2 ms·
> Many physicists believe that GR, as well confirmed as it is, can't be the final fundamental theory of gravity because it's not a quantum theory. But nobody ha
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> Many physicists believe that GR, as well confirmed as it is, can't be the final fundamental theory of gravity because it's not a quantum theory. But nobody has yet found a quantum theory of gravity that (a) is consistent with the rest of quantum mechanics
It was my (lay) impression that we believe general relativity cannot be the final fundemental theory of gravity because general relativity itself is not consistent with quantum mechanics. Whether general relativity is a quantum theory or not is beside the point; we want to have a theory -- any theory -- that is consistent with itself. Right now we have two separate theories (general relativity / quantum mechanics) that can't be combined because they conflict with each other.
Obviously, that in itself doesn't prove that the problem is in the theory of gravity, but it does prove the problem is either in the theory of gravity or the theory of quantum mechanics, and we have to be getting one of them wrong.
- pdonis 7y ago> It was my (lay) impression that we believe general relativity cannot be the final fundemental theory of gravity because general relativity itself is not consistent with quantum mechanics. That's the same as "not a quantum theory", which is what I was saying. "Consistent with quantum mechanics" requires "is a quantum theory", according to the many physicists I was referring to. > Right now we have two separate theories (general relativity / quantum mechanics) that can't be combined because they conflict with each other. Most physicists believe that they conflict, yes. But not all. Freeman Dyson, for example, has speculated that gravity might just be different and not require a quantum theory the way the other interactions do.
- ncmncm 7y ago> the problem is either in the theory of gravity or the theory of quantum mechanics, and we have to be getting one of them wrong. Not true: we could also be getting them both wrong.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThere is no way to be getting both of them wrong but not be getting one of them wrong.
- syockit 7y agoPedantically that is true, but you should still word it as "at least one of them" to avoid being misunderstood.