6 ms·
I think a better question that isn't asked is the following: Has Google created a market for ads where non would exist if they simply provided only organic resu
by ineedasername 7y ago
I think a better question that isn't asked is the following: Has Google created a market for ads where non would exist if they simply provided only organic results?
By this I mean that it's possible the main reason Google Ads are useful for companies is because Google has reinforced a sort of negative Nash equilibrium by allowing competitors to squat on organic results by purchasing ads against those better results. I.e. So the best organic results lose user share & clicks because Google lets competitors set ads against them. Given this situation, those targeted by their competitors have no choice but to try & outbid their rivals. Meaning Google Ads are only useful to companies because they exist at all, and assuming minimal gaming of the organic results system with SEO, both companies and users would be better off if there were no ads and the best most relevant results won out on their own merit.
- oehpr 7y agoIf you put the question to people "Would you have an easier time finding good products and services if there were no advertisements?" I think the majority of people would answer "no". It's sad state of affairs we're in if we can't even imagine finding out about something without that knowledge being forced down our throats.
- feanaro 7y agoI haven't seen an internet ad in years due to using uBlock Origin with very strict block lists. I feel like I find products and services I need effortlessly. Am I missing something?
- oehpr 7y agoYes. We are discussing googles advertising, and the strategic decisions it forces on companies operating within googles context. And in my post more generally, how that same game plays out in wider society, and with the general public We are not discussing your personal advertising experience. Nor even the general technocratic audience of HN's advertising experience.
- feanaro 7y agoI'm aware the overall discussion was not about my personal preferences, so it should hopefully be clear this is not what I was asking. The context (set by the OP of this branch) is also that perhaps there is a case of perverse incentives going on, one where we have reached an unhealthy, but relatively stable equilibrium of the majority having the impression of needing Google ads where there would be no such need if they didn't exist. You responded by saying the majority would indeed confirm that they would not want to be left without ads (an unsubstantiated but plausible claim). But there are clearly people who choose to opt out of ads completely, myself included, and I don't see myself as missing out on anything. So I'm asking whether I am missing out on something.