5 ms·
It appears that few companies have benefited financially as much as Apple Inc from literally decades of outside FOSS development (bsd etc). Are new Apple softw
by mistrial9 7y ago
It appears that few companies have benefited financially as much as Apple Inc from literally decades of outside FOSS development (bsd etc).
Are new Apple software engineers still asked to sign a paper that they will not contribute to FOSS at any time during employment? Are they legally bound from discussing the existence of that agreement?
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI don't think you can be legally bound not to discuss the existence of an agreement. Your employment contract can say things like confirming the existence of this agreement can be grounds for dismissal, and that might hold up, but if it said something like you can be sued for confirming the existence of this agreement I think the courts would consider that non-binding. However as I am not a lawyer, any lawyers here can comment on that?
- mushufasa 7y agoyou can have a nondisclosure agreement about a business relationship. that's pretty common. nondisclosure is not the same as denying it exists -- you just can't volunteer the topic / information.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoOk normally I'm aware of non-disclosure agreements concerning trade secrets. But I don't think you can have a non-disclosure agreement that says you cannot admit this non-disclosure agreement exists. This would also be generally problematic if you are being asked things that you cannot disclose, then you cannot disclose why you cannot disclose them.
- ComputerGuru 7y agoI don’t know about employment contracts, but Google around for info about National Security Letters and gag orders. It’s certainly a thing, at least when the other party is the federal government.
- novok 7y agoI think, out of a matter of function, you can talk about even NSLs and such with your attorney and company's lawyers. I would imagine key employees would have to know about NSL letters too, otherwise it doesn't really work?
- ComputerGuru 7y agoSource? I know plenty of people working at Apple that are the core contributors to FOSS projects. The only thing I can find is this, from the Apple developer agreement (for using their SDK and publishing on their platform, not working there): > 3.3.22 If Your Application includes any FOSS, You agree to comply with all applicable FOSS licensing terms. You also agree not to use any FOSS in the development of Your Application in such a way that would cause the non-FOSS portions of the Apple Software to be subject to any FOSS licensing terms or obligations.
- _bxg1 7y agoThat just sounds like a copyleft-avoidance policy, which nearly any tech company is going to (reasonably) have
- ComputerGuru 7y agoThat’s my point.
- kick 7y agoApple is a bad actor in contributing back to free software; however, they do contribute back. Granted, it's by throwing things over the wall in a way that's usually after upstream and it have diverged so much it can no longer be upstreamed, but still under free licenses.
- ComputerGuru 7y agoUnless something furthers the development of their ecosystem, eg all the llvm contributions.
- scarface74 7y agoYou mean like every other for profit company.....
- kick 7y agoThey released launchd under a free license, and it was one of the most interesting developments in the past two decades, despite it not actually contributing to the development of their own ecosystem to free it.
- scarface74 7y agoThis is old news where the Khtml people were complaining about WebKit.
- kick 7y agoA situation I remember well (and bitterly)!
- vnorilo 7y agoOne FOSS project I follow, LLVM, has quite a few folks from Apple actively and constructively participating.
- judge2020 7y agoI don't see someone affirming that the clause exists but if it did, LLVM would probably be different since it's the backbone of xcode and iOS app development.
- ralph84 7y agoIt’s a tautology that the biggest tech companies have benefited the most. Microsoft generates more revenue from Linux (via Linux VMs on Azure) than any Linux company ever did.
- zaphirplane 7y agoTech companies benefiting and quantifying how much they give back to FOSS aside LLVM, cups, Swift, WebKit of the top of my head. WebKit pretty much laid the foundation to IE’s death, web standards kid of becoming a thing again and innovation to the web (I think at some point MS reformed the IE again) LLVM is pretty much everywhere Perhaps you can browse https://developer.apple.com/opensource/ https://developer.apple.com/opensource/
- Hayvok 7y agoApple has open source projects it actively maintains, like FoundationDB, so this is just patently untrue.
- jldugger 7y agoThis is a bit hyperbole. The employee intellectual property agreement is pretty much 'we own everything you do[1]', same as every other company. So you're at the whim of legal and director approval for CLAs. There are numerous teams contributing to OSS projects, a small smattering of which can be found under Apple's own Github: https://github.com/apple https://github.com/apple However, folks undergoing software engineer training could be forgiven for this impression, as the training is very OSS hostile. Some of this is understandable, as the two major concerns are corporate engineers plagiarizing OSS, and accidentally giving away patents, both of which are massive liabilities to be avoided. And yes, the company is very allergic to GPLv3, for a variety of reasons. My recollection is that all the tech companies don't like it or its companion, AGPL. You'll note that many of the GNU tools shipped predate GPLv3. [1]: Unless you live in California and comply with all the gotchas of that one loophole.
- mistrial9 7y ago"we own everything you do" -- is not the same as "every other company" .. flatly false "You are at the whim of legal (dept)" -- true numerous teams contributing to OSS -- true, like LLVM ; how many software engineers work at Apple? "training is very OSS hostile" -- true software patents -- lets talk about that later plagiarizing OSS -- certainly a serious concern on both sides of this chat very allergic to GPLv3, .. AGPL -- why is that? surely the rules of GPL, by the third version, are pretty well understood.. Apple Inc benefits quite a bit from say, the Internet .. Thank you for this reply -- I believe that this factual parent response does address each point, but in a voice that makes it sound like it is all ok and expected. But you see, its not all ok and not all expected. How much money is enough money, Apple Inc ? What is the world we are creating here?
- jldugger 7y ago> "we own everything you do" -- is not the same as "every other company" .. flatly false This is not a commonly held position, but maybe we can use a third party to mediate the dispute. Joel Spolsky has written on the subject not that long ago[1]: > So before you hire this developer, you agree, “hey listen, I know that inventing happens all the time, and it’s impossible to prove whether you invented something while you were sitting in the chair I supplied in the cubicle I supplied or not. I don’t just want to buy your 9:00-5:00 inventions. I want them all, and I’m going to pay you a nice salary to get them all,” and she agrees to that, so now you want to sign something that says that all her inventions belong to the company for as long as she is employed by the company. > This is where we are by default. This is the standard employment contract for developers, inventors, and researchers. So let's meet in the middle: it is an uphill battle to get an employer to assign IP created 'off the clock' to you. Even when I was working for a public university, for a department dedicated to supporting open source, they had me sign an IP agreement. I don't have the text of the contract to quote you, but as I recall it was the same 24/7/365 overreach. Amusingly, this leads to a substantial conflict; I hear tales of people circumventing the policy by using a personal email account to land things upstream. [1]: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2016/12/09/developers-side-projects/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2016/12/09/developers-side-pr...
- prepend 7y agoNot sure how that’s possible since Apple is a big contributor to tons of stuff, https://developer.apple.com/opensource/ https://developer.apple.com/opensource/