5 ms·
Once again so many people are piling in with the "Google cancels everything" trope. But the official blog post states it was due to "low usage" [1] after 18 mon
by crazygringo 7y ago
Once again so many people are piling in with the "Google cancels everything" trope. But the official blog post states it was due to "low usage" [1] after 18 months of general availability.
Obviously, as well-intentioned or well-designed as it may have been... the product was a dud with users. I mean, did anyone here ever use it? Or know someone non-technical who did?
So obviously they got the product wrong, somehow. This isn't a beloved product like Reader... it looks like it was a dud. And they're trying again with the other suggested alternatives, since "no-code" still has promise.
I fail to see how this is any different from a startup that doesn't gain traction and shuts down. What do HN'ers think Google should do when a product is a dud without enough users and no clear path to success can be found -- if not cancel it? At least they're still supporting it for another full year (so users can find other solutions), which is almost as long as it existed for in the first place.
[1] https://gsuiteupdates.googleblog.com/2020/01/app-maker-update.html https://gsuiteupdates.googleblog.com/2020/01/app-maker-updat...
- Jasper_ 7y agoMaybe nobody used it because they couldn't trust it to be around for a long time?
- achillesheels 7y ago18 months is nothing and indeed consistent with their short-sightedness. For instance, Saastr affirms it takes 2 years to find market fit. Real products (ie non digital) take years to organically compound in the market. The repeated product shutdowns demonstrates misaligned incentives in the org, of more or less glorified project management padding for promotion versus long-term (5+ year) product development roadmaps. This is why I am not a GOOG investor.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- agentdrtran 7y agoIt was a dud becuase Google did not advertise it, did not invest ANY resources in training people on how to use it, and did not add any significant updates to the product in its entire existence.
- mqus 7y agoI somewhat agree with your point but what does "low usage" mean if you're Google? In comparison to their other services 100k people[0] are not many. For a startup/small business they certainly are. [0] made up, could be much lower, of course.
- crazygringo 7y agoFor any company anywhere, it's going to be relative to the costs of running it. There's no such thing as absolute low/high usage for Google. There's simply different thresholds for enough usage for a product that takes 1 engineer to maintain, 10 engineers, 100 engineers, or 1,000 engineers. Google isn't going to have hugely different metrics here from a startup. Either a product justifies its profitability or it doesn't. Aside from minor details, doesn't substantially matter if it's a 50-person team inside a MegaCorp, or a 50-person startup.
- bcrosby95 7y agoYou're missing opportunity cost in your calculations. That is significantly different for Google vs a startup vs a small business. It isn't enough to make "some profit" in a mega corporation. The profit compared to the resources invested has to be of a similar magnitude to their primary business, or else they're wasting resources. Things are axed all the time for not being profitable enough.
- crazygringo 7y agoBut the same is absolutely true for VC. They're not looking for 2x returns, they're looking for 10x returns. And VC-funded startups are the right comparison to make here. Are they any less ruthless about pulling the plug on something that can't show any probable path to required growth? (I think it goes without saying that neither Google nor VC's are trying to fund lifestyle businesses, the way a mom-and-pop bootstrapped startup might be.)
- draw_down 7y agoBut which is the cart and which is the horse? Was it shut down because people didn't use it, or was usage low due to people avoiding it because they knew it would be shut down, leaving them stranded?
- ollerac 7y agoIt had one of the worst landing pages in the industry. You couldn't tell how it worked or what it did or how it might be useful. Google goes full-tilt on some products (Stadia/Chrome/GSuite) and leaves others to die. What kinds of startup -- in any industry -- gets traction after only 18 months and $0 marketing budget?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- purple_rain 7y agoConcur
- judge2020 7y agoIt doesn't help that it wasn't available for the tier 1 $6/mo GSuite orgs; companies paying for business/enterprise likely already had better software that did what app maker did.
- am262327 7y agoIndie developer here, working in education. AppMaker was extensively used by some folks where the low maintenance offered was very attractive. I know of many people who were starting to make major investments in the platform. I was engaged with Google about spreading the value of the service. I told them I was worried about the graveyard. Education moves much slower than other industries. 18 months is nothing. One year to sunsetting is tomorrow. I believe Google owes me an apology. I can live with the usual technical debt reasons, low usage reasons for needing to shut something down. But they have to do it in way that doesn't put a massive amount of work into the lap of those users who DID use it. I'm literally so busy at this now that I barely have time to even respond to the general internet. Instead I've been writing to the mailing list.