5 ms·
> Just think if this level of marketing, lobbying, and energy was channeled into something like a national fiber broadband utility available to everyone. I mea
by rayiner 7y ago
> Just think if this level of marketing, lobbying, and energy was channeled into something like a national fiber broadband utility available to everyone.
I mean this is pretty much exactly why the government shouldn’t be in charge of deciding how to allocate this investment.
Fiber is far less useful than fast wireless. 60% of Maryland has access to fiber. It hasn’t been revolutionary in the least. Most people don’t even subscribe to it, even in high income suburbs. Meanwhile, over 15% of high income households are “mobile only.”
I think it’s fair to say that if you are computing using a tablet, you’re probably not benefitting much from fiber. Well, global PC sales peaked in 2010: https://images.app.goo.gl/4jwgmheZhp1S39EZ6 https://images.app.goo.gl/4jwgmheZhp1S39EZ6. Desktop PC sales globally are about the same as they were in 2001. The percentage of people using a computing device that can take advantage of fiber continues to shrink.
- wtallis 7y agoWhen the "fast wireless" under discussion more or less requires deploying FTTC as the backhaul, consumers definitely stand to benefit from transforming that into a regulated FTTH network instead of being further subjugated by cellular carriers.
- tptacek 7y agoIsn't the cost difference between running fiber to base stations and running fiber to individual homes enormous? Just based on the economics: a fiber-lit base station serves anyone nearby with a mobile device, while the infrastructure to support FTTH is a risk (and, apparently, an unprofitable risk) based on how many homes sign up. I don't think base station backhaul and FTTH are comparable investments.
- wtallis 7y agoIf we're talking typical suburban housing density, deploying 5G mmWave will require digging trenches or hanging wires on poles through almost as many properties as deploying FTTH. A 5G basestation is going to be a lot more expensive than a GPON ONT, probably enough that the per-customer costs aren't a net win for 5G. (When the fiber is already at the mailbox, taking it down the driveway too just isn't that much more investment.) And the 5G basestation faces the same problem as FTTH that not every person in the neighborhood will be a guaranteed subscriber to any particular provider; even if Verizon/ATT/etc. already has you under contract for your smartphone, they have to work on convincing you to add all your wired devices to the plan. Barring detailed cost estimates to the contrary, I don't see how mmWave will be viable in suburban America. Sub-6GHz 5G will be, but that's not going to be providing dramatic speed upgrades or price/Mbps improvement the way FTTH has. In a denser urban residential setting, mmWave certainly won't have enough penetration to provide solid service to high-rise apartments, and it's even less likely that sub-6GHz 5G will have enough aggregate capacity to kill off wired ISPs. mmWave simply isn't viable for residential/fixed usage, and sub-6 is only an incremental improvement that brings cellular performance up to WiFi speeds, but not beyond.
- rayiner 7y ago> If we're talking typical suburban housing density, deploying 5G mmWave will require digging trenches or hanging wires on poles through almost as many properties as deploying FTTH. This is far off base. Conservatively, a mmwave base station has a range of about 1,500 feet, covering about 7 million square feet, or 160 acres. Median subdivision density is about 2 houses per acre: https://www.nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?sectionID=734&genericContentID=253886 https://www.nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?sectionID=734&gener.... So one base station can cover 300 houses. For comparison, an N+0 cable node (a node where the fiber is close enough to the houses to require no amplifiers on the coax side) is 50-130 houses. Cable companies have been running N+0 nodes all over the place, but have been hesitant to build the fiber all the way to the premises. That should tell you a lot about how expensive that next increment is.
- wtallis 7y ago> Conservatively, a mmwave base station has a range of about 1,500 feet, At what speed? If that's just the range at which it stops being an upgrade over current LTE speeds, that's really unimpressive. The figure of interest here is the range at which mmWave can reliably sustain WiFi-like performance, including enough aggregate capacity for gaming to still have low latency when all your neighbors and one or two of your family members are streaming video. > That should tell you a lot about how expensive that next increment is. Not really. Cable companies are upgrading their networks by replacing some of the coax in the ground with fiber, as necessary to get enough backhaul bandwidth to each node. The incentives there are wildly different than for a new ISP that's either deploying FTTH or short-range cellular, without having access to pre-existing last mile wiring that has no trouble carrying gigabit to each customer. For wired infrastructure, digging the trenches is a lot more expensive than the materials cost for whatever you're putting in the trenches.
- rayiner 7y agoTesting of the Houston Verizon deployment is showing near a gigabit at 2,000 feet: http://wirelessone.news/8-high-frequency-mmwave/981-2-000-feet-verizon-5g-field-test-nlos-often-close-to-a-gig http://wirelessone.news/8-high-frequency-mmwave/981-2-000-fe... As to your second point, the whole point of wireless is you avoid the need to dig trenches. Getting the last 500 feet through a subdivision is a huge pain in the ass. I had Comcast install fiber to my house a couple of years ago. It took the contractors half a day to run fiber 1,700 feet on the pole down the main road, another half a day to run it 300 feet to the pole outside my house, and another half day to run it 30 feet under my driveway. With 5G they could’ve stopped after the first step and served the whole subdivision (200 houses).
- AdrianB1 7y agoWhat is the cost for residential fiber there? In my country (Europe) it is about $9 per month for 1 Gbps, minimum guaranteed speed of 100 Mbps. For working from home it is way more than enough and much more reliable than "mobile only".
- rayiner 7y agoVerizon charges about $80 for gigabit fiber. But to put that into context, most of the states in Verizon’s footprint, like Maryland, New Jersey, and Virginia, are richer than Switzerland: https://images.app.goo.gl/PeQYfKDsLkHoJ3787 https://images.app.goo.gl/PeQYfKDsLkHoJ3787. It looks like prices for gigabit in Switzerland range from $65-140 USD per month (with the $65 figure being over Zurich’s municipal fiber system.) At least here in Maryland, its not cost that limits the uptake here, it’s usefulness. Cable broadband here is very fast. Comcast charges more for 1000/35 cable than Verizon charges for 1000/1000 fiber, even in neighborhoods that have access to both (which is most of the state outside Baltimore and very rural areas). People just don’t value the extra upload speeds that highly compared to Comcast’s better TV packages.
- apexalpha 7y agoThis is off-topic but I found that the more you dive into the methods used to compare income on both sides of the Atlantic the weirder it gets. Average tends to be skewed to America's favour because of an extremely rich top 5% or so. Median is closer to each other but also seems to favor the US. But then do you account for the fact that Americans work longer hours? Or not? In my country the average workweek is 29 hours. In the US it's 38 I think. And most Western EU countries are in between these two. And European also have more paid leave on average. And you can also use disposable income, which is what you can actually spend, so seems like a fair comparison. Then the US wins again, but on the other hand Americans also have to use this income for stuff like out of pocket healthcare costs, education costs, emergency-unemployment fund etc, where in Europe these things are mostly covered by taxes. But that means your disposable income is lower. But on the other hand buying stuff is usually more expensive in EU because of the VAT system.
- soylentcola 7y agoAs one of the other 40%, I'd love to have fiber to my house. As you mention later in this thread, I pay Comcast more per month for a fraction of the speed and have no better options. The vast majority of my personal (ie: not at work) computing is done at home. Whether I'm using my desktop workstation (wired), my laptop (either wired or wifi), or a tablet/phone (wifi), I would benefit if the WAN connection serving my home network offered gigabit speeds. At work I already have fiber-level speeds. I don't need my phone to stream music faster in the car or pull up search results faster when I'm out at the store. LTE is more than sufficient for that stuff and I can buy a reasonable allotment of data (5GB) for $30 each month. At home I don't want my local network's connection to the outside world depending on signal strength, data caps, or the whims of cell-service-style billing practices. And I don't care about TV packages or any of that. Between OTA (free), Netflix ($150/yr) Prime Video (included with $120/yr Amazon Prime), and whatever free stuff is on YouTube, PlutoTV, and news sites, I have plenty of stuff to look at when I feel like being a lump on the couch.