4 ms·
It means that the US economy is in much worse shape than various indicators (successful stock market, low unemployment, high price of US government bonds) would
by jfengel 7y ago
It means that the US economy is in much worse shape than various indicators (successful stock market, low unemployment, high price of US government bonds) would indicate.
The government regularly spends more than it takes in from taxes by issuing bonds. People buy the bonds because the US government is considered quite safe. That in turn lets the government spend money, which ultimately makes its way into the economy as a whole. People use that money to hire workers, buy stocks, etc, making the economy look good.
But the Federal Reserve Bank has the ability to invent money for buying those bonds out of thin air. That means the bond prices stay high (and the interest rates low). That implies that the current strong economy is an illusion, and that's worrying.
The expected response of extra money being pushed into the economy without added value is inflation, and the inflation rate has crept up over 2%[1]. It's actually a little surprising that it has taken this long, since this is actually something they've been doing for over a decade. There is considerable debate about that, but it may be that the inflationary chickens are finally coming home to roost -- in which case things might get real bad real quick.
tl;dr: this indicates that the economy may not be as strong as we think, caused by economic manipulation by the Federal Reserve to make the economy seem stronger than it is.
[1] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t01.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t01.htm
- tabtab 7y agoWe need something similar to the Balanced Budget Amendment (BBA). Our system rewards short-term thinking. However, the BBA should take into account stimuluses during slumps. It would probably have to kick in slowly to avoid hurting the representatives who sign it.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoWhy? Do you think it would reasonable to require that all homes be paid in cash? Should we ban auto loans? Why is the government different in this regard? There is nothing wrong with using debt responsibly. I enjoy the opportunity this affords me to buy the debt. it's a good investment for me. When mixed in the proper ratios with the remainder of my portfolio in combination with reasonably applied leverage US debt provides a safe, stable, and inflation protected place for a great many of us to store excess earnings.
- jfengel 7y agoGovernment debt is different from personal debt. People don't work forever, or live forever. Buying a home on debt is a good choice for a person, since it lets them have a place to live after they stop working. And that debt is backed by the house: if the person dies before the house is paid off, they get the house rather than coming after the heirs for debts. The government never retires, and never has to pay off its debts. That gives it a lot of leverage, but it also obligates new citizens to a share of the debt as soon as they're born. Your parents can't pass their mortgage debt to you, but they do pass on their share of money that the government has borrowed. So the government can safely borrow money, but at some point it will accumulate so much debt that people begin to doubt its ability to pay it back. Whoever is left holding the bag at that point will be in very deep trouble. I don't know what point that is. Interest rates are still low, so the answer appears to be "not today" (and "not imminently"). But the article points out that the low interest rates may be something of a false indicator. So as you say, responsible debt is good. But decreasing revenue via tax cuts, and increasing debt accumulation, at a time when the economy appears to be booming doesn't appear to be responsible. It reduces the ability to borrow in the future, at precisely the time you could be increasing that ability by paying down old debts. Especially if you're then covering it up by borrowing in a way that's hard for people to see.
- RockIslandLine 7y ago"So the government can safely borrow money, but at some point it will accumulate so much debt that people begin to doubt its ability to pay it back." Currency issuers can always pay any debt denominated in the currency that they issue. It is literally impossible for a currency issuer to be forced to default. "But decreasing revenue via tax cuts, and increasing debt accumulation, at a time when the economy appears to be booming doesn't appear to be responsible." That's a sane position, but the argument against a Federal Balanced Budget Amendment comes from the opposite case. You want the capability to deficit spend during recessions. The Federal Balanced Budget Amendment forces you to make the wrong decision of cutting spending during recessions, driving the nation deeper into recession. When factories are idle and unemployment is high, it is vicious to claim that the best policy is to choose to throw more people out of work. Federal spending should be explicitly countercyclical.
- wombatpm 7y agoIllinois has one of those. It just means they explicitly call out the amount of debt they will take on, not that they will have a true balanced budget. Problem is that no legislative body can pass laws dictating the future actions of a legislative body- - they will just pass new laws if they need to.
- RockIslandLine 7y ago"The government regularly spends more than it takes in from taxes by issuing bonds. [...] That in turn lets the government spend money, which ultimately makes its way into the economy as a whole" This is straight up nonsense. All currency issuers have the ability to spend which is skew from their need to tax. Taxes do not fund Federal spending. Taxes destroy money, and thus control inflation. That is a fundamentally different role. https://www.bradford-delong.com/2013/04/abba-lerner-1943-functional-finance.html https://www.bradford-delong.com/2013/04/abba-lerner-1943-fun...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoTaxes destroy money? How so? Taxes take money from some private entity, and give it to the government. The government then spends the money, usually by buying something from some private entity. How does that destroy any money?
- RockIslandLine 7y agoWe're not on the Gold Standard. We don't have to track Pretty Yellow Rocks. The rules are different for Currency Issuers (nations with a fiat currency) versus currency users (citizens, provinces, and nations on the Gold Standard). For the United States, which is a currency issuer, Congressional appropriations create money. Taxes do indeed return money to the government from the private sector, but there is no need to claim that money is "recycled" for spending purposes. Revenue is an obsolete concept for currency issuers.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI call BS. > For the United States, which is a currency issuer, Congressional appropriations create money. What is your basis for claiming that this is true? > Taxes do indeed return money to the government from the private sector, but there is no need to claim that money is "recycled" for spending purposes. Are you saying that it isn't recycled? If not, what do you think happens to it, and what is your basis for claiming that it is true? > Revenue is an obsolete concept for currency issuers. Only if you want staggering amounts of inflation. It is true that a currency issuer can just issue more money, and therefore could survive (short term) with no tax revenue. But that debases the currency, and in the end destroys it. And, I'm going to need to see better answers to these points than "But MMT says it's true!"