Much of your comment could be summarised as “it’s no worse than prior tools”. That doesn’t invalidate the authors points though: just because it’s better than p

Much of your comment could be summarised as “it’s no worse than prior tools”. That doesn’t invalidate the authors points though: just because it’s better than previous tools, which have the same or worse problems, doesn’t mean notebooks don’t have problems that should perhaps be tackled or talked about. That it’s an improvement over what existed before doesn’t mean you can’t be critical about the flaws it still has and a study like this (looking at real people) and discussion like we’re having here is a necessary start to finding out how to improve on this.