5 ms·
Even given your second point, I would argue with the first, given that I think that globally, the company is more thought of when someone sees the word "Amazon"
by fastball 7y ago
Even given your second point, I would argue with the first, given that I think that globally, the company is more thought of when someone sees the word "Amazon" in 2020 than the rainforest.
- celeritascelery 7y agoThat’s exactly the situation the South American countries what to fight against.
- fastball 7y agoSo it's not AMZN that wants to own the word, it's South American countries that want to do so, even though they have no more right to it than the company.
- anoncake 7y agoOf course they do simply by virtue of being sovereign countries rather than some corporation.
- onion2k 7y agoThey had the word first. That is a compelling argument. Imagine I start a company today called "America" (I'm in the UK). My business is wildly successful and grows to the point of being a global unicorn that can afford gTLDs. Should ICANN allow me to own .america? A lot of people would argue I shouldn't..
- fastball 7y agoThey did not have the word first. Amazon was first used to describe warrior-women from Scythia.
- neiman 7y ago"the amazon": thought of the rainforest/river (only) "amazon": thought of as either the rainforest/river or the company. I really dunno what does the world population think of that though (no one knows really).
- vhvjkyhkogvv 7y ago> the amazon I think of tall female warriors
- anoncake 7y agoIf tall female legendary Greek warriors show up and make a claim to the .amazon TLD, we should consider their claim. So far they haven't.
- perl4ever 7y agoThe river was named due to a European associating it with the mythical warriors.
- anoncake 7y agoGo on?
- perl4ever 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francisco_de_Orellana https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francisco_de_Orellana "The name 'Amazon' is said to arise from a battle Francisco de Orellana fought with a tribe of Tapuyas. The women of the tribe fought alongside the men, as was the custom among the tribe. Orellana derived the name Amazonas from the mythical Amazons of Asia described by Herodotus (see The Histories [4.110-116]) and Diodorus in Greek legends"
- anoncake 7y agoI was (vaguely) aware of that but what difference does it make here?
- fastball 7y agoThe point is that the word "amazon" (which is what is being bought as a gTLD) was not first used in South America, so they have no claim to it beyond "we use it too". Which isn't a good claim, otherwise they should've/would've been able to prevent Jeff Bezos from calling the company Amazon in the first place.
- peterwwillis 7y agoThat's not even the important point. Ownership of a domain name doesn't have to do with who is more of the owner of the name, nor whether the name is "etymologically pure", or whose use of the name is more popular. The entire right to own a domain (or TLD) is based solely upon ICANN's Uniform Dispute Resolution Process, and any established case law which exists in your particular jurisdiction. So this thing that the majority of the world's communication and commerce is dependent upon is adjudicated by a private entity in a single country that makes its own rules.
- perl4ever 7y agoIs it wrong to think of the mythical warriors? Also, maybe someone should make a modest proposal to Bezos to rename the company "Orellana".