3 ms·
> So the Clean Water Act says the EPA can regulate ”the waters of the United States,” which is defined consistent with “navigable waters,” contemporaneous with
by jcranmer 7y ago
> So the Clean Water Act says the EPA can regulate ”the waters of the United States,” which is defined consistent with “navigable waters,” contemporaneous with Congress’s Commerce Clause authority over navigable waterways. The Obama EO extended it to include even small bodies of waters like ponds, such that farmers would have to get EPA permits to make modifications on their own land that was nowhere near navigable waters.
That is a rather distorted view of the water. Note that the definition of "navigable waters" is explicitly laid out in the law (33 USC §1362 (7), for exact reference) as:
> The term “navigable waters” means the waters of the United States, including the territorial seas.
This has been generally interpreted to include at least pretty much all non-ephemeral streams in the US, and ephemeral waterways are rather more questionable. See, e.g., Rapanos v US, decided in 2006 (i.e., before Obama took office).
- rayiner 7y agoThat’s not a correct reading of Rapanos. Rapanos says that “the meaning of ’navigable waters’ in the Act is broader than the traditional understanding of that term, SWANCC, 531 U. S., at 167; Riverside Bayview, 474 U. S., at 133.3 We have also emphasized, however, that the qualifier ’navigable’ is not devoid of significance, SWANCC, supra, at 172.“ Rapanos doesn’t define exactly what navigable waters are, but casts sharp doubt on two types of waters: ephemeral streams, and wetlands without a surface water connection to navigable water. The key changes to the 2020 rule are to exclude those things: https://www.eenews.net/stories/1062159101 https://www.eenews.net/stories/1062159101 > Specifically, the new rule will erase protections for so-called ephemeral streams, which flow only after rain or during snowmelt. > The rule also erases protections for wetlands that do not have surface water connections to intermittent or perennial streams, which account for more than 51% of the nation's wetlands.