2 ms·
Not really, what they did is basically summarize all the various research related to genes. It was mildly useful, but more so as just a way to easily have some
by prepend 7y ago
Not really, what they did is basically summarize all the various research related to genes. It was mildly useful, but more so as just a way to easily have some surveillance as new research came out.
You may argue that it’s not useful, but saying it’s not safe is hyperbole as there is no evidence of danger or misuse and there’s been like 10-15 years for horror stories to come up.
I would like some way to automate my scanning of research for genes related to me. 23andme sort of does this again, but for years they didn’t.
- smt88 7y ago> saying it’s not safe is hyperbole It absolutely is not hyperbole. Any test that leads to unnecessary treatment is unsafe. That list typically includes anything with false positives. For example, excessive testing for certain cancers (like breast cancer) lead to higher death rates. Here's a concrete example where poorly-understood genetic testing has led to unnecessary surgery, which is obviously not safe. https://www.webmd.com/breast-cancer/news/20170412/misunderstood-gene-tests-may-lead-to-unnecessary-mastectomies https://www.webmd.com/breast-cancer/news/20170412/misunderst...
- prepend 7y ago> Any test that leads to unnecessary treatment is unsafe. The AMA argues against letting patients run their own lab tests too, and fortunately lost. While it is possible that people could make mistakes using their own data, but this is rare and certainly the data being available is a net positive for people. Using your definition, wouldn’t it be more dangerous to only make the information available to rich people and prevent the information being available affordable? $100 for webmd is much cheaper than the tens of thousands it would cost to consult with specialists, counselors, and gps. We need to look for ways to lower healthcare costs, not scare people about hypothetical dangers that just happen to be solved by very expensive tests and consults.