2 ms·
I agree the author lost their argument partway through, and I would have made the point a bit differently. Broadcast TV and radio signals are not secure, and d
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I agree the author lost their argument partway through, and I would have made the point a bit differently.
Broadcast TV and radio signals are not secure, and don't need to be. Their information is supposed to be available for everyone. If someone hijacks a radio station, the worst they can do is spread disinformation, and there are easier ways to accomplish that.
Similarly, if all a website does is display text that is designed to be visible to everyone, a secure protocol is unnecessary.
IMO, http pages which lacks input fields and other forms of two-way communication should not receive an insecure warning. By contrast, if there's an input field, there's a good chance the user expects what they're writing to be private.
- mixedCase 7y ago> the worst they can do is spread disinformation From a seemingly reputable source that people trust. Now take a 4chan prank like the home grown crystals and put it on a site like the NHS'. Grab one of the blogs of these people who post about https not being necessary and if they have any tutorial where they have terminal snippets to copy and paste you can own their reader's machines. There are so, so many ways to do mischief if not outright ruin the lives of people in these websites that "just display text".
- pixl97 7y ago>Similarly, if all a website does is display text that is designed to be visible to everyone, a secure protocol is unnecessary And how is the browser supposed to figure that out? If I can edit your data stream I can load up inline javascript that could add data submission in very hard to figure out ways. Secure protocols dont just encrypt, they authenticate the originality of the data (at least from the https instance it was sent from).
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI should have added Javascript to the list of things http sites shouldn’t be able to do without triggering a browser warning. If it’s just a document/markup format, the warning strikes me as unnecessary. Mind, I realize that wouldn’t apply to many sites today.