4 ms·
Stupid title, but interesting article. They try to use radioactive Carbon-14 to make diamonds to produce heat in a RTG power source. Obviously it doesn't have
by gus_massa 7y ago
Stupid title, but interesting article. They try to use radioactive Carbon-14 to make diamonds to produce heat in a RTG power source.
Obviously it doesn't have near infinite power. The amount of power will be very small, but it may be useful for some applications. Also, the half-life of C14 is 5750 years, so after a few milenia it will need a replacement.
- montalbano 7y agoIndeed the title is not great. I assume that by 'near infinite power' they mean in duration, not magnitude.
- macawfish 7y agoLiterally the inverse of power!
- darkarmani 7y ago> "Primarily though, they are best for devices requiring long lifetime, low power and where it is difficult to replace energy sources." Infinite power or low power? I think they mean infinite energy. As in "The power went out".
- juancn 7y agoIt's a lot anyway. Although peak power is not great. Over 5000 years the output would be a few tera Joules of energy. The first prototype used nickel-63 (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diamond_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diamond_battery) It could be interesting coupled with an ultra-capacitor, if you have something that has sporadic high energy demands, but not always. Think a remote sensor, or pace maker, or such devices that need a short spike of power, but on average the energy requirements are not huge.
- wlesieutre 7y agoPower is a measure of energy per time, so to get nitpicky about it that's the equivalent of saying "near infinite speed" about something that goes a mile per hour for a few thousand years. It'll cover some distance, yeah, but it's not what I'd call speedy.
- m4rtink 7y agoI guess you would not get much power given the long half life (as the stuff decaing is what gives you power and this thing doesn not decay a whole lot), but it will give you that power level for quite a while.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jarfil 7y agoHalf-life means that after 5750 years half of it will have decayed, then half of that in another 5750 years, half of what's left in another 5750 years, and so on. That's about 20000 years for still 10% of the original power output, and it won't go totally dead for some million years more.
- irjustin 7y agoYes, but it's the operational energy that he's talking to and it's even shorter than that. If the power output is expected to be 1000W, usually you design the system to utilize all of it. So as the power starts to degrade, even when you're really far from the half life, it may not be enough to power the systems. Specifically, the Voyager's RTGs have degraded a lot since Pu-238's half life is much shorter[0], but most of the machine's systems can't run at ~67% power. We're basically down to the very last few experiments running intermittently. So for useful energy, parent comment is largely right. You've got <5750 yrs of usable work, which is absolutely fantastic. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator#Life_span https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_ge...
- robinduckett 7y agoNo chance of using some sort of capacitor or staged voltage operation so different components deactivate as the power degrades?
- ryanmercer 7y agoYou'd have to design a capacitor, or the equivalent, that could last thousands of years for stuff that you can't service (like a space probe). That is a pretty big ask for many materials in general. Right out of the gate aluminum electrolytic capacitors are out as getting 10-20 years out of consumer grade ones is pretty good. I have a single monitor I've replaced caps in 3 times now (and they weren't even a known bad batch) in the past 10 years. Electrolytic caps will go bad even faster if they aren't regularly receiving electricity, many have a 2 year shelf life. If you've ever plugged in a vintage electronic (say an Atari/Commodore computer) and you've had smoke-like stuff come out, that's usually the electrolytic capacitors going. If you open up an old device that has had one or more fail, you'll find this brownish-black stuff all over the insides after they go. Most super-capacitors would die from use long before useful power output, they're usually good for a million cycles or less so even at one cycle a day you're only looking at 2700 years and change. Polymer electrolytic capacitors are good in use for 10-15 years. Pretty much every capacitor out there right now has a 5-15 year lifespan.
- juancn 7y agoIt's not an RTG, it's a betavoltaic device. They directly convert the beta radiation to electricity, using a semiconductor also made of carbon.
- exposay 7y agoIt will likely end up in a landfill after a year or 2.
- dang 7y agoOk, we've stripped the title of near-infinite power above.
- hinkley 7y agoI can't hear 'carbon-14' without thinking of archaeology. Archaeologists of 3020: We carbon dated this object, and it comes from the future.