4 ms·
From the article: “They can test for GMO (genetically modified organisms) … but corn that’s not GMO, you can’t tell whether it’s been sprayed or not sprayed.”
by Animats 7y ago
From the article: “They can test for GMO (genetically modified organisms) … but corn that’s not GMO, you can’t tell whether it’s been sprayed or not sprayed.”
"Technically, you can, but you’re not likely to get a positive result unless the inspector hits it just right and collects a plant sample before the residues wash away."
Yes. See this Forbes article. By the time it reaches retail, you can't tell.[1]
Non-organic food is probably healthier. Less insect residue. Also cheaper.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevensavage/2016/02/08/inconvenient-truth-there-are-pesticide-residues-on-organics/#77b077dd683b https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevensavage/2016/02/08/inconve...
- ajross 7y ago> Non-organic food is probably healthier. Less insect residue. Sorry, is "insect residue" a term of art? Any why would a bug's "residue" be unhealthy, exactly? (In particular in a way that would survive routine washing in a way that a pesticide would not?) I'd ask for a citation, but... yeah. You just made that up, right? None of that should be taken as a particular defense of the US organic food regulation regime, which is indeed a big mess. But what you wrote was just silly.
- ahopskin 7y agoWhy the fuck is this downvoted? This site has rapidly decayed from mere crap into absolute trash it seems.
- m463 7y ago> Non-organic food is probably healthier. Less insect residue. Not a foregone conclusion. Reading the Forbes article, I wonder if the studies took organic food fraud into account, possibly even from Randy Constant. Also, there are a lot of interests - very well funded interests - downplaying glyphosate and other herbicides/insecticides. The net effect would be to make non-organic food seem costly with fewer benefits.
- seattle_spring 7y agoThere are also a lot of well funded interests who stand to gain an enormous amount of money from vilifying GMOs: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-otc-masstorts/doj-charges-roundup-plaintiffs-lawyer-in-200-million-alleged-extortion-scheme-idUSKBN1YM2L9 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-otc-masstorts/doj-charges... Let's not pretend that "organic" is simply synonymous with altruism. It's a huge, huge industry.
- nine_k 7y agoI buy organic fruit and vegetables, but not because I care about pesticides too much. Mainstream vegetables and fruit are optimized for looks and for shelf life (which measures in many months for much of produce). Taste takes the back seat. Organic produce is expected to have a shorter shelf life, smaller size, and some visual imperfections, because of how it's marketed. It can compete on taste, though. And noticeably tastier it is. Organic produce does cost a bit more (sometimes quite a bit). But eating untasty vegetables and plastic-feeling fruit is unpleasant, so I just avoid it, missing all the health benefits. Tasty organic produce does not have this problem :)
- DavidVoid 7y agoThe point of organic food was never for it to be healthier though right? From my understanding, it was pretty much always about reducing the use of synthetic fertilizers and -pesticides in order to increase (or at least not reduce) biodiversity in farmland wildlife.
- hedora 7y agoYou certainly can test for some non-organic foods at retail. For example, non-organic oats are often sprayed with roundup at harvest time, so cereals made from them routinely have unsafe levels of carcinogens in them: https://www.ewg.org/childrenshealth/monsanto-weedkiller-still-contaminates-foods-marketed-to-children/ https://www.ewg.org/childrenshealth/monsanto-weedkiller-stil... Organic oats have less than 1/10th as much roundup in them on average: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/pesticides-in-organic-oatmeal-oat-products/ https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/pesticides-in-organic-oatmeal-... Also, the more farms go organic, the less contamination there will be in the organic crops.
- saalweachter 7y agoNote the use of glyphosate as a dessicant is highly regional -- it's common in the Dakotas, Saskatchewan and UK because they have growing seasons that are too short for the crops being grown, but nearly unheard of in places like Iowa and Indiana, because the growing season is long enough for grains to mature and dry before the weather turns.
- jerry1979 7y agoCertain pesticides may hurt farm workers by causing cancer. Whether those chemicals get washed away or not does not change anything for the workers. Also, why is it important that non-organic produce be just as healthy as organic produce?
- defterGoose 7y agoWait, do you really think that "insect residue" is a bigger health risk than carcinogenic pesticides? Seems pretty far-fetched.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cortesoft 7y agoThere is also no way to test your shoes to see if they were made by child labor... does that mean it is totally fine to not worry about the labor practices of companies making shoes? The appeal of organic is (at least in part) that it is better for the environment and the farm workers... that isn't something that shows up directly in the end product, because they are externalities. That doesn't mean it isn't important.
- loeg 7y agoWhy not go full Godwin and compare non-organic product to the Nazis? The comparison is about as apt as to child labor.