3 ms·
In this 2019 Register article: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/07/03/reactos_windows_research_kernel_claim/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/07/03/reactos
by peter_d_sherman 7y ago
In this 2019 Register article:
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/07/03/reactos_windows_research_kernel_claim/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/07/03/reactos_windows_res...
"ReactOS 'a ripoff of the Windows Research Kernel', claims Microsoft kernel engineer"
We read that:
"Axel Rietschin, kernel engineer at Microsoft, has claimed that ReactOS, an open source operating system intended to be binary-compatible with Windows, is "a ripoff of the Windows Research Kernel that Microsoft licensed to universities."
Rietschin, who is currently "Senior Software Engineer (Windows Base Kernel, Container Technologies)" according to his LinkedIn profile, made the claim in late 2017, where it was apparently little noticed at the time, and has backed it up today with a post on Hacker News.
"I think it's a ripoff of the Windows Research Kernel that Microsoft licensed to universities under an agreement that was obviously violated by some, as the code has been uploaded to numerous places, some of it on GitHub.
"I glanced at the ReactOS code tree, and in my opinion, there is absolutely no way on Earth this was written from a clean sheet only from the available public documentation," Rietschin wrote.
He says that "internal data structures and internal functions, not exported anywhere and not part of the public symbols, have the exact same names as they appear in the Research Kernel."
In his recent post, he presents further arguments against ReactOS being a "clean room" implementation done without reference to the source code. "Macros names, parameters, etc. never appears in the compiled code. It is … almost surely impossible that a clean-room reimplementation ends up using macros for the same things, let alone macros with the same or similar names."
Well, this video can be thought of as the rebuttal by Alex Ionescu to Axel Rietschin.
And quite the rebuttal it is!
See, without the proper deep understanding, one could easily believe that what Axel Rietschin is alleging is true, as it seems believable enough.
But watch the video by Alex Ionescu, and see if you don't believe otherwise at the end...
I think the following quote captures one of his key points:
"o For malware, you usually don't have symbols (usually!)
-*For Windows, you do*"
But apart from Windows, there's also deep lesson in what Alex is saying, and it is as follows:
If there's a black box; a mystery, somewhere, wherever that is, whatever form that takes -- if one is willing to do the necessary research on it over long periods of time, and accumulate piecemeal pieces of information over that time, and do the necessary homework and legwork (in whatever forms those take), then eventually that mystery box will be opened.
This would also be equally true for mysteries in Math, Science, Physics, Engineering, and other areas in life too...
Alex, I applaud you in your work and diligence!
This is my new favorite video on HN!
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI suppose its possible that somebody did the reverse engineering. But Occams Razor says, it's more probable that it was as Rietschin is right?
- peter_d_sherman 7y agoYou might want to have a look at this old HN article, and the corresponding video: "How Diablo Was Reverse-Engineered Without Source Code" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20340406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20340406