6 ms·
The assumption seems to be that you can transfer mass and energy into information in a way that subtracts from total mass+energy of the system but still shows u
by nabla9 7y ago
The assumption seems to be that you can transfer mass and energy into information in a way that subtracts from total mass+energy of the system but still shows up when weighed.
To test the hypothesis it's not enough just to weigh the memory. You must ensure that the energy stored in the memory has not been increased, because energy increases the weight of the memory device. (relaxed spring weighs less than tensed spring, storing energy in capacitors increases the weight of the memory).
The paper:
https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.5123794 https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.5123794
>Here we formulate a new principle of mass-energy-information equivalence proposing that a bit of information is not just physical, as already demonstrated, but it has a finite and quantifiable mass while it stores information.
(...)
>Assuming that all the missing dark matter is in fact information mass, the initial estimates (to be reported in a different article) indicate that ∼10^93 bits would be sufficient to explain all the missing dark matter in the visible Universe. Remarkably, this number is reasonably close to another estimate of the Universe information bit content of ∼10^87 given by Gough in 2008 via a different approach.12 In fact, one could argue that information is a distinct form of matter, or the 5th state, along the other four observable solid, liquid, gas, and plasma states of matter. It is expected that this work will stimulate further theoretical and experimental research, bringing the scientific community one-step closer to understanding the abstract nature of matter, energy and information in the Universe.
ps. AIP advances is so called scientific mega journal. It has very low selectivity and don't select articles based on importance. They are "peer reviewed" only in the lowest criteria possible.
- choxi 7y agoNewbie question, would this imply that there's something like an "information particle"?
- krastanov 7y agoNot in any of the usual meanings of "particle" (an "excitation of a quantum field", which of course is not a particularly elucidating explanation if you are lacking context).
- mojomark 7y agoIn Light Emitting Diodes, electrons move across the electron transport layer, while "hole" particles move through the hole transport, where they meet at the heterojunction to combine and emit photon particles. Holes aren't really like other atomic particles, rather they represent the lack of an electron in an energy field that has an affinity for electrons. But it's still a type of manifestation of energy (or lack thereof), thus represents a unit of mass (albeit negative), which effectively signifies the presence of a manipulatable minute piece of negative matter - the definition of a particle. So, I don't see why you couldn't use the particle label when referring to information. How about an "infon"?
- krastanov 7y agoYes, holes exist and are a useful formalism. But you are wrong, holes very much behave like other elementary particles (pseudo-particles), and you get to call these things particles, exactly because they behave like excitations of a field. If you insist, sure, you can make up an infon and call it a particle. However, it would not behave like anything a physicist would call a particle, nor would it use any of the mathematical tools that were developed to deal with particles, nor it would provide any useful intuition or insight, nor would it provide any pedagogical value. And at that point why bother calling it a particle if it does not behave like one.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]