4 ms·
This seems like a bizarre point of view - AppKit may not be getting as much investment as some other elements, but the overall platform has received massive inv
by zepto 7y ago
This seems like a bizarre point of view - AppKit may not be getting as much investment as some other elements, but the overall platform has received massive investments.
What would Apple be doing differently if they weren’t hypothetically trying to hold back tools for thought?
- robenkleene 7y agoThe platform investment it's getting makes macOS more like iOS. Almost all of those changes simultaneously have an effect of making it difficult to develop powerful, platform-defining software for it. As I'm fond of pointing out, Sketch is the last major triumph of the Mac as a platform and it was released the year before the sandboxing requirement came to the Mac App Store. I'd argue there would be more Sketch like success on the Mac if Apple were trying to cultivate it as a platform for powerful software instead of actively hurting it. But that's what they’re doing by trying to make it like iOS, which is an OS that has produced no new industry-defining software like the desktop produced Adobe CS, MS Office, Ableton Live, and Sketch. If you don't think that's caused by Apple's policies than what do you think it's caused by? For the arguments that it is caused by Apple's policies, there's the two Thompson pieces I linked to above, and I cover more details myself in this piece https://blog.robenkleene.com/2019/08/07/apples-app-stores-have-failed-creative-apps/ https://blog.robenkleene.com/2019/08/07/apples-app-stores-ha...
- zepto 7y agoIt seems like what you and the linked piece are taking about are a narrow set of heavyweight old-school creative apps that are analog to the Adobe suite. I see how the App Store impedes existing apps of that kind, but the presence of newcomers like Pixelmator and Pixelmator pro seems to imply that it’s more about legacy than about anything fundamental. I also don’t see how this is about the wider category of ‘tools for thought’. MindNode for example is a world class tool for thought that thrives on the App Store too. Given these examples it’s hard to see how there is any general conspiracy against tools for thought, although I grant that meeting the needs of people like Adobe is a low priority.
- robenkleene 7y agoPixelmator was launched in 2007 and used the same strategy as Sketch, it’s similarly based on the AppKit frameworks that Sketch is based on. It would be great if Apple had continued to create those kinds of powerful APIs instead of say, bringing iOS share sheets to macOS. MindNode’s about page lists seven people. That’s pretty close to the maximum level of success Apple’s policies allow on their platforms. If you don’t care about ambitious apps sure, no big deal, but I care. Couple of other quick points: I’m less concerned about existing apps like Adobe (they’ll be fine), I want new apps that are powerful like those apps. Also, and this is pretty subtle, I don’t think there’s any kind of conspiracy here, I know I talk like it is, but I don’t think executives are sitting in a room saying let’s make our products bad for powerful apps, it’s more like indifference, and “hey iOS is making us so much money, why not just use that same stuff everywhere?” But an implication of that is it moves the Mac to a more iOS-like software market, and that’s a market that’s failed to produce technology that’s the same caliber as things like Adobe, Office, Ableton. Whereas what Apple was doing before the iPad was producing apps of that caliber with the OmniGroup’s apps, and Sketch.
- dannyow 7y ago@robenkleene I concur with your pov and re conspiracy to clear things up - the way you see things is more a result of the law of unintended consequences than anything else - right? One of those (partially at least) is IMHO the way swift makes apps unextendible when you compare it with the flexibility of objc app in this area and that's a huge part of creative search too.
- zepto 7y agoThese are fair observations, however your answer is too general to be informative. It seems like Apple has added a lot of powerful stuff - e.g. CoreML, ARKit, massive improvements to 3D apis etc, which makes the ‘share sheets from iOS’ comment seem like an inaccurate dismissal. Team size seems like an odd measure off success. If Apple is actually supporting the development of new tools, you would expect the team size for more powerful apps to go down, not up. It’s fair to say that the rise of iOS (and Android and the web) has drawn attention away from the Mac, but it’s not clear that this has anything to do with Apple investing in the Mac or not. The market isn’t just larger for Apple it’s larger for everyone else too, so that is going to guide everyone else’s strategies as well. What kind of apps of the caliber of the ones you list are missing? And what kinds of functionality should Apple have been investing in to enable them?