2 ms·
> First, where is he getting that car commuters outnumber rail commuters (just barely) in New York? Last I heard the split was 60/40 in favor of rail. He's get
by jcranmer 7y ago
> First, where is he getting that car commuters outnumber rail commuters (just barely) in New York? Last I heard the split was 60/40 in favor of rail.
He's getting that number from American Community Survey data, and it's including the full MSA, which includes the entirety of Long Island and half of New Jersey, even if you don't work anywhere near NYC itself. The 60/40 split you're talking about is more representative of the mode share for people who live in NYC proper.
> Second, where did he get that it is unusual for management to not use a car? Rather famously Bloomberg himself used to commute to city Hall by subway.
He's talked with several staff at the NYC MTA, and it's fairly well-known that most of the upper management at the MTA don't use its own services. Bloomberg is an exception, not the rule.
> Fourth, he clearly used New York metro area, not the city proper in his calc. Can I get some footnotes on if the cross comparison did the same thing to other cities?
The author does spend a lot of time trying to compare like-to-like. Official city boundaries are notoriously bad indicators of urbanization--Staten Island is basically a suburb within NYC boundaries, to say nothing of places like Houston, while Boston and Washington, D.C. have core parts of their key business districts just outside official boundaries. The official metric that tends to be most comparable across countries is various approximations of the MSA.