2 ms·
What I dislike of criticism like this is, that it always operates on the underlying assumption that they have no idea what they are doing. Implying only the cri
by atoav 7y ago
What I dislike of criticism like this is, that it always operates on the underlying assumption that they have no idea what they are doing. Implying only the critics know how to calculate things and everybody who does renewable energy is fueled by blind ideology and therefore doesn't even bother.
Unless one knows the scottish plans this kind of criticism only brings one closer to becoming an armchair expert. So instead of actually pointing out a meaningful risk someone didn't calculate for in service of society, ones criticism becomes pure agitation and propaganda to the detrement of it.
And over time what started from a honest doubt can be quite dangerous, as can be observed in alternative medicine, where people first formulated their unease about aspects of the modern medical practise and moved quite rapidely to disregarding it completely and selling people sugar as medicine with real consequences.
- littlestymaar 7y agoI'm sorry but that's a straw man. It never relied on the assumption that they don't know what they are doing: they know it pretty well it has an economic cost in exchange for a political edge, and they know it only works if they are doing it first. And the criticism stays valid. > this kind of criticism only brings one closer to becoming an armchair expert. So instead of actually pointing out a meaningful risk someone didn't calculate for in service of society, ones criticism becomes pure agitation and propaganda to the detrement of it. I know the energy sector pretty well for multiple reasons and two years ago, I spent two weeks aggregating data and modelling the outcome of a full transition to renewable in the case of France[1] so I don't think I deserve your personal attack here. [1]: https://bourrasque.info/articles/20180116-moulins-%C3%A0-vent https://bourrasque.info/articles/20180116-moulins-%C3%A0-ven... in French unfortunately.