6 ms·
Dual Uprisings Show Potent New Threats to Arab States
- tokenadult 16y agoThis article includes astounding details about how Arab democracy movement activists used new technologies to organize their movement internationally. It also mentions little-known connections to writers and movements in other, non-Arab countries. The phenomena described could sweep the world.
- Vivtek 16y agoThis is the twenty-first century I signed up for.
- Joakal 16y agoUnfortunately, it sounds like 'terrorists' invented it first as part of a guerrilla campaign.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoDon't count your eggs too early, this has yet to play out fully. The Iranian uprising is either still simmering or largely ineffectual. Algeria has apparently degenerated back to despotism. And it's too soon to see how Egypt will develop. On the whole though, these are positive signs. People in the Arab world are taking an active role in their governance. They are having discussions about the role of government and of liberty. They are being more and more exposed to reporting and information from other countries. Compared to the state of things a mere decade ago, this is a vast improvement.
- Vivtek 16y agoI don't care - those honking horns on Friday will make me happy for months. Just let me assume we're headed into the Kim Stanley Robinson future I so very much want, OK? I haven't felt so hopeful about this lump of wet rock since the Berlin Wall came down.
- zalew 16y agoMr. Obama ended the call, the official said, with these words: “I respect my elders. And you have been in politics for a very long time, Mr. President. But there are moments in history when just because things were the same way in the past doesn’t mean they will be that way in the future.” I can't recall a single dictator in the modern history of the world which would fall down without US interference. People's engagement and activism is hard to undervalue and for sure the revolution is in their hands, but when I came across lots of such comments http://i.imgur.com/7u8xk.png http://i.imgur.com/7u8xk.png I was really disappointed how people tend to easily forget history.
- afshin 16y agoThe Shah of Iran was a dictator who only came to power because of an American/British orchestrated coup. He was overthrown against American wishes, and the government that came to exist in Iran is reactionary and hostile to the West as a direct result. This is a case of a homegrown movement to overthrow a dictator. The resultant government is not necessarily what the West would prefer, but that is a consequence of being (rightly) seen as the funders and supporters of both the previous dictator and the instigators of the war waged by the next-door neighbor (Saddam Hussein's Iraq, whose military was entirely funded by Western powers and was once among the most powerful in the world).
- zalew 16y agoI know the story, I'm quite interested in Iran, so I'm surprised myself I didn't mention it as an exception, but here the only reason is US was the opposite (overthrown) side this time. Good point.
- _djo_ 16y agoDo you have a citation for the claim that Saddam's military was 'entirely funded by Western powers'? To my knowledge there was never any direct funding of Iraq's military by any Western state during the Saddam era. The West was certainly not averse to selling weapons to the country, though neither was the Soviet bloc. During the 1980s the Iraqi air force was equipped mostly with French aircraft, and the army mostly with Soviet tanks, vehicles and weapons in addition to a smattering of weapons from other sources such as 100 G5 155mm howitzers from South Africa. But it need not be said that selling weapons to a country is very different to funding its military.
- mkramlich 16y agoOne thing I noticed about the recent Egyptian events that few have mentioned. Folks in Egypt gather in Tahir Square and protest for almost 3 weeks, Mubarak still in power. Obama administration on Thursday then basically gives an ultimatum to the senior Egyptian military leadership, and bang, the next day Mubarak has "resigned". Lesson: huge props to the Egyptian people. But also give credit to the US administration. They didn't have to do what they did. Also, the follow-in issue being that probably the biggest reason why we had such strong leverage over Egypt was the billions in military aid we give them annually. To a government run by a dictator. Leverage is good, but backing dictators is bad in the long run, despite short term benefits.
- zalew 16y agoThey didn't have to do what they did. Since when the US doesn't have to join/start political changes in strategic regions? Let's wait what will be going on during the upcomming elections - US and EU have to an will take a big part in this game. To a government run by a dictator. Leverage is good, but backing dictators is bad in the long run, despite short term benefits. Oh, come on, a lot of dictatorships overthrown with US help where good buddies before.
- Joakal 16y agoSeems to be correlation does not equal causation here. What if Mubarak needed 18 days to move his money offshore or a myriad of other reasons? Obama administration could have simply saw the government deteriorating and joined the crescendo of calls. Joining the bandwagon doesn't give them any more credence than the many other countries and people in the world demanding Mubarak to resign. They all deserve as much credit.
- mkramlich 16y agoHopefully the events in Egypt will serve as a model for people in all the other Middle East, Arab and Muslim dictatorships. If they don't want a foreign country or coalition to come in and topple their regime then, well, they need to do something domestically to make it happen. Otherwise it's hard to whine. Pick your poison.