3 ms·
> I wonder how many of them would even care. This week the EPA dismantled the Clean Water Rule. This week, the EPA rolled back an Obama-era executive order int
by rayiner 7y ago
> I wonder how many of them would even care. This week the EPA dismantled the Clean Water Rule.
This week, the EPA rolled back an Obama-era executive order interpreting the Clean Water Act. Hard to see how rescinding a three year old executive order could “dismantle” a 47-year old statute.
The Obama-era interpretation was ridiculous on top of everything else. The Wikipedia article is actually pretty good:
> The Clean Water Act is the primary federal law regulating water pollution in the United States. The language of the Clean Water Act describes itself as pertaining to ‘Waters of the United States’. These the act defines as ‘navigable waterways’, which connects the act to constitutional authority to regulate interstate commerce. Two U.S. Supreme Court decisions, in 2001 and 2006, interpreted the law to include waters not presently navigable that were formerly navigable that might be readily dredged to be restored to navigation or be made available for navigation. The scope of these decisions cast into doubt lower court decisions interpreting the act’s authority to extend regulatory authority to streams, wetlands, and small bodies of water not navigable in the sense of the interstate commerce clause.
So the Clean Water Act says the EPA can regulate ”the waters of the United States,” which is defined consistent with “navigable waters,” contemporaneous with Congress’s Commerce Clause authority over navigable waterways. The Obama EO extended it to include even small bodies of waters like ponds, such that farmers would have to get EPA permits to make modifications on their own land that was nowhere near navigable waters.
Maybe we need a law that requires permitting of everything that could affect any body of water no matter how small, because it’s true that pollution can flow from such waters into navigable waters. Maybe there is a way to even make such a law constitutional (e.g. setting up state regulation of water bodies that fall outside the commerce clause). But the Clean Water Act is not that law, and the permitting framework under the CWA is not appropriate for farmers doing work on land far from rivers and lakes.
So just because farmers supported rolling back this rule, why would you assume they’d be okay with radioactive materials polluting their land? Is there any room in our politics to acknowledge that agencies sometimes overreach, and just because you want to push back on that overreach doesn’t mean you want get rid of the agency or long-standing laws entirely?
- hanniabu 7y ago> Is there any room in our politics to acknowledge that agencies sometimes overreach Yes, but what we're seeing under the current Trump administration isn't a "sometimes" thing. It's become an effort to systemically rollback as many regulations as they could in order to allow for greater profits. They have gutted anybody of power within the EPA and replaced then with pro-corporate drones and climate change deniers. > The new rules make it easier to take out protections for threatened animals and plants and allow federal agencies to conduct economic assessments when deciding whether to protect a species from things like construction projects in a critical habitat. The rules also remove tools used by scientists to predict future harm to species from climate change. [1] [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/24/5-major-trump-climate-rollbacks-you-might-have-missed-in-2019.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/24/5-major-trump-climate-rollba... > The White House and the EPA had tried to stop the report from being published. [2] [2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-water-foreverchemicals-idUSKBN1ZL0F8 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-water-foreverchemical... [3] https://www.voanews.com/usa/trumps-epa-moves-loosen-radiation-limits https://www.voanews.com/usa/trumps-epa-moves-loosen-radiatio... Note that these are just from the past few weeks. There has been much more over the past few years that you can google if you'd like to dig it up.
- rayiner 7y agoTrump has rolled back a lot of things, yes, but a lot of the Obama-era rules were vast overreaches. Ask yourself how agencies like the EPA managed to find new sources of authority, like the authority to regulate ponds on farms, in 47-year old statutes? Congress did not create the EPA as an agency that has plenary authority to regulate environmental issues. Such an agency would not be constitutional, because it would involve wholesale delegation of Congress’s legislative powers to the executive branch. Instead, the Clean Water Act, Solid Waste Disposal Act, Clean Air Act, etc., created specific programs to address specific types of environmental harms. The EPA is only supposed to be administering the programs Congress created. Congress should be updating these laws to address new types of issues, but it’s not. It’s not because Republicans don’t care about these issues, and Democrats aren’t willing to spend the political capital to make these issues a priority. Whatever the reason, however, that doesn’t mean it’s okay for agencies like the EPA to creatively interpret statutes to expand their powers into new areas.
- jcranmer 7y ago> So the Clean Water Act says the EPA can regulate ”the waters of the United States,” which is defined consistent with “navigable waters,” contemporaneous with Congress’s Commerce Clause authority over navigable waterways. The Obama EO extended it to include even small bodies of waters like ponds, such that farmers would have to get EPA permits to make modifications on their own land that was nowhere near navigable waters. That is a rather distorted view of the water. Note that the definition of "navigable waters" is explicitly laid out in the law (33 USC §1362 (7), for exact reference) as: > The term “navigable waters” means the waters of the United States, including the territorial seas. This has been generally interpreted to include at least pretty much all non-ephemeral streams in the US, and ephemeral waterways are rather more questionable. See, e.g., Rapanos v US, decided in 2006 (i.e., before Obama took office).
- rayiner 7y agoThat’s not a correct reading of Rapanos. Rapanos says that “the meaning of ’navigable waters’ in the Act is broader than the traditional understanding of that term, SWANCC, 531 U. S., at 167; Riverside Bayview, 474 U. S., at 133.3 We have also emphasized, however, that the qualifier ’navigable’ is not devoid of significance, SWANCC, supra, at 172.“ Rapanos doesn’t define exactly what navigable waters are, but casts sharp doubt on two types of waters: ephemeral streams, and wetlands without a surface water connection to navigable water. The key changes to the 2020 rule are to exclude those things: https://www.eenews.net/stories/1062159101 https://www.eenews.net/stories/1062159101 > Specifically, the new rule will erase protections for so-called ephemeral streams, which flow only after rain or during snowmelt. > The rule also erases protections for wetlands that do not have surface water connections to intermittent or perennial streams, which account for more than 51% of the nation's wetlands.
- cptskippy 7y agoThe media spin of and your account, while different, are both very different from what I hear from my partner the environmental engineer. The media would lead you to believe farmers have stock piles of 50 gallon chemical drums they're waiting to pour into our lakes and streams. My partner's take is that a wetland, natural or otherwise is a protected habitat that can't just be destroyed. Farms have such wetlands and land developers are finding they can't just buy up farm land and plop developments on it due to wetlands. That seems to make the most sense to me being that Trump is a developer.
- rayiner 7y agoJust because wetlands should be protected doesn’t mean that they are protected under the Clean Water Act. (Congress doesn’t have the authority to regulate every body of water in the US. It’s limited to regulating the “channels of interstate commerce.”) States can, and do, regulate intrastate wetlands. And they can do it more efficiently, because they already handle permitting of local construction projects.
- cptskippy 7y agoIt's actually up to the Army Core of Engineers to determine if a wetland is under the CWA. They aren't blanket included or excluded.
- rayiner 7y agoThe Army Corps of Engineers makes decisions on individual wetlands, but they have to follow the statutory definition in the Clean Water Act. (And the Clean Water Act can only be interpreted in a way consistent with the Constitutional limits on Congress’s power to regulate intra-state activity.)
- cptskippy 7y agoSo what exactly are you arguing? The CWA stipulates what is covered and the Army Core of Engineers is responsible for interpretation. My point was that the rules rollback wasn't about farmers wanting to pollute or regulation of water ways, but rather about eliminating restrictions and regulations that inhibit land development on wetlands. Nothing you have said challenges that assertion, you just seem to be hung up on whether or not the Fed has the right to regulate something.