4 ms·
seems to be the fairly common take among economists/tech folks about inequality being fine along as wealth grows, we're not living in a zero-sum world etc. Pro
by Barrin92 7y ago
seems to be the fairly common take among economists/tech folks about inequality being fine along as wealth grows, we're not living in a zero-sum world etc.
Problem with that attitude is that it's mostly circular and asserts its conclusion. Inequality does not matter because social well-being and so on is only a measure of absolute wealth, so the only thing left is to show that wealth is growing etc.
It's worthwhile to question the assumption which people like Robert Sapolsky have done.[1] One thing that he figured out is that even when one accounts for the worse material outcomes of inequality like worse healthcare access, there is an extremely large difference in outcome based on inequality itself. Gaps in social hierarchy matter and inform how people perceive their environment and their place in society. Compressing inequality itself may drastically increase social and individual well-being as inequality appears to induce significant stress in human populations.
The same is true for many studies about happiness. Happiness is indeed influenced by material wealth, but to a significantly smaller degree than one might imagine. Countries like Germany and Nigeria, for example, report similar levels of happiness even despite being magnitudes apart on some wealth and econ metrics.
the key point I want to make is that, even if one disagrees with some particular data points or conclusions, the effect of inequality must be studied at a biological/social / well-being level if one wants to make meaningful statements. Asserting that humans are Homines oeconomici and using it to justify inequality is a tautological exercise.
[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-economic-inequality-inflicts-real-biological-harm/?error=cookies_not_supported&code=c3cbc5b9-01dc-4ca8-8a23-537f4a6d5da0 https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-economic-ineq...
- rapind 7y agoThey way I think of this is that everything is relative. Happiness is a product of success and expectations. When everyone around you is rich it influences your expectations thus reducing your happiness (except for buddhist monks?) and driving you to great success or potential despair. So it really is a zero-sum game unless (until) we evolve some enlightenment where expectations are fixed. We'd be content, but would anything ever get done? Does it matter? Sounds like a sci-fi topic. Of course this is a super simplistic way to see it. Both success and expectations have many contributing factors themselves.
- closeparen 7y agoThank you for saying this. I'm bookmarking it for the next time I hear "no one is saying we should make everyone poor." When I talk about the anti-inequality people preferring a third-world standard of living as long as no one else has it better, they typically call it a strawman. I appreciate the admission that this is actually your belief.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoExactly nowhere in that post did barrin92 say that we should make everyone poor. You seem to be reading into it something that is not actually there. In another post, you refer to this comment and say that it said that we should go back to being hunter-gatherers. That is even less there.
- closeparen 7y agoThe argument about Germany and Nigeria is to say that absolute standard of living doesn't matter much, and the rest of the post argues that relative position does. What part of the characterization "preferring a third-world standard of living as long as no one else has it better" is unfair? To be charitable, I'm sure the parent would appreciate a high uniform standard of living even better. But he seems to find the situation I describe preferable to the current state of things, which is pretty wild.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThe argument about Germany and Nigeria is to say that absolute standard of living doesn't matter much to happiness. > What part of the characterization "preferring a third-world standard of living as long as no one else has it better" is unfair? All of it? Barrin92 explicitly notes "the worse material outcomes of inequality like worse healthcare access". > But he seems to find the situation I describe preferable to the current state of things, which is pretty wild. Not at all. That's you reading into what was said; Barrin92 said no such thing. What he said was that inequality, by itself, causes worse outcomes. He didn't say "therefore go back to hunter-gatherer societies". He didn't say "therefore go to third-world societies". He said that, even after you account for the negative effects of poverty, there are additional negative effects from inequality. No actions were proposed other than to stop assuming that inequality itself has no consequences. Everything beyond that is you reading into Barrin92's comment, and is on you, not him.
- bransonf 7y agoRobert Sapolsky is a genius. His work relating psycho-social phenomena to physiology is profound. Other thinkers in the realm (albeit different expertise) are Gabor Mate and Stephen Porges. I think there’s a natural inclination for any species to become hierarchical, but it’s a problem when those at the bottom of the hierarchy do not have their basic need of safety met.