3 ms·
This structure seems like it should not be stable. If the middle part were not centered, it would be gravitationally attracted to the ring.
by phkahler 7y ago
This structure seems like it should not be stable. If the middle part were not centered, it would be gravitationally attracted to the ring.
- bmgxyz 7y agoIt seems the story of how this galaxy formed remains unknown. > Many of the details of the galaxy remain a mystery, foremost of which is how it formed. So-called "classic" ring galaxies are generally formed by the collision of a small galaxy with a larger disk-shaped galaxy. [...] However, there is no sign of any second galaxy that would have acted as the "bullet", and the likely older core of Hoag's Object has a very low velocity relative to the ring, making the typical formation hypothesis quite unlikely. [...] > A few other galaxies share the primary characteristics of Hoag's Object, including a bright detached ring of stars, but their centers are elongated or barred, and they may exhibit some spiral structure. While none match Hoag's Object in symmetry, this handful of galaxies are known to some as Hoag-type galaxies. I offer no hypothesis of my own (not least because this is outside my field), but it does seem odd to me as well. Is it possible that our mechanical intuition fails at such a large scale?
- phkahler 7y agoMy completely speculative thought is that a smaller galaxy rotating the other direction collided near the center. The angular velocities cancelled in the inner region and that all collapsed to a dense slower core. That just seems unlikely, but then again it's an unusual galaxy.
- ur-whale 7y ago>This structure seems like it should not be stable Mmmh ... not sure that you can easily apply intuition to N-body problems.
- mcguire 7y agoSure you can. The intuition is that they're not stable. The ones that are, are special cases.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIf I understand correctly, the middle part far out-masses the ring. If the middle part were not centered, then the ring could continue to peacefully orbit it, as the planets orbit the sun, even though their orbits are not (quite) centered on it.
- phkahler 7y agoOk, then the ring would be pulled in. But only to the extent that it behaves like a solid which it isnt.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]