4 ms·
What's missing is a $/kwh quote. It's important because renewables are the cheapest option on the market right now and nowhere near done dropping further in pri
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
What's missing is a $/kwh quote. It's important because renewables are the cheapest option on the market right now and nowhere near done dropping further in price.
If the last ten years are any indication, an order of magnitude further drop in prices before the end of the decade is not unreasonable considering mass production of batteries, solar, and wind is still ramping up and considering the enormous amount of R&D currently being spent on reducing cost and increasing efficiencies further.
In the UK it's going to be hard to compete with wind (Scotland exports more of that than its total energy consumption already) and people installing solar panels on their roof and putting batteries in their house and cars (which can power a house for several days).
- wazoox 7y agoNo, renewable are incredibly expensive, on the contrary. Why is that? Because renewable produce when wind blows or sun shines, and not when we need power. That's the first point, we need to produce exactly as much energy as we consume, at any time. Renewables fail utterly at that, and that's why renewable energy appears so cheap when you simply consider the price at which it's sold on the markets: production occurs at random times when it isn't needed, pushing market prices down in the toilet. But that's an undesirable side-effect, and not a good thing. Renewable produces only a fraction of their nominal output (typically 15-20%), and at random times. So typically a huge, sprawling 12km2 900MW solar plant produces a small amount of power during the year, in the best case (in the desert) 1.4TWh, while a 900MW nuclear reactor produces typically (actual numbers) 6.5TWh every year. You also need to complement renewable production with an equivalent amount of steerable power (usually natural gas), or a large amount of batteries which multiplies the price by 5, 10 or more. So you can't consider the renewable price alone; you must take into account the price of the substitute power source, too... And its environmental price! So renewable energy is cheap because it isn't worth much. It puts extra pressure on the grid, it forces nuclear plant to run at reduced capacity, which reduces the yield, and artificially lowers their profitability for no good reason at all. In fact, renewables, by reducing profitability of nuclear power, has another very undesirable side-effect: making nuclear power companies cut corners on safety to save money. Renewable power is better than coal; but it isn't, by large, as good as nuclear.
- fsh 7y agoDo you have any sources for your claim of batteries multiplying the cost for renewables by "5, 10 or more" in a realistic grid scenario? Did you take into account that most energy storage is done with hydro, not batteries? I haven't had time to carefully review the literature, but there seem to be quite a few papers that claim that storage for a 100% renewable grid would not be such a big issue.
- wazoox 7y agoBasically renewables produce 15-20% of the time (30 to 40% for offshore wind). Let's be generous and start with 30% of the time. You need storage to provide 70% of the demand. So for every GWh or required power, you need 700MWh of storage. The famed Tesla Mega battery is a puny 129MWh... You must account for the fact that there could be no sun or no wind for several days, therefore be able to store incredible amounts of power, far beyond the scale we know of.Then the sheer space required for renewable power is staggering. As I said, the biggest solar plants are 600MW to 1GW and occupy tens of square km. Now imagine supplying 10s of GW this way. As someone joked on twitter, if you covered the whole Fukushima exclusion zone (250 km2 or so)with solar panels, it wouldn't come close to the Daishi nuclear plant annual power output. For a detailed discussion on these matters, see https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/100-renewable-electricity-at-no-extra-cost-a-piece-of-cake/ https://jancovici.com/en/energy-transition/renewables/100-re...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fsh 7y agoYour calculation does not make much sense (GWh isn't even a unit of power). One would have to look at actual power production and consumption curves in order to estimate the required storage capacity. Battery storage is still very exotic, pretty much the entire capacity is provided by hydro nowadays. Current-gen solar panels average about 30 W/m² over the year in Japan's latitude and climate. So a solar park the size of the Fukushima exclusion zone would produce around 7 GW on average which is more than the combined nameplate capacity of the six reactors (5.3 GW). Supplying the entire country with electricity (~114 GW) would require about 3800 km² of solar panels, or about 1% of Japan's area.
- consumer451 7y ago> What's missing is a $/kwh quote. And if we are being honest, why not include total cost of ownership in the $/kwh. As far as I know this is an impossible calculation for any current nuclear reactor technology.
- ctdonath 7y agoI'm running on partial "utility solar". Cost varies wildly over the year, from 1x to >3x vs regular electric; average is 1.5x ... but that's with a reliable instant backup supply for every second solar supply is insufficient vs demand. During summer, I run my office 100% solar. It's a fun exercise, but it's deeply reliant on batteries. Storage capacity is a cliff: run out of stored power, you're done. This "brick wall effect" is grossly under-appreciated by solar proponents. There's a funny thing about supply-and-demand: so long as supply is sufficient, costs are reasonable; when supply actually hits zero, and demand isn't zero, economic badness follows. Solar hits zero daily; batteries have a hard limit of a few hours/days.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoYou can solve that by installing more solar. Also, if you have an EV, it comes with a (typically 60kwh) battery. If you have the right systems installed, you could power your house from that for a few days. For reference, e.g. a tesla powerwall would come in at only 13.5 kwh (i.e. less than 25%) and you could buy a more expensive EV with 75kwh or even more. So, you could power your house using your car for a while. If you have the square meters, you could install enough solar to charge that battery capacity. It's just a matter of what still makes sense in terms of cost. Doing stuff like this is currently expensive but will eventually drop in price to the point where it stops being a cost reducing supporting technology and can actually become your main source of energy together with maybe a more expensive option as an emergency fallback based on some grid level solution (wind, more solar, tidal power, nuclear even, gas, etc). It's just a matter of $/kwh of battery & solar panels. Both are still coming down in price. The reason people are putting this stuff in their homes is that they are already on the right side of that price compared to the grid.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoThey can't provide the $/kwh quote because it's not even an implemented technology yet...it's a propositional technology and they can't even provide a quote that solar/wind could smash easily in the majority of markets.