5 ms·
The ACA mandates the maximum [maximum out-of-pocket] that an insurance plan can require. There's no such thing as good or bad insurance when it comes to extrem
by colechristensen 7y ago
The ACA mandates the maximum [maximum out-of-pocket] that an insurance plan can require. There's no such thing as good or bad insurance when it comes to extreme medical events. "Good" or "bad" depends on how much of your premium your employer covers and how expensive it is when you only use a little bit of medical services.
The worst-case max out of pocket for any insurance plan in 2020 is:
$8,150 for self-only coverage
$16,300 for family coverage
In America, it is important to have liquid savings to handle life events like losing a job or a serious health issue. We get taxed less, have fewer safety nets, so we need to build our own safety net. You can argue that one way is better than another way as a big picture, but many people misconstrue the individualist vs. collectivist societies as a serious moral issue instead of a choice. Some of the details of each can be serious moral issues, but the big picture is simply a difference in priorities.
Bottom line: If you can come up with $16k/year to cover medical expenses for a serious issue, you won't go bankrupt.
- duxup 7y agoThe maximum limit is just ... the maximum limit. How / when you might hit it is an unknown from plan to plan for the reasons I noted.
- colechristensen 7y agoIn / out of network is not relevant to max out of pocket.
- duxup 7y agoIn / out of network can dramatically impact what you pay out of pocket.
- colechristensen 7y agoNot if you hit the max. If you hit the max it is irrelevant, I am talking about hitting the max and going bankrupt.
- duxup 7y agoAt this point I'm not at all sure what this concept of hitting the max means as far as your response to my comment. The costs of a given hospital visit is still an unknown leading up to the max... and how quickly you hit it is an unknown... and thus actually finding "descent insurance" is not easy. As far as I can tell you seem to just be hooked on this concept that after you hit the max you're not paying and that somehow means something. Perhaps you feel that hitting the max is a trivial thing?
- aggie 7y agoThis thread is discussing the astronomical costs you would expect from robot-assisted quarantine procedures for infectious disease. That would be a case where the max out of pocket is what is relevant to consider.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vkou 7y agoIf you hit the max, you can still be billed over the max. https://time.com/5555988/medical-bills-out-of-network/ https://time.com/5555988/medical-bills-out-of-network/ This lady had insurance, and yet was stuck with a $227,000 'balance bill'. I'm no mathematician, but $227,000 seems to be a bit higher than the 8.5k max that this thread keeps citing.
- colechristensen 7y ago25 of 50 states ban the practice, in the rest you are responsible for negotiating and fixing the billing discrepancy. This kind of issue should be taken into account when choosing an insurance plan. If you choose one which has a restricted network, you have to be more diligent about where you get your care in emergencies. Medical billing is nonsense though. Just because someone sends you a bill does not mean you owe it or will ever have to pay it. This is one of those details and rare occurrences which get way out into the weeds and doesn't really support the argument of which type of health care your country should provide. There are similar edge cases in social medicine where some situation or another is appalling. Extreme cases need to be handled, but unless they are common, they shouldn't drive the debate.
- vkou 7y agoMost people who can't come up with $16k/year in rainy day money don't actually benefit from lower taxes on the rich, because they are in the lower income brackets.
- colechristensen 7y agoIt isn't lower taxes on the rich, its lower taxes on the middle income. For example, the French tax bracket for income between $28k and $81k* is 30% In the US the rate in that bracket is 12% up to $39k and 20% after. If I did my math right that averages to 18%. That isn't high income earners saving on taxes, that's a 40% lower marginal income tax rate for the middle class in the US vs. France. There are also many other sources of tax outside income which are different and higher in countries with social medicine. * converted from EUR to USD (taxation is complicated and making apples-to-apples comparisons is hard. it is easy to argue about fiddly details and hard to avoid a long list of caveats)
- vkou 7y agoThat net difference of 12% of your income will be completely eaten by the premiums of the cheapest, crappiest insurance plan you can buy in the US. Just the premiums - I'm not even talking about the co-pays for actually getting care (which are quite high on those plans.) The poor and lower middle class aren't in any better position to save tens of thousands of dollars for medical emergencies, despite the lower taxes. Lower rates don't help, when your income is low. And in California, that difference is a lot less than 12%.
- CraigJPerry 7y agoDoes that continue to year 2 after a huge claim or would the insurance price increase in year 2 to make up the expected gap the 16k limit might suggest to the prospective insurer?
- jdlshore 7y agoNo, premiums don’t increase. The ACA prevents insurance companies from considering medical history when pricing insurance.
- kayodelycaon 7y ago> If you can come up with $16k/year to cover medical expenses for a serious issue, you won't go bankrupt. The US median income is $63k... $16k would be 25% of that.
- lwhalen 7y agoIndeed, and do you know what kills you faster and more reliably than lack of free/subsidized medical care? Lack of food (9 days), and lack of potable water (72 hours). Since we seem to be leaning towards the opinion that the gov't needs to provide everything for us and we should have minimal/no responsiblity for our own sustenance, repair, or longevity, where's the Free Sh*t Army slogans for no-cost food and water?
- voxic11 7y agoThe US had a pretty extensive foodstamps program. It still exists but is slowly getting killed off. Even so there are multiple states in which 20% of the population has their food paid for by the government.
- lexs 7y agoThat's a rather polemic way of talking about this topic. No one but a strawman actually talks about "free shit" or "no-cost", it is about social distribution of burdens for these extreme cases. Paying a reasonable price for drinkable water through i.e municipal water companies seems to fit your "responsibility" requirement. Paying 25% or more of your _yearly_ income for a medical bill because you had bad luck...not so reasonable in my opinion and has nothing much to do with "responsibility". And let's not pretend it is about no costs or free things, everyone is paying for it through taxes according to their means. Are you seriously suggesting to let someone on disabilities or social security starve to death cause those are essentially your "no-cost food and water" slogans. This notion of "having the government provide" shows the twisted view on government, it's not a separate entity the money comes from society, society is providing, is that such a bad thing for a society?
- lwhalen 7y ago
- Gibbon1 7y ago> We get taxed less My friends from other countries say, not really when you add everything. Then add the US's system of 'private taxes' which drive up the cost of things like health insurance, schools, etc.