle. When I brought up how I heard the oceans would be unfishable in 50 years, he said, "That's not true." He want to to say the fishery industry is concerned with sustainability, after all these fisheries have been around for generations and want to stay that way. He claimed they carefully monitored fish populations to maintain stability in fishing. I don't know enough about the subject. He could have been touting the official line fed to him, but he could have also been telling us the honest truth based on his team/company's research.
- jes5199 7y agoacidification is out of their control, though - it's directly linked to global carbon emissions
- 40four 7y ago>The ocean is acidifying because it's absorbing more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, which lowers pH levels in the water. Doesn't matter how sustainable the fishing practices are, or how well they manage the populations, if the water quality won't support a population to begin with.
- grouseway 7y agoThe Canadian government was carefully monitoring Atlantic cod too. Until they completely collapsed. These systems are apparently too complex for us to make good predictions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collapse_of_the_Atlantic_northwest_cod_fishery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collapse_of_the_Atlantic_north...
- philipkglass 7y agoScientists correctly predicted that catch quotas needed to be set much lower. The government discounted the lower-end predictions of sustainable catch rates or even ignored them outright, choosing instead to "balance" the scientists' advice against "socio-economic considerations." But nature cannot be fooled, so socio-economic conditions deteriorated abruptly and catastrophically in the 1990s as the ecological conditions did likewise.
- ska 7y agoThese systems are apparently too complex for us to make good predictions. I don't know if that is true so much that good predictions are rejected for political reasons. See also climate change.
- jonnydubowsky 7y agoAt the precipice of collapse, it becomes a game of Jenga.
- madaxe_again 7y agoAt the current rate of acidification, nothing that requires a calcium skeleton will be able to exist by the early 2030s in northern seas - it’s going to be a catastrophic collapse. Cnidaria look like they may end up being pretty much the sole survivors - it has happened before