4 ms·
I fact checked some of it. His source for the 2009 reading numbers is this report (which he linked to): http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2011/2011004_1.pdf http://nces.ed
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I fact checked some of it. His source for the 2009 reading numbers is this report (which he linked to): http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2011/2011004_1.pdf http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2011/2011004_1.pdf
I checked 5 of the numbers on his first chart against table R1 in the official report. They all agreed. I checked the 2009 numbers in his second chart against table R3. They also agreed.
I'm curious - Sailer links to his source. It took me 3 minutes to find the relevant data. Why didn't you do this yourself? Why insinuate bias on his part, rather than simply attempting to determine for yourself if he is lying?
- philwelch 16y agoI get the rhetorical point of asking these questions, but we both know the answer to them. Racism isn't a socially acceptable intellectual position, so people who express racist ideas only deserve outright dismissal. Actual corroboration and fact checking are only done when you take an argument in good faith. Likewise, the characterization of scientific racism as "white supremacism" or of VDARE as a "hate group" means belief in statistical differences between different races is the moral equivalent of being a neo-Nazi. Even if your very own arguments better suggest Chinese supremacism than white supremacism.
- ahi 16y agoThere's no such thing as "scientific racism" since race is a social construct.
- philwelch 16y agoFirst, race isn't purely a social construct. Obviously race is determined, at least partially, by ancestry and physical appearance, both of which are things science is fully capable of empirically measuring. The common conception of race is probably too flawed and inconsistent to use for scientific purposes, and most contemporary mainstream scientists who study human genetics don't use the word "race", but it's not a completely arbitrary and unfounded concept. If it was, public health offices wouldn't use it to narrow down which groups of people are at greater risk for genetic conditions like sickle cell disease. Second, even if there is no scientific validity to the concept of race (and there very well may not be), I think everyone knows what the term "scientific racism" means. So I don't see the constructive point in your comment. My point is that there's a distinction between arguing about IQ statistics and burning crosses in people's front yards; I think you're using rhetorical tricks to undermine that point rather than arguing against it directly.