5 ms·
The relevant number here is the cost to repave, not reconstruct, which is about $330,000-$350,000 per mile for a minor arterial road in a rural or urban area.
by rayiner 7y ago
The relevant number here is the cost to repave, not reconstruct, which is about $330,000-$350,000 per mile for a minor arterial road in a rural or urban area.
As to how small towns afford it--you don't repave that often, and you focus efforts on what to repave. For example, Cedar Rapids, Iowa calculated it would cost $500 million over 10 years to repave everything that needs to be repaved: https://www.kcrg.com/content/news/Annual-road-repaving-to-start-next-week-in-Cedar-Rapids-507227201.html https://www.kcrg.com/content/news/Annual-road-repaving-to-st....
Cedar Rapids has about 53,000 households, so that's about $943 per household per year. To put that into perspective, we can do a calculation. 18% of DC metro area commuters use Metrorail. If you take 18% of the 2.2 million DC metro households, that's about 400,000 households (roughly) using Metrorail. The rail capital budget is about $1 billion annually, so about $2,500 per household per year. Excluding the cost of new rail cars, its about $1,500 per household.
(Obviously this is a very back-of-the-napkin calculation, but it puts things into perspective.)
[1] https://www.wmata.com/initiatives/budget/upload/FY19-Proposed-Budget.pdf https://www.wmata.com/initiatives/budget/upload/FY19-Propose... (p. 76)
- notatoad 7y agothe "$2,5000" typo is an extra 0, not a comma in the wrong place. $1b/400k = $2500 per household for more perspective, cedar rapids average income is $54,465 per household, compared to $99,669 for the DC metro area.
- rayiner 7y agoThanks, yes, the extra zero was a typo.
- Drunk_Engineer 7y agoThat's a very apples-oranges comparison. DC commuters benefit from Metrorail even if they don't use it. And the Metrorail capital budget is for much more than just trackway (i.e. railcars, buses, parking garages, etc).
- zaroth 7y agoOf course the metro riders also benefit greatly from roads. It’s almost like it shouldn’t be all one or the other.
- Symbiote 7y agoRemember in this comparison that a metro line has significantly higher capacity than an average road, and the metro cost includes the vehicles, fuel and drivers. Also, the uncosted externalities (CO₂, air pollution, accidents, noise) are significantly lower for the metro.
- njarboe 7y agoI know of a 4.5 mile stretch of small rural road in the California foothills was recently repaved for about $400k. It would be great if the variance on these numbers were also given.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoYeah. If my experience in towns and small cities of highly varied affluence is any indication I would guess that road maintenance costs swell to fit the available budget. My parents retired somewhere nice (read: wealthy) and there was recently a big stink at the town meeting because they wanted to repave a road that doesn't need it to the tune of a mil or so and it was an obvious handout to a well connected paving/construction company.Meanwhile my city (who's name is synonymous with urban blight if you ask my parents neighbors) bought a pavement milling attachment for a skid steer (an item that costs less than a pickup truck) and it made the regional news because they're known for being so tight with money. I could go on but I won't since you get the picture.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoObviously this is a very back-of-the-napkin calculation, but it puts things into perspective. You're comparing an all-inclusive capital budget versus simply repaving roads. How much does DC Metro spend on track maintenance annually? How much does Cedar Rapids spend on lighting and signage? How much do Cedar Rapids residents spend on their cars? The average used car payment runs in excess of $4,800 annually. New cars run around a hundred or so bucks a month more. The DC metro is a bit of an odd duck since a large chunk of its users don't actually live in DC. The Census Dept. puts metro ridership at about 21% of all commuters commuting into DC, and overall about 34% of all DC residents use public transit (of all modes) as their primary means of transportation. So even though you're including the cost of things like stations and vehicles, I think the overall cost is much closer (if not slanted in favor of transit) than you're letting on. That said, rail is typically one of the most expensive modes of public transit.
- rayiner 7y agoGood point--I forgot WMATA is in the middle of major rail car purchases. The 6-year plan for rail systems, track rehabilitation, and stations is $600 million annually. I've updated my numbers above accordingly.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoAgain you're making an apples to oranges comparison. The metro budget also includes expenditures for bus and paratransit service, station improvements, fare collection modernization, fire alarm upgrades, information technology projects, police services, and so-called "business support investments". Per the budget the plan is to spend at most $249 million annually (less for most years) on track and structures rehabilitation. That's the closest you'll get to a repaving budget and includes things beyond track maintenance and replacement. With that in mind the six year plan would call for per-capita spending of between $335 and $620 annually, cheaper than repaving the roads.
- rayiner 7y agoI excluded those items from the Metro budget. I included signaling and stations, because those are a necessary part of subway maintenance that don’t have much of an analog with roads. (Traffic lights must be maintained, but train signaling systems are very complex and very expensive to maintain in comparison. There are millions of feet of wiring throughout the Metro system and each track segment is wired up for the traffic control system to work.) In any event, the point isn’t to say that road paving is cheaper, but to address GP’s question, which is how cities can afford it. It’s an order of magnitude comparison to put the number into context. (For one thing, the road maintenance budget for Cedar Rapids is overstated by a factor of two, because I used the projection of what the city thinks it ideally needs to spend rather than what it does spend.)
- clarry 7y ago> The relevant number here is the cost to repave, not reconstruct, which is about $330,000-$350,000 per mile for a minor arterial road in a rural or urban area. Sounds a tad more expensive than it needs to be. Skimming search results for my country (.fi), I get numbers ranging from 30 000 to 50 000 eur per kilometer. I know murican roads are wider, but I don't think they're that much wider. And I don't think we're particularly effective or cheap at doing it..
- viuphiet 7y agoI think it's because everything is far more spread out in the US.
- clarry 7y agoI don't understand why that would make a fixed length of road be so much more expensive, unless commute time for blue collar workers is compensated better than lawyers. Shipping a truckload of asphalt plus the required machinery can't be that expensive.