I agree with your stated goals, but I'm less convinced Go gets this totally wrong. It has the nice property that a string is a string is a string -- a slice of

I agree with your stated goals, but I'm less convinced Go gets this totally wrong. It has the nice property that a string is a string is a string -- a slice of bytes. The only exception is raw strings which as part of source code are defined to be UTF-8. So, while there's a tradeoff in elegance I do think it's logically very simple. I do think the Rust approach for example is more "correct", but it's also tedious to work with and I think the ergonomics matter (can't speak for swift).