4 ms·
>I'm guessing below 5%, but I think this level of preparedness would be a good goal for most people who can afford it. I never understood this attitude (very c
by coldtea 7y ago
>I'm guessing below 5%, but I think this level of preparedness would be a good goal for most people who can afford it.
I never understood this attitude (very common in the US popular culture for one), or the same idea about stocking food, utilities, ammo and such, and taking of to some kind of bunker for emergency scenarios (from a storm, to "when the government comes", to the zombie apocalypse or similar).
While it's prudent to be prepared as a family, it's even more prudent (and it's always missing even as a though from such descriptions, posts, etc) to push and make sure your country/city/community is prepared.
It's the complacent "everyman for themselves" mentality I don't understand.
And with such a mindset, most of these "everyman for themselves" won't last a day. They'd have their stuff stolen, or even be killed, by people with more guns and larger teams. That you have guns yourself wont matter much, they'll have more, or smoke you out, or kill you from afar when you're not aware they're even watching you, or any other such technique.
If the prevalent idea for making it safe, is going at it alone (as a single person or family unit), then others will be all for themselves too, and if they can get ahead by screwing you, they will. Harder for them to do so when a community works together and shares their preparations.
- golergka 7y ago> It's the complacent "everyman for themselves" mentality I don't understand. It's a classic prisoner's dilemma game: you don't know what's the winning move is until you see what others are doing. And this kind of preparation is just getting ready in case this prep is needed. Hope for the best, prepare for the worst, and etcetera.
- coldtea 7y agoThat would make sense if efforts were made and posts were written about making the state/city/community more prepared. Of course, one could always prepare for themselves too. But most I've chanced are mostly ignoring the community/city/etc aspect, and go directly to the "how I, personally me, and my family at most, will survive, and screw the rest of them suckers". At best they don't think they can influence the community/city/etc preparedness (or think it's already great). At worst, they don't care as long as they are prepared.
- golergka 7y agoThere's already a whole population which pays taxes and funds the community effort. Your family side of the equation, though, is empty by default.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoPrisoner's Dilemma posits that you can't talk to the other party. In most real life situations, you can talk to your neighbors and what not. I used that fact to good effect during my divorce, which involved no lawyers and was amicable. So I have first-hand experience with how well it can work to actually talk to the other party instead of waiting to see what they will do and reacting, based on an unnecessary assumption that it's clearly a hostile situation and we will be enemies.
- golergka 7y ago> you can talk to your neighbors There's over a thousand people living in my building, and a lot more in just a few hundred meters around me. I have very similar experience with my divorce, but I don't think I would be able to effectively communicate with this community, or to trust all these random people.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSorry, I can't really relate. I'm dirt poor. I attend public meetings and do pro bono work trying to help make my community healthier and better. I don't think I need to personally speak individually with the thousands who live in my town to do something constructive or to effectively communicate with people around me.
- jefftk 7y agoThis isn't a prisoner's dilemma: you benefit from preparing even if no one else prepares.
- golergka 7y agoIf you prepare, and your preparations were unnceccessary, you just spent a lot of resources for nothing. (Of course, this could start a whole converation aboud hindsight and a priori knowledge, but point still stands).
- jefftk 7y agoThis is just the nature of risk, it's not about defection and cooperation.
- jefftk 7y ago(author) In a disaster I would help my neighbors, which is also what you see in most real disasters. Having supplies let's me do that. We have tenants downstairs, and when I figure out supplies I count them too. While I don't try to store enough of things for the whole neighborhood, it often makes sense to get extra ones. A community where individuals are prepared is a community that is prepared as a group. I'm not opposed to the government preparing for disasters or anything, but that's also not where I would spend my advocacy efforts (I think there are other policy changes that would be more impactful).
- coldtea 7y ago>In a disaster I would help my neighbors, which is also what you see in most real disasters. Having supplies let's me do that. This also means that your supplies are limited to your individual capacity -- and diminish when you help neighbours that haven't any (whereas the community could organize and make sure everybody puts in and eventually gets their share, or redistribute as needed, etc.). >A community where individuals are prepared is a community that is prepared as a group. A community that is prepared consciously as a group though is even better (and doesn't prevent individuals for adding their own extra preparations). But this needs communication and coordination. Without communication one doesn't need know whether their community is one of "prepared individuals" (and not e.g. one where only them and a few others are). So I don't think that "a community where individuals are prepared" is as good as "a community that is prepared as a group". Besides the necessary communication and coordination (to ensure individual members are indeed prepared, and not just a few), a community prepared as a group is a more cohesive community, explicitly set to help each other in such times - making hoarding and conflicts for resources less likely.
- gumby 7y agoI think of it as defense in depth. Civil institutions are indeed the place for disaster preparedness but in an actual disaster there will be transient problems of recognizing the problem, distribution (say) water, etc. in an earthquake immediate first aid may be needed when ambulances may be overloaded or sent to more critical locations etc. Worrying about managing complete civil breakdown and indefinite self reliance seems absurd to me, especially in an urban setting.
- kerkeslager 7y agoUltimately I do agree, the people that will survive in a post-apocalyptic scenario are the ones who can collaborate as a tight group. Pre-existing trust is much more effective preparation than any bunker or stockpile. However, there's no shortcut to creating a tight group. If the zombie apocalypse comes and you just go to your neighbor and say, "Hey, we'll have a better chance of surviving if we collaborate!" there's nothing that keeps him from saying "Sure, let's collaborate!" and then killing you in your sleep and taking your stuff. And in fact, from his perspective, there's nothing that's keeping you from saying what you're saying and then killing him in his sleep and taking his stuff, so he's got a strong reason to do that to you before you do that to him. And I don't think that just living next to someone and saying "Good morning" is enough to counteract that. You have to actually know someone at a deep level, and have shared ideology, and possibly even shared trauma, before you're willing to take a risk trusting them with your life. One of my frustrations as an atheist is that there's not really a cohesive atheist community, but I don't really see how their could be: we don't have a cohesive ideology (beyond "there's no god") and no real shared goals. If the SHTF, my guess is that the groups that will survive will be the religious groups, the gay community, the addiction/alcoholism recovery community, the military and veterans, immigrant communities and various groups that cross over between those: all these are large groups with cohesive group identities, and in some cases shared trauma that has given them opportunity to be there for one another.
- homonculus1 7y agoWhat a backward take. The real complacency is "I will do nothing to prepare individually because a community response plan is hypothetically more ideal". Well, if you're involved with such a program then it would add to the discussion to share the details. There's always a social critic when this topic comes up but it always seems to coincide with complete inaction, which makes it look like an excuse to defer responsibility. In the meantime other people have found that it saves a lot of bureaucratic headache and provides a lot of personal security to have their own, nontheoretical plans in place. Which is always an advantage over the alternative even if there are larger community plans too.
- scottlocklin 7y agoThe US still has a frontier mentality. It's embedded in our culture, and in the case of groups like the Mormons, it's actually part of their religious obligations[1]. If you've been outside of the coastal urban cores, you can understand why: the place is huge, mostly empty, and most of it, the climate can be extremely hostile (compared to, say, central or southern Europe -northern Europe actually has something like US prepper culture). The US also has racial fault lines which have periodically broken out into civil insurrections and outright warfare; the last Indian wars were in the 1920s [2], and inner cities periodically break out into riots. It's fairly well known that general social trust in the US is on a precipitous decline, which of course encourages this sort of thing. A consequence of the size and frontier mentality: the US also has a huge hunting and gun culture. Tens of millions of people actually hunt, and many tens of millions more people have hunting family and friends or do similar outdoors activities that encourage the "prepper" mentality of being able to survive in the wild without any help from civilization. Western Europe, for contrast, has a comparable population and about a third the number of hunters, and the history of hunting in Europe (maybe aside from France) is more of an upper class game preserve thing than a frontier thing. Americans also have a fundamental mistrust of government. Lots of fairly rational reasons for this. Many people live fairly far away from any real government officialdom. You aren't far from police or firemen or animal control in a big city. If you live in the countryside, believe it or not, coyotes might eat your children. A guy 100 miles from me, in a fairly urbanized area, had to strangle a coyote who was trying to eat his kid[3] just the other day. Also, generally speaking, the US civil services do not have a reputation for diligence or efficiency. The types of people who are into prepper mentality generally falls into the set of people who has profound mistrust for government's ability to provide any social services efficiently in event of a disaster or in any other situation. For recent history, various civil defense initiatives have also encouraged the tendency: in the 1950s peak cold war, many otherwise normal people built nuclear fallout shelters in their back yards, encouraged by the government and the media. We don't have those cool centrally planned underground parking garages the Europeans built to deal with this sort of thing. Ham radio is also a part of all this: there are nearly three quarter of a million active amateur radio licensees in the US, and all receive some formal training in disaster preparedness. "Preppers" are a cultural part of all these tendencies. Maybe their preparations seem silly or misguided, but it's deeply American in the same way the Blues, free speech absolutism and PTA meetings are deeply American. I suspect it will fade with increasing urbanization and social pressures, but it will always be there in some form. Heck, we even have chain stores which cater to this outdoors/survivalist mentality[4]. I myself am half redneck and kept a bug out bag ready when I lived in Berkeley (an earthquake zone). I wasn't envisioning holding off hordes of cannibal hippies after my canned goods; more like hiking into the woods and living off pemmican and the local animal population for a week or two until the shortwave said to come back. There are a few recent history events which seem to justify this sort of thing; floods where city officials fled and fishermen provided emergency services[5]. [1] https://mormonrules.com/list/mormon-rules-emergency-preparedness https://mormonrules.com/list/mormon-rules-emergency-prepared... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Indian_Wars#Last_conflicts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Indian_Wars#Last_conf... [3] https://abcnews.go.com/US/hampshire-father-strangles-coyote-attacked-child/story?id=68412201 https://abcnews.go.com/US/hampshire-father-strangles-coyote-... [4] https://www.basspro.com/ https://www.basspro.com/ [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cajun_Navy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cajun_Navy
- kragen 7y ago> While it's prudent to be prepared as a family, it's even more prudent (and it's always missing even as a thought from such descriptions, posts, etc) to push and make sure your country/city/community is prepared. A friend of mine is active in the San Francisco Fire Department Neighborhood Emergency Response Team. The first and most important thing NERT teaches you to do is to be individually prepared with stocks of emergency supplies in your house. So I think your criticism is exactly backwards. Given things like https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/briannasacks/puerto-rico-warehouse-disaster-supplies-discovered https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/briannasacks/puerto-ric... or the concentration camps that were set up after Hurricane Katrina, it seems like even in everyday disasters it would be imprudent to assume the government will step in and save you in the US. And of course nobody who sees how the SF cops treat the homeless has any illusions about the benevolence of the local government toward the vulnerable. Here in Argentina it would be even more imprudent. The government is apparently incapable of reliably delivering even basic public utilities like electricity and water even without disasters.