8 ms·
Night train connecting Amsterdam to Scandinavian capitals under consideration
- Numberwang 7y agoIt would be awesome, but don't they know there is a bit of water between Sweden and Finland?
- jacquesm 7y agoI'd love for one connecting through the Baltics to Helsinki. That would unlock a huge part of Europe that is right now only accessible via airtravel (if you value your life).
- krzyk 7y ago> huge part of Europe that is right now only accessible via airtravel (if you value your life). What do you mean by that? For who it would open, Baltics or Fins?
- jacquesm 7y agoFor everybody that does business in the region. Helsinki<->Tallin<->Riga<->Vilnius<->Warsaw<->Poznan<->Berlin<->Hannover<->Amsterdam would be a very useful connection to have. East of Poznan road travel gets more and more dangerous, especially with the winter weather thrown in. Being able to visit those parts of Europe year round without having to go by air would be something I would definitely make use of, especially on an overnight connection.
- marapuru 7y agoWow, that looks like a great route. I had to check it on a Map to see what shape it would make. It has a nice curve to it :) https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Helsinki,+Finland/Tallinn,+Estonia/Riga,+Latvia/Vilnius,+Lithuania/Warsaw,+Poland/Pozna%C5%84,+Poland/Berlin,+Germany/Hannover,+Germany/Amsterdam/ https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Helsinki,+Finland/Tallinn,+E... I'm travelling from The Netherlands to Berlin next week and although the train is comfortable. It's a bit annoying that it has so many stops in between. (taking the DB train, not the high speed one).
- jcranmer 7y agoThe route you're talking about is basically Rail Baltica (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_Baltica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_Baltica) and the Helsinki-Tallinn Tunnel. The first project is agreed upon in theory, and the latter one is also included on long-range plans, although there is some criticism of the project on grounds such as financial feasibility and other issues (like the tracks being the only 1435mm track in these countries, who normally use 1520mm (or 1524mm) gauge).
- iso1210 7y agoVery easy safe route, leaving lunchtime on Tuesday from Amsterdam will get you the ferry from Travemünde Tuesday evening (depart 3AM wed morning), arriving 0900 Thursday morning in Helsinki
- krzyk 7y agoEast of Poznan? I leave east of Poznan and the roads are good in winter, even when we have more snow than the recent winters. Most drivers know how to behave in such conditions and drive more slowly (and have winter tires). And roads are mostly kept in good condition (if you allow 1-2 day after first heavy snow during winter). Not sure how the conditions are in other countries during the winter.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- iso1210 7y agoWhy does valuing your life have to do with it? It takes a fair bit of time, but there's a ferry to Helsinki from Germany that takes a day, a 5 hour train from Copenhagen to Stockholm, an overnight ferry Copenhagen to Oslo etc.
- jacquesm 7y agoHave you ever driven from Amsterdam to Riga? I have. It's not something I care to repeat. Several near misses on such a distance is not something that I care for.
- iso1210 7y agoTrain to Stockholm and then ferry to Riga 7AM Wed day trip arrives 2340, stay overnight, then get the 5PM Thursday evening ferry to Riga, arriving Friday morning.
- willvarfar 7y agoHolidays in the sun seem to be out of fashion in Sweden right now. Everyone is talking and doing hemesters and tours within Sweden. Trains to Hamburg would be really popular for nearby tourism.
- null_object 7y agoThis was definitely true last summer, when it was trendy to flight-shame. But human nature being what it is, the itch to travel to the sun is inevitably creeping back, and I’ve noticed several colleagues returning from breaks in Bali, Goa, Thailand and Sri Lanka. They just don’t talk very much about it.
- _Microft 7y agoIs hemester a play on words with hemma and semester, i.e. a vacation at home? Edit: Yes.
- clarry 7y agoI wonder how they planned to route from Stockholm to Helsinki. Going around the gulf is a damn long sidetrack (1700 kilometers). I feel rather disconnected from central Europe since the only practical way to get there involves flight or ship or a detour via St. Petersburg. On that front, this seems like an interesting project: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki%E2%80%93Tallinn_Tunnel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki%E2%80%93Tallinn_Tunne... I'd love to take a cozy train to hamsterdamn.
- jpalomaki 7y agoMaybe not related to this, but some time ago there were some thoughts about Hyperloop between Stockholm and Helsinki [1]. [1] https://hyperloop-one.com/fs-links-case-study https://hyperloop-one.com/fs-links-case-study
- pw6hv 7y agoI am also very interested to know their solution to link Helsinki to Stockholm by train. It would be nice also to hear about this project from other sources too. Anyway, having even just a Stockholm-Amsterdam night train would be great. But unfortunately I am not very optimistic on that...
- towb 7y agoI remember reading about ideas of a hyperloop tunnel between Stockholm and Helsinki a few years ago, that would be something! I would go to Finland more if that was a thing. Or just a regular underwater train tunnel! One can dream ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Edit: Aw, second... Stared too long at the map to figure out the best route and took too long to post.
- kds3 7y agoThere is also an option to take Stockholm-Turku ferry (10 hours overnight) and Turku-Helsinki train (2 hours).
- jcranmer 7y agoGoing via Åland is definitely practicable--the eastern side is about 80-90 km of shallow sea, which means you need basically a series of trestle bridges similar to the Florida Overseas Railroad (which was 200 km end-to-end). The western side is more difficult, since it's 40km at its narrowest point, which is slightly longer than the Channel Tunnel, and most of the sea appears to be about 200-300m deep. But if you detour around a bit more to the north, you could again use a trestle bridge for most of it, and use a large bridge only to cross the deepest portion of it. The point is crossing via Åland is firmly in the category of "we've crossed these kinds of gaps before."
- tdons 7y agoYes, please. I fondly remember taking trips on the night train to France when I was little. Rail is a great semi-long distance (<= 500mi/800km) mode of transportation in general. It's unfortunate that it's so expensive to construct (high speed) railways.
- marapuru 7y agoIs it really that much more expensive as an airport, or asphalt travel? I'm just curious whether you have found some pricing details somewhere :)
- elric 7y agoRail networks require land for tracks. Acquiring new land for new networks is very expensive. Airspace is sort of abundant. Both modes of transport require a lot of energy. Airline fuel is apparently virtually untaxed. Train operators, on the other hand, pay the full price for electricity.
- lucb1e 7y agoAs a Dutchman, I would 100% use this. Been meaning to see more of Scandinavia (without flying there for pollution reasons) and I've also been meaning to use a night train after reading an article about it via HN, both for about 2-3 years now, but haven't gotten around to either yet!
- etrautmann 7y agoI appreciate your emphasize on reducing flying. This seems like an unfortunately rare attitude though perhaps changing quickly.
- melling 7y agoIf we reduce flying by half, how much would that reduce the climate change problem? The world is still generating an incredible amount of electricity using coal. http://h4labs.org/ive-got-another-stupid-idea-to-deal-with-climate-change/ http://h4labs.org/ive-got-another-stupid-idea-to-deal-with-c... I was pleasantly surprised to see BlackRock recently come out against coal: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jan/16/blackrock-coal-divestment-regulation-fund-manager https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jan/16/blackr...
- ryder9 7y agoso we do nothing? attitudes like this don't help
- melling 7y agoI didn’t say that we do nothing. We have a few large problems like coal that have been known for decades. https://www.google.org/rec.html?theme=greenz_dev https://www.google.org/rec.html?theme=greenz_dev We’ve lost another 15 years and the now the idea is to guilt people into reducing a few percent a year. Do the math. It’s not going to work.
- perfunctory 7y ago> If we reduce flying by half, how much would that reduce the climate change problem? You could say that about any sector of the economy. while coal is responsible for more ghg than aviation at the moment, air travel keeps growing. In general, there is no one low hanging fruit to solve the climate crisis. It will take lots and lots of different solutions all across the board. And just because BlackRock came out against coal, it doesn't get you off the hook.
- _Microft 7y agoI've never used one but imagining to go by night train from one part of Europe to another gives me a feeling of travelling somewhere as experience instead of it being a chore where being-en-route rather feels like not-being-there-yet.
- Analemma_ 7y agoFor my next vacation I’m planning on taking the train from Seattle to San Francisco, for exactly this reason. I’ve told people about this and they all think I’m crazy: “It costs as much as flying and takes 22 hours, why would you do that?“ But they’re not getting that the train ride is the point.
- gboss 7y agoDo it! The coast starlight is great. I have taken it a few times from Los Angeles to Oakland. It is so relaxing, the diner car is great and so is the observation car which is a fantastic place to camp out with a book. I've been meaning to take it up to Seattle. I'm sure it's beautiful going through Oregon and Northern California. When you take it to Los Angeles you go right by vendenberg air force base and the Space X and Nasa hangers.
- edoceo 7y agoAnother upvote for this plan. I'm from the East Bay, in Seattle now, train is great to get down there. The time can be productive too. And the view is great.
- fock 7y agoanother point is that by having to use more time for long distance travel, the relation between the substantial energy cost and the travel time becomes more reasonable from a "what if everyone uses the possibility to travel long distances for cheap" perspective
- jlengrand 7y agoI used to take the night train to go back to my parents as a student back in France. Was a nice feeling, having a bed and reading a good book during the night while enjoying the scenery and the relaxing sound of the tracks under you. I really miss it and would love doing it again. They removed those trains like 10 years ago.
- pjmlp 7y agoAs someone that loves to travel by train, I would appreciate to have this opportunity, but as prices usually go on European wide trains, I doubt that the prices would be competitive to flying. :\
- wvh 7y agoI once tried to plan such a train trip – I travel semi-regularly between Scandinavia and Central Europe – and while I wouldn't mind to take a two day trip as a bit of an adventure, the price was prohibitively expensive. This is a nice idea though, I could see it being popular if they manage to keep the price reasonable. The journey itself could actually become part of the experience.
- timwaagh 7y agoi think this nightline trend is largely pointless. there isnt much traffic between these aside of a bunch of tourists. but that doesn't mean i wouldn't use it, once or twice. scandinavia is the kind of place i like to hate for trying to be better than everywhere, but would like to see anyway, just in case i am wrong and it actually is. what we do need is high speed infrastructure to more cities and metro lines in more cities if we want to improve accessibility. Edit: having actually read the thing, i see this is an extension of an hsl line to groningen. i'd love to see that line happen. and if the night train becomes an hsl as well, maybe the project isn't quite so doomed from the start. after all, a one hour trip on the hsl would make commuting between amsterdam and up to Bremen possible.
- elric 7y agoYou might enjoy reading these articles about how high speed rail is detrimental to the European rail network. 1. https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2013/12/high-speed-trains-are-killing-the-european-railway-network.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2013/12/high-speed-trains-ar... 2. https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2013/12/high-speed-trains-are-not-sustainable.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2013/12/high-speed-trains-ar... Sleeper trains are the best in my opinion. You board, shut your eyes, and when you wake up, you've arrived. No wasted time. A lot cheaper and a lot more pleasant than this "high speed" malarky. Especially now that "high speed" has come to equate "invasive security checks".
- timwaagh 7y agoyour opinion is not the only possible opinion. I used the hsl to paris once. it was amazing. In three hours i was home and could go on with my life. a plane would not have been faster. paris is a little bit too far to commute these days but one would imagine people will use it to commute to brussels. that's also the real weakness of sleeper trains: they are only useful for tourists. whereas most trains are being used for home-work commute.
- eCa 7y agoNight trains generally don't do high speed due to comfort issues. Once the fixed link across Fehmarn is completed I would guestimate the travel time between Amsterdam and Stockholm to be about 12 hours or so, perfect for dinner on the train and then a good night's sleep. Also, if the scheduling of the train is properly constructed, I would assume quite a few people from Finland, Sweden and Denmark working in Brussels would take that train regularly. "scandinavia is the kind of place i like to hate for trying to be better than everywhere" I think you might enjoy reading[1] :) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante
- Freestyler_3 7y agoIs Finland now officially Scandinavian? Or is this some other Helsinki they speak of. Looks like a nice project, then I don't have to drive up anymore.
- cpach 7y agoNo not really AFAICT. It’s part of the Nordics though.
- runarberg 7y agoTechnically Finland is not a part of Scandinavia, but neither is Iceland nor Greenland. However Finland is very much a part of the Nordic Countries (and so is Iceland and Greenland, et al.). And people sort of use the terms “Scandinavia” and “The Nordic Countries” interchangeably, as the distinction isn’t that important[1]. So for for all intents and purposes (barring being pedantic) Finland is a part of Scandinavia. [1]: I’m not an expert on this, but I doubt there are many inter-Scandinavian cooperation happening any more that excludes the other Nordic Countries.
- cpach 7y ago⇧ What he said :)
- perfunctory 7y agoStupidly enough the width of the railway track is not the same in all European countries. Notably, relevant for the article, it's different in Finland. But also in Ireland, Portugal and Spain. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_gauge_in_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_gauge_in_Europe
- jcranmer 7y agoAll of the HSR systems in Europe have standardized on 1435mm. (The highest-speed line in Finland is the 220km/h link between Helsinki and Laht, which is on the slowest end of high speed rail). The integration of the Baltic states into the European HSR system, Rail Baltica, including the Helsinki/Tallinn tunnel, are planned to be 1435mm.
- Arnt 7y agoHas that tunnel moved beyond the "wild dream" stage? https://www.dezeen.com/2019/11/21/zaha-hadid-architects-ulemiste-terminal-rail-baltica-network/ https://www.dezeen.com/2019/11/21/zaha-hadid-architects-ulem... BTW. I'm definitely going to go there, by train, the year Rail Baltica is finished.
- rexpress 7y agoVariable gauge trains help overcome this problem: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_gauge https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_gauge I once took a night train from Barcelona to Paris that changed gauge at the border. It slowed to a walking pace and travelled through a shed like structure that housed the equipment. There was some mild clunking and clanging from underneath as we slid over the mechanism. Quite impressive.
- dboreham 7y agoIs a night train the same thing as a sleeper? Night Bus Sleeper Train, no?
- lqet 7y agoI cannot understand why they aren't more night trains. For me, it's the perfect way to travel. You have your own room which you can lock and do whatever you want, you have a bed, some storage room, a table, a sink, and if you spend a little more money, you even have a shower. I enjoyed using night trains when I was single, I enjoyed them as a couple, and I enjoy them very much now as a father, as it is basically the most comfortable way to travel with small children. For inner-European travel, it is often cheaper than flying, but much more comfortable. Who cares if takes 12 hours to Kopenhagen if you are sleeping 8 of them, and relaxing on a bed with your laptop, eating breakfast or looking out of the window drinking wine for the remaining 4. You arrive fresh, relaxed, with brushed teeth and shaven and you do not have to worry about getting into town from the airport, because the train station will usually be near the town center. The problem seems to be that their once glamorous image has been lost. At least in Europe, they have gained a somewhat dubious reputation over the last decades. Deutsche Bahn stopped their night train services 2 years ago, they sold if off completely to the Austrian Federal Railways (ÖBB), which now run it with a profit. Their idea? Clean up the trains, fix the reputation and attract families. As a passenger, I am happy about that, they are also planning to extend the network. As a German, I am a bit sad that the Austrians are now running our night trains, but providing train services does not exactly seem to be the main area of expertise of Deutsche Bahn. PS: in case anyone is wondering, this is what a standard 2 bed night train room looks like in Europe (only one bed is flipped out): https://fidelgastro83.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/img_1272.jpg https://fidelgastro83.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/img_1272.j...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- paulryanrogers 7y agoTook a night train in central Europe once. It was a lot of money, and to reserve a whole compartment was even more. And if you don't get the whole compartment the other travelers may talk at all hours of the night on the phone... Then there are border crossings where they check passports. Such checks make it impossible to get uninterrupted sleep.
- 7y ago
- dr_dshiv 7y agoI missed yet another easyJet plane from Berlin last month. Damn gate closing 45 min before flight. Anyway, I took a night bus from Berlin to Amsterdam. Among the many amenities on the €30, 9 hour Flixbus were Ukrainians with excessive amounts of liquor to share. I arrived at 7am, 3 hours earlier than the next plane or train.
- fock 7y agonot sure, what's requiring billions of euros, a full, factory new train (e.g. classic cars and a locomotive) built for relative high-speeds on existing rails (e.g. maxing out at 160 to 200km/h) costs around 20-30Mio euros iirc (Austrian Railjets). If you go the used, traditional car route, you are more realistically looking at 10Mio euros max. So: the only problem is getting your route approved by all states network operators, which is a complex problem of congestion, neglect and slow, european style processes. Case in point (no joke): a hotel sued the Deutsche Bahn because some train tracks were not operating within the permitted legal framework. Now you say: that's a democratic, rule-of-law society. I say: the train has been there for 90 years, no living human has ever been at a disadvantage because the state pushed trough with the train without proper permissions... And of course, the rail needs to be high speed, because otherwise the environment, rail service companies and people could actually profit from the latter rediscovering how cheap and nice train travel could be... (for example: a single ICE (german high speed train, which generally goes 160-200km/h, because there is no dedicated high-speed-track) costs at least thrice the aforementioned Railjet and also more maintenance (higher safety margins for higher speeds) - now talk about the high cost of car/bus-rivaling rail again)
- throwawaysea 7y agoIntercity rail is great. In Germany it allows people to self select the density and lifestyle they desire, while still working in bigger agglomeration. I can see this being a big economic and quality of life benefit.