3 ms·
My order-of-magnitude detector went off at "0.02 million", it's 0.27 million, which still makes your point https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1.6+million+20
by jazzyjackson 7y ago
My order-of-magnitude detector went off at "0.02 million", it's 0.27 million, which still makes your point
https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1.6+million+2020+dollars+in+1973 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1.6+million+2020+dolla...
- kragen 7y agoWolfram Vertical Line Alpha is terrible at citing sources, perhaps unsurprisingly given its own provenance, but it says it's using one of the BLS CPI deflators, which to my way of thinking systematically understate inflation over long periods of time; but there isn't an objectively correct deflator to use. If you instead use a basket of commodities made to the same standard in 2020 and 1973, such as crude oil, coal, or gold, it comes out closer to 0.02.
- dragonwriter 7y agoYes, if you use exhaustible resources which become more expensive to extract relative to labor, sustainable goods, and everything else over time simply because the cheapest to extract are already extracted, you get a deflator that ridiculously overstates general inflation far more than any reasonable argument could be made that the headline CPI or any other commonly-used consumer inflation measure understates it.
- kragen 7y agoMost gold in circulation today was mined before 1973, and it turns out that referencing to coal gives you the lowest inflation rate among these commodities. By contrast, the mainstream expense whose cost gives the highest inflation estimate is university tuition, which involves extracting no resources whatsoever. So your off-the-cuff guess about the reason for this discrepancy is not only incorrect, but apparently entirely divorced from the truth.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> and it turns out that referencing to coal gives you the lowest inflation rate among these commodities. ...and its still, over the period in question, a significantly higher rate than headline inflation. > So your off-the-cuff guess about the reason for this discrepancy is not only incorrect It wasn't an off-the-cuff guess and, as even the lowest-inflation extractive resource in the set inflated significantly faster than headline inflation, you haven't shown it was incorrect. (Also, that most gold was extracted before the period doesn't matter, current extraction is still a supply factor that influences price [though “they aren't making any more” would be an extreme version of the same effect, so even if it all was extracted before the period in question, that fact would reinforce rather than negate the description.])