2 ms·
Well, isn't that special. Let's try this a different way. 1) "As soon as a player can’t perform at a high level anymore, they’re gone." Who defines what "hig
by eesmith 7y ago
Well, isn't that special.
Let's try this a different way.
1) "As soon as a player can’t perform at a high level anymore, they’re gone."
Who defines what "high level" means?
Most jobs are a mix of skills. Someone just starting may be good at cranking code. Someone with more experience may be good at avoiding dead ends, and providing advice to get those beginners up to speed. Someone with more leadership skills may be good at management. Someone with more people skills may be a low performer by most labor measurements, but great at building team cohesiveness - a catalyst, to use a chemistry term.
2) "Then there are the companies which let older employees linger due to seniority instead of phasing them out as their performance drops."
This is the Silicon Valley disease. Let someone else train people, pay them a lot, burn them out, then get rid of them like the worn down parts they are.
Again, how is "performance" measured?
From what I've read, seniority systems can arise when it's hard to figure out who is good or bad. Is there a 10x commercial airline pilot? If 99+% of flights are routine, and trained for, then how do you tell who those 10x pilots are?
3) "There must be no doubt in anyone’s mind that performance is what is valued throughout the organization."
Again, how is "performance" measured?
4) "If you’re the GM or CEO, this cultural message needs to [... be ...] People are paid on the value of their performance, nothing else-full stop."
Which backfires in the face of hypocrisy. How many millions did the ex-CEO of Boeing get paid upon leaving the company after this recent fiasco?
How is the CEO's performance measured, and why is that measurement different than how the rest of the employees are measured?
5) "This also means that there will be a large discrepancy in salaries, bonuses, options and rewards."
You know, I've got no problem with that. I just want all that information - yes, including salary and income for each employee - to be public data.
6) "no one should care if you’re the biggest asshole on the planet."
Except for jobs where team cohesiveness is an important factor. I don't want to work with asshole, I'm good enough at what I do that I can quit if I'm forced to work with an unrepentant asshole.
7) "like putting down a once-prized stallion that can no longer stud"
We are all but meat widgets to the all-important corporation. Hail capitalism!
8) "implement a stack rank and tell me what happens?"
The company goes to the crapper, a la "Microsoft's Lost Decade"? - https://www.vanityfair.com/news/business/2012/08/microsoft-lost-mojo-steve-ballmer https://www.vanityfair.com/news/business/2012/08/microsoft-l...
That's behind a paywall. Alternatives at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/microsoft-throws-employee-stack-ranking-out-window-steffen-maier https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/microsoft-throws-employee-sta...
> Going forward, the system would focus on how employees collaborated with each other. Performance reviews wouldn’t just be focused on how well the employee did, but how they engaged with their peers around them.
https://www.businessinsider.com/stack-ranking-employees-is-a-bad-idea-2013-11?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/stack-ranking-employees-is-a...
> The use of stack ranking, which has been almost ubiquitous at large companies for years, has recently plummeted, since many companies now realize it can actually hurt performance.
- ksaj 7y agoI'm reminded of the song "As Tears Go By" from Marianne Faithful. From when she first recorded it, until her last performance of it, there were very notable differences in her singing, and the overall sound of the song. It went from sad and thoughtful to utterly depressed and desperate, depending on which versions you heard. But there was change, nonetheless. A lot of it. The most obvious is the pitch and speed - she started singing it in a fairly clean high register at a particular beat, but by the end of her career her voice was very deep and raspy, and the song was performed a lot slower. Despite significant change in her singing, nobody ever said she and the song got better, or worse. They just kept some sort of honest likable quality, and it got more dramatic as the years went by. Pretty much as forecast by the song itself. The lack of acceptance for change existed back then, but she lucked out and was surrounded by grace. It's just more "in your face" as the Internet tends to be nowadays. Change isn't allowed so much because we constantly click on the next big thing. Any amount of change like that in a musician today would be considered unacceptable and buried under loads of competition and "us and them" mentalities.