3 ms·
Good luck. We may constantly decry the erosion of privacy on HN, but I guarantee you that the populace at large (like 95%+), even if they may sometimes complain
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
Good luck. We may constantly decry the erosion of privacy on HN, but I guarantee you that the populace at large (like 95%+), even if they may sometimes complain about a lack of privacy, also generally really like the stuff that personalization provides. People (again, the vast populace at large) make their purchasing decisions based on things like price and perceived quality; privacy considerations are a distant follow up. Why do you think the ad-supported web is the dominant model in the first place? Because to most users it feels like "free", because the stuff they're giving up (like privacy and the cost of advertising baked into things they buy) isn't readily apparent.
Privacy is a concern that really doesn't matter much, until it does. For other concerns like this it seems like regulation is the only thing that works. For example, insurance companies are highly regulated because the default risk of an insurer is something so amorphous for the average consumer to determine that it's basically impossible for them to judge on their own. So that's when government steps in and says there are basic standards an insurance company must adhere to to operate at an acceptable level of risk. I feel like that's the same for privacy. The average user isn't really able to comprehend, or value, the gradual long term effects of privacy erosion, so that's where the government steps in to demand all players must have basic standards.
- bobthepanda 7y ago> Because to most users it feels like "free", because the stuff they're giving up (like privacy and the cost of advertising baked into things they buy) isn't readily apparent. This is currently because the internet treats data collection as an "opt-out" feature, if you're even allowed to do that. Changing the law so that it is "opt in", and via a mechanism that is clear to a layman, might significantly change that for people. Wasn't that the point of GDPR, anyways?
- shadowgovt 7y agoAnd it does not seem to have succeeded, If the mass proliferation of cookie tracking warnings is any indication.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoCounterpoint, robo-call/text laws do influence some companies. I worked with one who required double opt-in for text to avoid getting blacklisted.
- shadowgovt 7y agoPeople actually hate robocalls and unsolicited texts, because they are an inconvenience. Cookie tracking is transparent and doesn't bother most of the populace; In fact, what bothers them is being annoyed by nagging cookie tracking notifications.