3 ms·
On the other hand, there was Jerry William McDonald who got stranded a few years after the Kim family, also in Oregon [1]. He did stay with the car, and died of
by tzs 7y ago
On the other hand, there was Jerry William McDonald who got stranded a few years after the Kim family, also in Oregon [1]. He did stay with the car, and died of starvation and/or hypothermia after 70 days in the car.
At some point trying to walk out, as bad as that is, gives you a better overall chance of surviving than waiting for rescue. The trick is figuring out when that is.
I've heard of only one incident where the stranded people had no trouble with making that decision. They were stranded in a well stocked RV, in a place they knew they were very likely to be found except by a search party specifically looking for them. They had satellite radio and TV, and so were able to watch the news reports about the search, and see when the search was called off, and so it was now either walk out or try to survive the entire winter there. They successfully had someone walk out.
[1] https://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-northwest-news/2011/05/man_found_dead_in_truck_after_getting_stuck_in_snow_spending_nearly_70_days_in_remote_linn_county.html https://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-northwest-news/2011/05/ma...
- watersb 7y ago^likely^unlikely Thanks for this story. I wonder what I would do.
- mike_d 7y agoI used to do Search and Rescue and I can absolutely tell you in all cases the best thing to do when lost is to stay put. Unless you are in immediate danger, or can move to a high point to get a cell signal but remain within visual range of your car/tent/etc. don't leave. SAR teams only have the resources to search a relatively small area (dozens of square miles at most), so if you start wandering off from your point last known (which we determine based on interviews with people with knowledge of your plans, tire tracks, open gates, cell phone pings, and other clues) you are removing yourself from the area where professional searchers and first responders are looking for you. Your time should be spent trying to create a signal. Make a small fire that you can keep under control and burn rubber/plastic to create dark smoke. Lay out reflective materials. Whistle, clap, or yell every 15 minutes. Keep listening for rescuers calling out.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoYour justification assumes you're being searched for. If you learn that the search has been called off, is it still always better to stay put?
- AstralStorm 7y agoA generic signal like smoke could work even when explicit search is called off. In this specific case, broken down car has gasoline and battery and even good fuel source (foams will a lot of smoke and thanks to fire retardant will burn long), making a fire is quite trivial with such means.