4 ms·
Trump has rolled back a lot of things, yes, but a lot of the Obama-era rules were vast overreaches. Ask yourself how agencies like the EPA managed to find new s
by rayiner 7y ago
Trump has rolled back a lot of things, yes, but a lot of the Obama-era rules were vast overreaches. Ask yourself how agencies like the EPA managed to find new sources of authority, like the authority to regulate ponds on farms, in 47-year old statutes?
Congress did not create the EPA as an agency that has plenary authority to regulate environmental issues. Such an agency would not be constitutional, because it would involve wholesale delegation of Congress’s legislative powers to the executive branch. Instead, the Clean Water Act, Solid Waste Disposal Act, Clean Air Act, etc., created specific programs to address specific types of environmental harms. The EPA is only supposed to be administering the programs Congress created.
Congress should be updating these laws to address new types of issues, but it’s not. It’s not because Republicans don’t care about these issues, and Democrats aren’t willing to spend the political capital to make these issues a priority. Whatever the reason, however, that doesn’t mean it’s okay for agencies like the EPA to creatively interpret statutes to expand their powers into new areas.
- foota 7y agoActually, it's exactly because Republican law makers by and large don't give a shit (especially the Senate)
- DuskStar 7y ago> Congress should be updating these laws to address new types of issues, but it’s not. It’s not because Republicans don’t care about these issues, and Democrats aren’t willing to spend the political capital to make these issues a priority. Whatever the reason, however, that doesn’t mean it’s okay for agencies like the EPA to creatively interpret statutes to expand their powers into new areas. I read the GP's post as "It's not (updating laws) because Republicans don't care about these issues", which I have to agree with. (though with the caveat that Democrats don't care much, either)
- foota 7y agoI see, yeah that's the right reading.
- teclordphrack2 7y ago"ponds on farms" Do you even know what you speak of? You seem easily manipulated by propaganda! What you seem to be references are people in the mid west and rockies that were creating "ponds" that were multi 10s of acres large with depths of multiple feet if not 10s of feet deep. The tributaires to the Rio Grand are regulated by treaties with Mexico. If left to do this, as more and more did, the water sheds to the larger tributaries would dry up. The federal government has treaty laws that dictate certain water flow to mexico, ranges of water flow that we have not met in decades, RANGES OF WATER FLOW THAT WOULD STOP ILLEGAL MIGRATION across the rio grande. "Congress did not create the EPA as an agency that has plenary authority to regulate environmental issues" O K A Y, S L O W, P E R S O N. T A K E, A, P I L L. Congress regulates the EPA. If the EPA has authority to do anything then the current congress has allowed it! YOU ARE A LIAR AND AN IDIOT.