4 ms·
I think that a better solution, at HN scale, would be to limit the number of downvotes in a 24 hour period. Not clear what the ideal number is; maybe 5 at 500
by samatman 7y ago
I think that a better solution, at HN scale, would be to limit the number of downvotes in a 24 hour period.
Not clear what the ideal number is; maybe 5 at 500 karma, and 5 more per 500, possibly up to some limit (25?).
Otherwise, 'you must provide a reason' is trivially gameable, it just means downvotes are two clicks instead of one.
I suspect that the recent trend to low-quality downvotes is because 500 is a relatively low threshold with as much traffic as HN gets these days, and we have a bunch of newbs who were champing at the bit to inflict some punishment and go nuts with it when they get the ability.
Limiting downvotes at first would train users to be more thoughtful in what they censure; eventually the limit becomes no practical barrier, but hopefully by then the habit is established.
- dbattaglia 7y ago> Otherwise, 'you must provide a reason' is trivially gameable, it just means downvotes are two clicks instead of one. I’d think if your reply was something low quality you’d end up with more downvotes than the parent you just down voted. Or am I misunderstanding something? My experience on HN is that getting 500 karma was not easy; it’s quite hard to get submissions past “new” and comment karma takes some time to accumulate. I think it took me about 7 years! Perhaps others have an easier time.
- samatman 7y agoI'm not on lobste.rs, so I could be getting this wrong. But I believe the system is that you have to choose a reason for downvoting, which is shown to the person you downvote, but that you're not required to reply to the post, and the user doesn't know who in particular did the downvoting.
- laumars 7y agoI'm not on lobste.rs either and if that's their system then that's not entirely what I had in mind. I'd want voting to be first class comments. That way bad moderation surfaces quickly and can be moderated on itself -- thus pushing the abuser below the threshold for access to negative voting. One thing I think HN does really nicely is that you cannot down vote someone who's replied to your comment. Only 3rd parties can. That too can be abused if there's an argument between 3 people but it's still a better system than not having one at all.
- detaro 7y agoHas the downside though that now a genuinely bad comment takes much more space in the comment section, because of all the comments necessary to justify its downvotes, and all the comments arguing with those comments (I'd expect that to descend into flamewars very quickly).
- laumars 7y agoThat is certainly one possible outcome. However HN already supports tools to minimize the pain there via comment folding and/or hiding down voted comments (the option for that is in your profile). Optimistically speaking another outcome is also possible, fewer people feel the need to down vote comments so topics where people are using moderation to suppress an unpopular opinion (rather than moderate an objectively bad comment) might see fewer flamewars. Of course incorrect posts should still receive moderation but this also ensures that errors are accompanied with corrections -- which doesn't always happen at the moment. HN's moderation system certainly isn't the worst I've seen. Far far from it!! But I do think now is a golden opportunity to review it's moderation system to see if any tweaks could enhance the experience. Doing nothing is sometimes just as bad as doing the wrong thing. :)
- ecliptik 7y agoThe Slashdot karma system sort of had something like this. It’s been a few years, but comments weren’t given point totals but tags like “insightful”, “funny” for positive or “troll” for negative. This way a comment had feedback on why it was ranked higher or lower. A moderator only had so many points to give for a limited period of time as well as other guardrails. In order to get mod status you had to do things like history of reading comments in articles and posting articles and comments which in turn had high marks. This made a positive feedback loop where more positive participation gave more chances for mod status. See: https://slashdot.org/moderation.shtml https://slashdot.org/moderation.shtml On top of that there’s a meta-moderation system where in turn mods in comments are evaluated if they were modded fairly or not. If marked fair the original mod got more karma, and less if deemed unfair. https://slashdot.org/story/99/09/07/155233/slashdots-meta-moderation https://slashdot.org/story/99/09/07/155233/slashdots-meta-mo... I don’t know if such a system can exist in modern day, but out of all comment systems I always found the Slashdot style both simple and fair for the complexities of large comment volumes.
- danaris 7y agoThey did also have point totals, but a given comment could only range from -1 to +5.
- yborg 7y agoThis is a very good idea, and I think the quota should be even lower. I also think the old Slashdot mechanic of allowing a set of tags on user mod votes is useful to provide additional feedback.
- a3n 7y ago> 5 at 500 karma Wow, someone would use 5 downvotes in 24 hours? I think I may have downvoted all of 5 to 15 times in all my time here. My "downvotes" are merely not upvoting, due to indifference or some flavor of distaste.