4 ms·
The article is on point. 5G has an advantage in only a few situations: - Very crowded areas, where you need lots of microcells so everyone can watch streaming
by Animats 7y ago
The article is on point. 5G has an advantage in only a few situations:
- Very crowded areas, where you need lots of microcells so everyone can watch streaming video at once. Like stadiums. Verizon is making a lot of noise about 5G in NFL stadiums. Amusingly, latency for sports video is a big deal, because, in sports bars, not all the screens have the same amount of buffering in the path. So some people are cheering while others are waiting for their feed to catch up, and they feel left out and alone.
- Moderately remote areas where the capability to drop to the VHF bands will provide some service far from towers. That's actually useful.
Claims involving public safety and remote surgery are fantasy.
Besides, once it's going, it will probably be overloaded, and there will be rate caps and data caps. But the capped service will be called "unlimited".
- gsich 7y ago"Overloading" will come later. Similar to LTE before, customers don't have 5G capable devices yet. There is also no need to buy one.
- Spooky23 7y ago5G is a strategy to replace wireline service and the regulatory limits imposed on them. Carriers selling fixed 5G will be able to monetize traffic more effectively.
- the8472 7y ago> - Moderately remote areas where the capability to drop to the VHF bands will provide some service far from towers. That's actually useful. It does? Wikipedia lists the lowest 5G frequencies at 600MHz, which is above the VHF band.
- culturestate 7y ago> in sports bars, not all the screens have the same amount of buffering in the path Assuming we aren't talking about personal devices, could this be solved at install time by ensuring same-length cable runs the same way you would for e.g. HFT tenants in a datacenter? Or is this a different kind of problem?
- thakoppno 7y agoIt is essentially the same problem. A sports bar may have some tvs hooked up via Comcast and some via DirectTV with noticeably different physical layer lengths. Additionally, the modern OTT services resemble personal devices and trade synchronicity for scalability.
- culturestate 7y agoThat makes sense. Assuming a bar probably maintains multiple subscriptions because they need access to both local and national broadcasts, I wonder if there's space to build a platform designed specifically to aggregate video content across providers and distribute it to commercial customers. I'm imagining an OTT service that specifically bids for (or sublicenses) public performance rights for e.g. sports and sells only to public venues, with hardware designed for this purpose. Thinking about it, this seems like the kind of thing that probably already exists in some specific niche.
- wtallis 7y agoIn this case, it's not about cable length, but the number of boxes the data has to travel through before hitting the screen. Cable length matters on the nanosecond scale. For human-noticeable latencies larger than 0.1 seconds, you can only blame buffers where data sits around not moving.
- BurnGpuBurn 7y agoNobody is asking the obvious question: Why would you go to a stadium or sports bar to watch sports on your phone. Didn't you just travel all the way to the stadium/sports bar to not have to watch sports on your phone? And also. So if stadiums and sports bars would fix their wifi, does that negate the need for 5G completely? Remote areas are soon to be better serviced by satellite constellations anyway.
- ksec 7y ago>5G has an advantage in only a few situations... That completely misses the point of 5G, which is capacity. 5G network capacity improves on 4G / 4.5G / 4.9G or their respective 3GPP Rel. Most people simply look at 5G as mmWave + 4G when it is far more. The world is divided into 5G is overhyped useless pieces of junk, or overhyped to be using Level 5 AV and Remote Surgery. Reality it is simply a much better 4G. And that is good enough as it is.