5 ms·
> has a goal to source the equivalent of 100% of its electricity demand from renewable energy sources by the end of this year. > production outstripping demand
by littlestymaar 7y ago
> has a goal to source the equivalent of 100% of its electricity demand from renewable energy sources by the end of this year.
> production outstripping demand on 20 out of 30 days and over the whole month providing 109 per cent of electricity demand.
Emphasis mine. This is a great summary of what really happens if you attempt to go full renewable on wind power: you don't control the supply so you need a foreign market to buy your excess production on windy days and to provide power the other days. And no, battery isn't really an option because you can have (and usually have, in anticyclonic conditions) weeks with low wind, and you won't get enough batteries to supply your country for one or more weeks. (I did a calculation for France bases on real power data 2 years ago, and it needed about 4 Tesla Model S battery per inhabitant).
- filmor 7y agoWind turbines are trivial to downregulate. The foreign market just allows you to shift the strike price for downregulation, making the generation in total more cost-efficient.
- littlestymaar 7y agoTechnically you can, but not financially: the advertised energy cost of wind power relies on the fact that turbines produce as much as they can, and in most European countries there has been contracts between windfarms owners and governments to guarantee a buying price, decorelated from the spot market price.
- thawaway1837 7y agoIt may be marketed that way in press releases, etc (although I don’t even think that’s true). But I bet you anything that the people investing in these projects, and the companies pricing their power and betting their future in them, are not doing it on the basis of selling every unit of energy generated.
- littlestymaar 7y ago> But I bet you anything that the people investing in these projects, and the companies pricing their power and betting their future in them, are not doing it on the basis of selling every unit of energy generated. Wind power has been subsidized a lot in Europe during the past decade, so for at least 80% of the projects, not only the investors cared about selling every unit being generated, but they even relied on them being sold at 3 times the market price!
- atoav 7y agoI don't see why buying external power in weeks with low wind is somehow against the rules — after all you would be stupid to have international power grids and not use them for exactly these purposes. Other than that I could imagine the three new pumped hydro projects that at least I heard of last year could also help with that.
- littlestymaar 7y agoBut that international market must rely mostly on something else than wind power, otherwise you don't have anything to buy (there is not so much independent wind regions in Europe). So in practice, a country running 100% renewable (on wind, not talking about Costa Rica running on hydro) ends up running on something like 60% renewable in the best case and the remaining is fossil or nuclear.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThere's just about zero chance of no wind even if you only consider the East and West coasts of Britain and Ireland. Both of which have colossal wind generation potential. Chances of the whole of Europe from Portugal to Romania, Malta to Finland being becalmed? Slim. :)
- littlestymaar 7y ago> There's just about zero chance of no wind even if you only consider the East and West coasts of Britain and Ireland. Almost zero chance, and yet it happens every year! > Chances of the whole of Europe from Portugal to Romania, Malta to Finland being becalmed? Slim. :) That's more true, byty that doesn't matter actually: 1- you can't expect one third of Europe to provide power for the whole continent when they are the only one with wind or you need to massively overdimension every country's power generation, to a point which is far from profitable. 2- the European grid don't work this way, you can't pump hundreds of gigawatts from one side of the grid to the other. Each link is only capable of transferring a few gigawatt at best from a country to another.
- xbmcuser 7y agoWorld spanning electric grids to me are good idea. As excess renewables can be utilized better which reduces carbon production. Singapore is planning to buy solar electricity with underwater sea cables from Australia which has a huge land mass for solar electricity production.
- littlestymaar 7y agoNote that solar doesn't have the same characteristics as wind: there's plenty of places in the world where you don't have weeks without sun while even the most windy offshore wind farm faces such events every once in a while.