3 ms·
Antivirus was more necessary back in the days when firewalls and security elevation privileges were rarely enabled on consumer machines. But more modern securit
by jcranmer 7y ago
Antivirus was more necessary back in the days when firewalls and security elevation privileges were rarely enabled on consumer machines. But more modern security software has rather weakened the value proposition for AV, and they've started branching into areas that aren't really helpful at all and sometimes counterproductive (e.g., web browsing protection--your AV does a much, much worse job of validating TLS than browser vendors do).
Given the dirty things that AV does to "work" correctly, you can characterize modern AV as malware that tries to keep other malware out.
- tptacek 7y agoI don't think this is true. Generally, I think that privilege levels are a red herring, and that being able to get malware running at the privilege of the user installing it is sufficient; to the extent that this is changing, it's changing only recently. I'd say that the problem with AV is that it has never worked at all; it's always been a "deck chairs on the Titanic" performative spot clean situation – at best, a smart team that reimages a machine with a confirmed "infection" can say they're using AV as a weak sort of host intrusion detection system. AV or no AV, for as long as I can remember (back into the 1990s), if your desktop is "infectable", you're screwed. You'd think that the Summer of Worms would have confirmed that for everyone, but AV is an extremely powerful marketing product category, because of its built-in per-seat multiplier.
- cpach 7y agoI’m curious when you say AV, do you also include solutions such as Windows Defender/Windows Defender ATP/CrowdStrike Falcon in that category?
- marrs 7y agoDo they have a 100% track record of preventing viruses from being installed on your system? Once your system is compromised, it's compromised. There's nothing the AV can do. It's the OS (and to a lesser extent user practice) that's going to limit the damage.