2 ms·
The first flaw with this argument is that consensus ethics are deliberately engineered anyway, usually by people with the money to finance PR and propaganda ope
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
The first flaw with this argument is that consensus ethics are deliberately engineered anyway, usually by people with the money to finance PR and propaganda operations.
So the idea that (e.g.) libertarians have a free choice about what they believe is - ironically - not even close to being true.
The second flaw with this argument is that all of these positions could, in principle, be tested objectively.
The best possible outcome for true general AI - also the least likely in practice, but not impossible in principle - is that it could provide definitive answers to matter-of-opinion ethical questions.
And it could do this not just in terms of incomprehensible statistics, but as comprehensible narratives derived from explicit arguments.
In fact a hyper-AGI would know which arguments to use to be most persuasive and convincing - which isn't particularly reassuring, but it would be an inevitable outcome of hyper-AGI.
- logicchains 7y ago>The second flaw with this argument is that all of these positions could, in principle, be tested objectively. What is the objective measure by which you would test them; against what standard? And by what standard is that standard the best standard to use? By what measure in turn is that standard the best measure to use? It's impossible to find a truly objective standard due to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regress_argument; https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regress_argument; a standard can only exist if defined circularly or upon some arbitrarily chosen axioms. A superintelligent AI can't somehow wave away the laws of logic, any more than it could prove that 1+1=3.